2 Samuel · Historical Books

2 Samuel 4

Ish-bosheth is assassinated, and David executes the murderers for killing an innocent man.

4:11

“How much more, when wicked men have killed a righteous man in his own house on his bed, shall I not now require his blood at your hand and destroy you from the earth?”

2 Samuel 4:11, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–3Courage failsWithout Abner, Saul’s house collapses
  2. 4MephiboshethJonathan’s son is lamed in the flight
  3. 5–8The murder of Ish-boshethTwo captains kill their king for gain
  4. 9–12David’s verdictThe LORD needs no murderers to keep His promise

The chapter in brief

When Ish-bosheth hears that Abner is dead, his courage fails and all Israel is dismayed. Two of his raiding captains, Rechab and Baanah, Benjaminites from Beeroth, come to his house at the heat of the day while he rests, stab him on his bed, behead him, and travel all night to bring the head to David at Hebron, announcing that the LORD has avenged the king on Saul and his offspring. David answers with an oath by the LORD “who has redeemed my life out of every adversity,” reminds them what he did to the man who brought news of Saul’s death, and has them executed. Ish-bosheth’s head is buried in Abner’s tomb. In the middle of the chapter the narrator pauses to introduce Jonathan’s son Mephibosheth, lamed at five years old when his nurse fled with him on the day the news came from Jezreel.

The last obstacle to David’s rule over Israel is removed, and David refuses to profit from it. Twice now men have brought him a dead king expecting a reward, and twice he has answered with justice. The kingdom will not be taken by murder and credited to the LORD. David’s confession in verse 9 is the key: the LORD has redeemed his life out of every adversity, so David does not need wicked men to do it for him. The brief notice about a crippled boy, the last heir of Saul’s line, waits quietly for chapter 9, where grace will find him. Many readers see in that pairing the gospel’s own order: the King who will not grasp, and the helpless one He seeks out.

Points for discussion

v. 4

A boy who fell

The verse seems to interrupt the story, and that is its point. With Ish-bosheth about to die, the narrator names the only other surviving heir of Saul through Jonathan: a five-year-old, dropped in a panic and lamed for life. A crippled child could not be king in that world, so he was no threat, which is perhaps why he survived. The verse also prepares for chapter 9, where David will look for anyone left of Saul’s house to show kindness for Jonathan’s sake. His name, Mephibosheth, appears in 1 Chronicles 8:34 as Merib-baal, another name where bosheth, “shame,” seems to stand in for baal.

vv. 5–8

Murder in the heat of the day

Rechab and Baanah are Ish-bosheth’s own officers, from Beeroth, a town the narrator notes was counted part of Benjamin. They come “as if to get wheat” and kill him on his bed at noon. Their speech to David is a model of religious language used to cover a crime: “The LORD has avenged my lord the king this day on Saul and on his offspring.” They claim to be God’s instruments. David hears it for what it is.

vv. 9–12

“Who has redeemed my life”

David’s oath names the LORD as the One who has rescued him “out of every adversity,” through all the years of Saul’s pursuit. That is why he can refuse the gift. He reasons from lesser to greater: if he executed the man who claimed to kill Saul in battle, “how much more” those who killed “a righteous man in his own house on his bed.” Ish-bosheth is called righteous here in the sense of innocent of any crime against his killers, not as a verdict on his whole life. The punishment, cutting off hands and feet and hanging the bodies by the pool, is the harsh public justice of the ancient world, and Scripture records it. The law of Israel’s state has expired with that state (Westminster Confession 19.4), but the principle that murder must be answered by lawful authority, not by private ambition, stands (Genesis 9:6; Romans 13:4). David’s honor for Ish-bosheth’s head, buried in Abner’s tomb, finishes what his mourning for Abner began.

For discussion

The murderers dressed their crime in the language of God’s vengeance. Where do people still use God’s name to justify what they want? Compare Romans 12:19.

Threads across the chapter

  • Courage and its failure. Ish-bosheth’s courage fails (v. 1), while David speaks with confidence in the LORD who has redeemed him (v. 9).

  • Good news that is not. The messenger of Saul’s death “thought he was bringing good news” (v. 10), and so did the bearers of Ish-bosheth’s head (v. 8).

  • Saul’s house. The murdered son (vv. 5-7) and the lamed grandson (v. 4) are what remain of Saul’s line, one killed for gain and one kept for grace.

Key words

4:9
פָּדָה padah“Redeemed”; to ransom or rescue, David’s word for what the LORD has done for him through every danger
4:11
צַדִּיק tsaddiq“Righteous”; here innocent, a man who had done his killers no wrong
4:8
נָקָם naqam“Avenged”; the vengeance the murderers claim the LORD has taken through them

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why might the narrator place Mephibosheth’s injury in the middle of the account of Ish-bosheth’s murder?

  2. 2

    What does David’s oath in verse 9 tell us about why he could refuse a throne gained by murder?

  3. 3

    The murderers said, “The LORD has avenged my lord.” How can we tell when someone is using God’s name to cover their own aims?

  4. 4

    Where are we tempted to accept a good result that came by a wrong road?

  5. 5

    How does David’s refusal here point to the way Jesus refused to gain His kingdom by any means other than the Father’s will?

My notes