John · Gospels & Acts

John 5

Jesus heals a man at the pool of Bethesda on the Sabbath and claims equality with the Father.

Jerusalem, about 2,450 ftFrom Judea through Samaria to Cana in Galilee (John 4:3-4, 46), about 69 milesCana, about 900 ft

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–9aThe pool of BethesdaJesus heals a man who could not help himself
  2. 9b-18The Sabbath charge“My Father is working until now, and I am working”
  3. 19–24The Son and the FatherEqual honor, perfect dependence, life now
  4. 25–29The hour of resurrectionThe Son’s voice raises the dead, now and at the end
  5. 30–40The witnessesJohn, the works, the Father, and the Scriptures
  6. 41–47Moses as accuserMoses wrote of Him

The chapter in brief

At a feast in Jerusalem, Jesus comes to the pool of Bethesda by the Sheep Gate, where many invalids lie. He singles out a man who has been sick for thirty-eight years and asks, “Do you want to be healed?” The man complains that he has no one to put him in the pool, and Jesus says, “Get up, take up your bed, and walk.” He is healed at once. But it is the Sabbath, and the authorities challenge him for carrying his mat; later Jesus finds him in the temple and warns him to sin no more, and the man reports Jesus to the leaders. When they persecute Jesus for working on the Sabbath, He answers, “My Father is working until now, and I am working,” and they seek all the more to kill Him, because He was making Himself equal with God. Jesus then lays out His relation to the Father: the Son does what He sees the Father doing, gives life to whom He will, and has been given all judgment, so that all may honor the Son as they honor the Father. He calls His witnesses: John the Baptist, His own works, the Father, and the Scriptures, which bear witness about Him, though His hearers refuse to come to Him that they may have life.

This is the chapter where open conflict begins in John, and it begins over who Jesus is. The healing on the Sabbath is the occasion; the claim behind it is the issue. Jesus does not defend Himself by lowering His claim but by raising it: He does what only God does, giving life and judging the world. The Son’s equality with the Father and His perfect dependence on the Father stand together, and the one way from death to life is to hear His Word and believe the One who sent Him. Even the Scriptures can be studied in a way that misses Him.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–9a

The pool of Bethesda

Excavations north of the temple have uncovered a large double pool matching John’s description of five colonnades, a detail that once seemed doubtful and now fits well. The ESV omits verse 4 (an angel stirring the water), which is missing from the earliest manuscripts and is given in a footnote; the man’s own words in verse 7 show the belief that grew up around the pool. Notice that this man shows no faith before the healing. Jesus chooses him out of many, asks a question he answers with a complaint, and heals him with a command. Grace here is entirely unprompted. Thirty-eight years echoes the years Israel wandered until the faithless generation died (Deuteronomy 2:14), though John does not press it.

vv. 9b-15

“Sin no more”

Carrying a mat on the Sabbath broke the tradition built around Jeremiah 17:21-22. Later Jesus tells the man, “See, you are well! Sin no more, that nothing worse may happen to you.” This does not mean all sickness is punishment for a particular sin; Jesus denies that plainly about the man born blind (9:2-3). It does mean that sin’s consequence is worse than thirty-eight years of illness: the “something worse” is judgment. The man then reports Jesus to the authorities. Set him beside the blind man of chapter 9, who is thrown out for defending Jesus, and the contrast is deliberate.

For discussion

The man was healed by grace and yet seems to have shown no gratitude. What does that tell us about the difference between receiving a gift and receiving the Giver? Compare Luke 17:11-19.

vv. 17–24

The Son and the Father

It was common ground among Jewish teachers that God Himself keeps working on the Sabbath, sustaining the world, giving life, and judging. Jesus claims that same work as His own, and His hearers understand Him exactly: He is “making himself equal with God” (v. 18). He does not correct them. Instead He describes a Son who does nothing “of his own accord,” only what He sees the Father doing. That is not inferiority but perfect unity of will: the Son does whatever the Father does, gives life as the Father does, and is to be honored just as the Father is honored (v. 23). Honor owed to God alone cannot be given to a creature. Verse 24 brings it to the hearer: whoever hears His Word and believes “has eternal life,” not merely will have, and “has passed from death to life.”

vv. 25–29

The hour of resurrection

Two hours are in view. One “is now here”: the spiritually dead hear the Son’s voice and live (v. 25). The other is “coming”: all in the tombs will hear His voice and come out (vv. 28-29). Verse 29 says those who have “done good” rise to life and those who have “done evil” to judgment. That is not salvation by works. Verse 24 has already said how anyone passes from death to life: by hearing and believing. The good done is the fruit and evidence of that new life, the kind of deed “carried out in God” (3:21), not its price.

For discussion

How does the “now” of verse 25 change the way a believer faces the “coming” of verse 28? Consider Ephesians 2:4-6.

vv. 30–40

The witnesses

The law required two or three witnesses (Deuteronomy 19:15), and Jesus brings four: John the Baptist, the works the Father gave Him, the Father Himself, and the Scriptures. The last is the sharpest. “You search the Scriptures because you think that in them you have eternal life; and it is they that bear witness about me” (v. 39), “yet you refuse to come to me that you may have life” (v. 40). Diligent Bible study can be a way of avoiding the One the Bible is about. The Scriptures are a signpost, and it is possible to study the signpost and never take the road.

vv. 41–47

Moses as accuser

The leaders set their hope on Moses, and Jesus says Moses will be their accuser, “for he wrote of me.” Moses promised a prophet like himself (Deuteronomy 18:15-18) and wrote the whole story of promise from Genesis 3:15 on. The root problem is named in verse 44: they receive glory from one another and do not seek the glory that comes from the only God. Unbelief is not first an intellectual failure; it is a wrong love.

Threads across the chapter

  • Work and rest. The Sabbath charge (vv. 9b-16), the Father’s unceasing work (v. 17), and the works the Father gave the Son to accomplish (v. 36) all turn on what kind of work Jesus does.

  • Life from the Son. He gives a lame man strength (vv. 8-9), gives life to whom He will (v. 21), raises the dead by His voice (vv. 25-29), and is the life the Scriptures point to (v. 40).

  • Hearing His voice. Whoever hears His Word has life (v. 24), the dead hear His voice (vv. 25, 28), and His hearers have never heard the Father’s voice (v. 37).

  • Glory and honor. Honor the Son as the Father (v. 23), and the leaders seek glory from one another (vv. 41-44).

Key words

5:18
ἴσος isos“Equal”; the charge His opponents rightly understood Him to be making
5:22–30
κρίσις krisis“Judgment”; given wholly to the Son, from which the believer is already freed
5:31–36
μαρτυρία martyria“Testimony,” witness; the evidence God supplies for His Son
5:39
γραφή graphē“Scripture” (here plural, “the Scriptures”); writings that bear witness to Christ

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does the first open conflict in John’s Gospel arise from a healing rather than a sermon?

  2. 2

    How does Jesus show He is both equal with the Father and fully dependent on Him, and why do we need both to be true?

  3. 3

    What does it mean that a believer “has passed from death to life” already, and how should that shape the way we live now?

  4. 4

    How can we read the Bible faithfully and still “refuse to come” to Jesus? What would guard us against that?

  5. 5

    Jesus says unbelief is tied to seeking glory from one another (v. 44). Where does the desire for approval keep people from Christ today?

My notes