2 Samuel · Historical Books

2 Samuel 3

Abner defects to David but is murdered by Joab, and David publicly mourns him.

3:1

“There was a long war between the house of Saul and the house of David. And David grew stronger and stronger, while the house of Saul became weaker and weaker.”

2 Samuel 3:1, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1The long warSaul’s house weakens; David’s grows
  2. 2–5Sons born at HebronDavid’s household grows, with trouble ahead
  3. 6–11Abner’s quarrelA dispute over Rizpah turns Abner to David
  4. 12–21Abner’s covenantMichal returned; Israel’s elders persuaded
  5. 22–30Joab kills AbnerRevenge in the gate of Hebron
  6. 31–39David mournsThe king clears himself and grieves

The chapter in brief

The war drags on, and David grows stronger while Saul’s house weakens. Six sons are born to David at Hebron by six wives. In the north, Ish-bosheth accuses Abner of going in to Saul’s concubine Rizpah, and Abner, furious, swears to bring all Israel over to David and so accomplish “what the LORD has sworn to him.” David agrees on one condition: Michal, Saul’s daughter and David’s first wife, must be returned, and she is taken from her husband Paltiel, who follows her weeping to Bahurim. Abner persuades the elders of Israel and Benjamin and comes to Hebron, where David feasts him and sends him away “in peace.” But Joab returns from a raid, rebukes the king, calls Abner back, and stabs him in the gate of Hebron for the blood of Asahel. David declares himself and his kingdom guiltless, curses Joab’s house, makes Joab mourn, walks behind the bier, laments Abner, and fasts until sunset, so that all Israel knows the king had no part in it.

The kingdom is coming to David, but not cleanly. Abner, who knew all along that “the LORD has sworn” the kingdom to David (v. 9), comes over only when it suits him, and Joab removes him for revenge and perhaps for rivalry. David is innocent of the blood but cannot control the men around him: “these men, the sons of Zeruiah, are more severe than I” (v. 39). The chapter shows a king whose promise is from God and whose throne is surrounded by sinners, and it makes the reader long for a King who is not only innocent of violence but able to end it. The promise Abner quotes, “By the hand of my servant David I will save my people Israel” (v. 18), is fulfilled finally in the Son of David, named Jesus “for he will save his people from their sins” (Matthew 1:21).

Points for discussion

vv. 2–5

Sons born at Hebron

The list reads like a royal record, and it is also a list of coming sorrows: Amnon (13), Absalom (13-18), and Adonijah (1 Kings 1-2) will each tear at the kingdom. Six sons from six mothers recalls the law’s warning that the king “shall not acquire many wives for himself, lest his heart turn away” (Deuteronomy 17:17). Scripture records David’s many wives without approving them, as it does with the patriarchs; the rest of the book shows what such a household cost. Absalom’s mother is a daughter of the king of Geshur, a political marriage that will matter when Absalom flees there (13:37).

vv. 6–11

Rizpah and Abner

To take a dead king’s concubine was a claim on his throne (compare 16:21-22; 1 Kings 2:22), so Ish-bosheth’s question is about power, not only morals. We are not told whether the charge was true. Abner’s answer, “Am I a dog’s head of Judah?” shows a man who believes he is owed. His oath in verses 9-10 is revealing: he knew “what the LORD has sworn to” David, from Dan to Beersheba, and had fought against it anyway. Abner’s turn is not repentance; it is a strong man changing sides.

vv. 12–16

Michal returned

David demands Michal back, citing the bride-price he paid (1 Samuel 18:25-27). Saul had given her to Paltiel while David was a fugitive (1 Samuel 25:44). Some readers stress David’s legal right and the political value of a marriage into Saul’s house; others notice that Michal herself is never asked, and that the only person in the scene who weeps is Paltiel, following her “all the way to Bahurim.” Both are true. Scripture records the way kings treated women as pieces in a contest for power without commending it, and the cold scene between David and Michal in chapter 6 is part of the cost.

For discussion

Paltiel’s tears are recorded in a single verse. Why might Scripture take time to notice him?

vv. 22–30

Joab in the gate

Joab’s rebuke of David is bold: Abner came to spy on you. His deed is worse. He brings Abner back without the king’s knowledge, takes him aside “into the midst of the gate,” and strikes him in the stomach, as Abner had struck Asahel. But Asahel fell in battle after two warnings; Abner was a guest who had left “in peace,” a phrase repeated three times (vv. 21, 22, 23) to make the betrayal plain. Hebron was also one of the cities of refuge (Joshua 20:7), where a man who had killed was to have a hearing before the avenger could act (Numbers 35:12). Joab’s motive is called revenge (vv. 27, 30), though many readers suspect he also feared a rival for command of the army.

vv. 31–39

The king’s grief and the king’s weakness

David’s mourning is public and costly: sackcloth for Joab, the king walking behind the bier, a lament (“Should Abner die as a fool dies?”), and a fast. The people were pleased, “as everything that the king did pleased all the people” (v. 36), and Israel understood that Abner’s death was not his will. Yet David does not punish Joab; he curses his house and leaves vengeance to the LORD (v. 39), and the matter returns at the end of his life (1 Kings 2:5-6). Some read David’s restraint as weakness before a powerful general, others as a wise refusal to start a second civil war. Either way it shows the limits of David’s rule. Even a good king could not make his own house just. Christ’s kingdom is not built by men like Joab, and its King will judge every hidden act (Romans 2:16).

Threads across the chapter

  • What the LORD swore. Abner cites the LORD’s oath to David (vv. 9-10, 18), and the long war of verse 1 is that oath being worked out in history.

  • “In peace.” Abner leaves David “in peace” three times (vv. 21-23), and is killed in the gate (v. 27).

  • Blood. Asahel’s blood (2:23) is avenged in Abner’s (vv. 27, 30), and David declares himself guiltless of it (v. 28).

  • Women and power. Rizpah (v. 7), Michal (vv. 13-16), and the six wives (vv. 2-5) show how a king’s household and a king’s power were bound together.

Key words

3:12–13, 21
בְּרִית berit“Covenant”; the agreements Abner and David make, and Israel’s covenant with its king, under the larger promise God has sworn
3:8
חֶסֶד chesed“Steadfast love”; Abner claims to have shown it to Saul’s house, and abandons it in a day
3:21–23
שָׁלוֹם shalom“Peace”; the repeated word that makes Joab’s betrayal stand out

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Chapter 2 asked whether the sword would devour forever. How does chapter 3 answer that question, and what does it leave unresolved?

  2. 2

    Abner knew what the LORD had sworn to David and fought against it anyway. What does his change of sides show about the difference between switching loyalties and repentance?

  3. 3

    What do Michal and Paltiel’s story and the list of David’s wives show about how power treats people, and how does that challenge us?

  4. 4

    David mourns Abner sincerely but does not punish Joab. Where are we tempted to grieve a wrong without dealing with it?

  5. 5

    How does a king who cannot control his own commanders make us long for the kingdom of Christ?

My notes