Matthew · Gospels & Acts

Matthew 23

Jesus pronounces seven woes on the scribes and Pharisees and laments over Jerusalem.

Nazareth, about 1,150 ftDown from Nazareth to the Sea of Galilee (Matthew 4:13), about 21 milesCapernaum, about 650 ft below sea level

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–7Moses’ seatHear the Law they read, not the lives they lead
  2. 8–12One TeacherAmong disciples, greatness is service
  3. 13–15Shutting and recruitingFalse religion keeps people out and makes them worse
  4. 16–22Blind guides and oathsGod is behind every oath
  5. 23–24Mint, dill, and cuminNeglecting the weightier matters
  6. 25–28Cup and tombClean outside, dead inside
  7. 29–36Tombs of the prophetsThe blood of the prophets comes due
  8. 37–39Lament over JerusalemGrief, refusal, and a house left desolate

The chapter in brief

Jesus turns from His questioners to the crowds and His disciples. The scribes and Pharisees sit on Moses’ seat, so do what they teach, “but not the works they do. For they preach, but do not practice.” They tie up heavy burdens for others, do their deeds to be seen, and love the best seats and the title “rabbi.” Disciples are to take no such titles, for they have one teacher, one Father, and one instructor, the Christ. Then come seven woes: they shut the kingdom in people’s faces, make converts twice as much a child of hell as themselves, split hairs over oaths, tithe herbs while neglecting justice, mercy, and faithfulness, clean the outside of the cup, are like whitewashed tombs, and build monuments to the prophets their fathers killed. The chapter ends in lament: “O Jerusalem, Jerusalem,” and the sentence that the house is left desolate.

This is the hardest speech in the Gospels, and it is spoken by the gentlest voice. The same Jesus who pronounced blessings on the mountain (5:3-12) now pronounces woes in the temple, and the woes fall on the people who had the Scriptures and used them to keep others out. These woes are spoken by Israel’s Messiah to Israel’s leaders, as the prophets spoke before Him; they have sometimes been turned into contempt for Jewish people, which they never warrant. Their sharpest edge falls on anyone, church leaders first, who uses God’s Word to load and exclude others. Yet the chapter does not end in anger but in tears. The One who denounces is the One who longed to gather Jerusalem’s children as a hen gathers her brood. He is the one Teacher who does what He teaches, the Servant who humbled Himself and will be exalted, and within days He will bear, for all who shelter under Him, the judgment their sin deserves.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–7

Moses’ seat

“Do and observe whatever they tell you” seems to clash with Jesus’ warning against the leaven of their teaching (16:12) and their traditions that void God’s command (15:3-6). The key is the seat. Insofar as they sit on Moses’ seat, reading and teaching Moses, their teaching carries his authority; where they add their own burdens, it does not. Some synagogue remains include a stone seat that may have been called by this name, though the evidence is debated. The broad phylacteries (boxes of Scripture worn at Deuteronomy 6:8) and long fringes (Numbers 15:38-39) were God’s own reminders turned into display.

For discussion

How do we tell the difference between honoring the Scripture a leader teaches and excusing the way he lives? Consider 1 Timothy 3:1-7.

vv. 8–12

One Teacher

Jesus is not banning the words “father” or “teacher” (Paul calls himself a father in 1 Corinthians 4:15). He is banning the rank. The church has one Father in heaven and one Instructor, “the Christ,” and all the rest are brothers. Verse 12 is the shape of the gospel itself: whoever exalts himself will be humbled, and whoever humbles himself will be exalted. Philippians 2:5-11 shows it fulfilled first in Christ, who humbled Himself to death and was highly exalted.

vv. 13–15

Shutting and recruiting

Some later manuscripts add another woe at verse 14 about devouring widows’ houses (compare Mark 12:40); the ESV places it in a footnote, leaving seven. The first two woes name the double harm of false religion: it will not enter the kingdom and blocks the door for others, and its zeal for converts makes them “twice as much a child of hell.” Energy is not evidence of truth.

vv. 16–24

Oaths and the weightier matters

The scribes graded oaths so that some could be broken: swear by the temple and it counts for nothing, swear by its gold and you are bound. Jesus answers that every oath is finally sworn before God, who dwells in the temple (vv. 21-22), which is why He told His disciples to let their yes be yes (5:33-37). The tithe on mint, dill, and cumin went past what the law required, yet “justice and mercy and faithfulness” were left undone. Note “These you ought to have done, without neglecting the others”: Jesus does not despise small obedience but its replacement of the great. Straining a gnat and swallowing a camel is a joke about two unclean animals (Leviticus 11:4, 41), the smallest and the largest.

vv. 25–28

Cup and tomb

The cup is clean outside and full of greed inside; the tombs are whitewashed and full of bones. Tombs are often said to have been whitewashed before the feasts so pilgrims would not touch them and be defiled (Numbers 19:16). The image inverts that: the Pharisees are the uncleanness, and they are painted to look attractive. Jesus’ remedy is to clean the inside first (v. 26), which only God can do (Ezekiel 36:25-27).

vv. 29–36

Tombs of the prophets

Building memorials to murdered prophets while saying “we would not have taken part with them” is the easiest kind of righteousness, because the prophets are dead. The span from Abel to “Zechariah the son of Barachiah” covers the whole record of martyrs. The Zechariah named in 2 Chronicles 24:20-22 is the son of Jehoiada, while the prophet Zechariah is son of Berechiah (Zechariah 1:1); readers have proposed that Jehoiada was a grandfather, or that the prophet himself is meant. The point does not depend on settling it. “This generation” (v. 36) will receive what the whole history has stored up.

vv. 37–39

The lament

The judge weeps. The image of the hen gathering her brood under her wings draws on the shelter of God’s wings in the Psalms (Psalm 91:4; Ruth 2:12), so Jesus speaks as the Lord who has sent the prophets. “And you were not willing!” holds God’s longing and human refusal together without explaining one away. “Your house is left to you desolate” anticipates chapter 24, and Jesus walks out of the temple in the next verse. Yet the last word is “Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord” (Psalm 118:26): the door is not bolted for anyone who will receive Him.

For discussion

How does Jesus’ grief over Jerusalem sit with God’s sovereign purpose in His death (Acts 2:23; Acts 4:27-28)?

Threads across the chapter

  • Outside vs. inside. Broad phylacteries, the clean cup, and the whitewashed tomb all show a righteousness that is visible and empty (vv. 5, 25-28).

  • Blindness. “Blind guides” and “blind fools” run from the oaths to the gnat and the cup (vv. 16-26), and blindness is worst in those who claim to lead.

  • Exaltation and humbling. The leaders who love the first seats (vv. 6-7) stand against the One who humbles Himself and is exalted (v. 12), and whose departure leaves their house desolate (v. 38).

  • The Word used as a weapon. Those who sit on Moses’ seat load burdens on others (v. 4) and shut the kingdom (v. 13), the very misuse this commentary refuses.

Key words

23:13
ὑποκριτής hypokritēs“Hypocrite”; originally a stage actor, one who plays a part behind a mask
23:10
καθηγητής kathēgētēs“Instructor”; the one title Jesus reserves for Christ alone
23:23
βαρύτερα barytera“Weightier matters”; justice, mercy, and faithfulness as the heavy center of the law
23:38
ἔρημος erēmos“Desolate”; a cognate of the word in “the abomination of desolation” in 24:15

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why might Matthew place the seven woes right after Jesus has silenced every questioner in chapter 22?

  2. 2

    What is the difference between keeping the small commands and letting them replace justice, mercy, and faithfulness?

  3. 3

    Where are we most tempted to clean the outside of the cup: in our homes, our church, or our reputation?

  4. 4

    How can a church honor its teachers without giving anyone the place that belongs to the one Teacher?

  5. 5

    What does Jesus’ weeping over the city that would kill Him teach us about how we should speak of those who reject Him?

My notes