20:19
“I am one of those who are peaceable and faithful in Israel. You seek to destroy a city that is a mother in Israel. Why will you swallow up the heritage of the LORD?”
The chapter at a glance
The chapter in brief
A worthless man named Sheba, a Benjaminite, blows the trumpet: “We have no portion in David” (v. 1), and the men of Israel follow him, while Judah stays with the king. In Jerusalem David shuts away the ten concubines Absalom had taken, providing for them but never going in to them, so that they live “as if in widowhood” (v. 3). Amasa is sent to muster Judah and is slow, so Abishai is sent after Sheba. At Gibeon Joab greets Amasa, “Is it well with you, my brother?” takes his beard as if to kiss him, and kills him with a single stroke. Amasa’s body lies in the highway until it is dragged into a field and covered. Joab besieges Sheba in Abel of Beth-maacah, and a wise woman calls to him from the wall. She speaks for a city known for its counsel, “a mother in Israel,” and when Joab says he wants only Sheba, the people throw Sheba’s head over the wall. The revolt ends, and the chapter closes with a list of David’s officers, Joab back at the head of the army.
David is restored, but the kingdom is cracked. The north’s cry, “We have no portion in David,” will be heard again when the kingdom splits for good (1 Kings 12:16). Joab’s sword keeps the throne safe while staining it with a second treacherous killing. In the middle stands a woman who does what neither the king nor the general has done all book long: she makes peace by wisdom, sparing a city by giving up the one guilty man. Her peacemaking is a small light in a dark chapter (Matthew 5:9). It also leaves the reader longing for the King in whom Israel has a true portion, the Son of David who brings peace not by giving up the guilty but by giving Himself for them (Ephesians 2:14-16).
Points for discussion
vv. 1–2
“No portion in David”
Sheba is called a “worthless man” (beliyya’al), the same phrase Shimei threw at David (2 Samuel 16:7), and a name Paul later uses for the evil one (2 Corinthians 6:15). His rallying cry is short and memorable: “We have no portion in David, and we have no inheritance in the son of Jesse” (v. 1). It grows directly out of the quarrel at the end of chapter 19. A “portion” (cheleq) is a share in the inheritance. God’s people have always been taught that their truest portion is the LORD Himself (Psalm 16:5; 73:26), and in the New Testament, in Christ, the Son of David, they receive an inheritance (Ephesians 1:11). To say “no portion in David” is, in the end, to refuse that.
v. 3
The ten women
The narrator pauses on the concubines left behind in 2 Samuel 15:16 and taken by Absalom in 16:22. David provides for them but shuts them away, “living as if in widowhood” until they die. Readers differ on whether David did right by the custom of his day or added a second injustice to the first. Either way, these women were wronged by both father and son and had no say in any of it. Scripture does not forget them, and neither should we.
vv. 4–13
A greeting and a sword
Amasa is late, and Joab, demoted in Amasa’s favor (2 Samuel 19:13), meets him at Gibeon. “Is it well with you, my brother?” (v. 9). He takes Amasa’s beard in his right hand as if to kiss him, and the sword in his other hand does the rest. It is the same treachery he used on Abner at the gate of Hebron (2 Samuel 3:27). Many readers think of Judas, who came with a greeting and a kiss (Matthew 26:48-50). Amasa lies in the highway, and the army stops at the sight until someone drags him into a field and throws a garment over him (vv. 12-13). Joab gets results, and the narrator lets us see what kind of results they are. David will name both murders on his deathbed (1 Kings 2:5-6). Effective violence in a leader’s service is still violence, and a king who keeps such a man close shares the stain.
vv. 14–22
The wise woman of Abel
Joab’s men are battering the wall when a woman calls, “Listen! Listen!” (v. 16), and the general answers, “I am listening” (v. 17). She appeals to her city’s old reputation for settling disputes by counsel (v. 18), names herself “peaceable and faithful in Israel” (v. 19), and calls the town “a mother in Israel,” the title once given to Deborah (Judges 5:7). Her question puts Joab on trial: “Why will you swallow up the heritage of the LORD?” (v. 19). The law required Israel to offer peace before besieging a city (Deuteronomy 20:10), and it is she, not Joab, who does it. Her answer is hard but just: the one man guilty of rebellion is given up and the city is spared. Many readers set this beside the gospel, where the reverse happens: the innocent One is given up so that the guilty may live (John 11:50; Romans 5:8).
For discussion
The wise woman of Tekoa (2 Samuel 14) used her wisdom to manipulate a king; the wise woman of Abel used hers to save a city. What makes the difference between the two? Read James 3:13-18.
vv. 23–26
The officers
The list repeats much of 2 Samuel 8:15-18, as if the kingdom has been restored to order. But Joab is again “in command of all the army” (v. 23), not by appointment but by murder, and a new office has appeared: Adoram “in charge of the forced labor” (v. 24). Many readers note how that office will help break the kingdom in the next generation (1 Kings 12:18). Order has returned, but the seeds of the next crisis are already listed.
Threads across the chapter
Portion and heritage. Sheba’s “no portion in David” (v. 1) is answered by the woman’s “heritage of the LORD” (v. 19).
Greetings that kill. “Is it well with you, my brother?” (v. 9) recalls Absalom’s kisses (2 Samuel 15:5) and Abner’s death (2 Samuel 3:27).
Heads. Joab takes Amasa by the beard (v. 9), and Sheba’s head comes over the wall (vv. 21-22).
Women who pay and women who save. The ten women live as widows (v. 3), and the wise woman saves a city (vv. 16-22).
Key words
- 20:1
- בְּלִיַּעַל beliyya'al“Worthless”; a man of no worth, the word behind Paul’s “Belial” (2 Corinthians 6:15)
- 20:1
- חֵלֶק cheleq“Portion,” a share in the inheritance; the LORD is His people’s portion (Psalm 16:5)
- 20:19
- נַחֲלַת יְהוָה nachalat YHWH“Heritage of the LORD”; Israel as the LORD’s own inheritance, which Joab is about to swallow
Cross-references
- 1 Kings 12:16The same cry when the kingdom divides
- 2 Samuel 3:27Joab’s murder of Abner
- 1 Kings 2:5-6David names Joab’s murders of Abner and Amasa
- Matthew 26:48-50Judas betrays with a kiss
- Deuteronomy 20:10Offer terms of peace before a siege
- Judges 5:7Deborah, “a mother in Israel”
- Matthew 5:9Blessed are the peacemakers
- Psalm 16:5The LORD is my chosen portion
- 1
How does the quarrel at the end of chapter 19 lead straight into Sheba’s revolt?
- 2
What does the chapter want us to see in Joab, and why does David keep him?
- 3
How does the wise woman of Abel use her words, and what does she teach about making peace?
- 4
Where are we tempted to say, “We have no portion” in the people God has joined us to?
- 5
The woman saved her city by giving up the guilty man. How does the gospel turn that around?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.