2:26
“Then Abner called to Joab, ’Shall the sword devour forever? Do you not know that the end will be bitter? How long will it be before you tell your people to turn from the pursuit of their brothers?’”
The chapter at a glance
- 1–4aAnointed at HebronDavid asks the LORD and is made king over Judah
- 4b-7A message to Jabesh-gileadDavid honors loyalty to Saul
- 8–11A rival kingAbner makes Ish-bosheth king; Israel is divided
- 12–17The pool of GibeonA deadly contest begins a civil war
- 18–23The death of AsahelAbner kills Joab’s brother
- 24–32“Shall the sword devour forever?”A truce at sunset, and the cost counted
The chapter in brief
David does not march on the throne; he asks the LORD, “Shall I go up into any of the cities of Judah?” and is sent to Hebron. There the men of Judah anoint him king over the house of Judah. His first act as king is to bless the men of Jabesh-gilead for burying Saul. Meanwhile Abner, Saul’s commander, makes Saul’s son Ish-bosheth king at Mahanaim over Gilead, Ephraim, Benjamin and “all Israel,” and the nation splits. At the pool of Gibeon the two sides meet; a contest of twelve against twelve ends with all twenty-four dead, and a fierce battle follows. Asahel, Joab’s brother, swift as a gazelle, chases Abner and will not turn aside, and Abner kills him with the butt of his spear. At sunset Abner calls across to Joab, “Shall the sword devour forever?” and Joab sounds the trumpet to stop.
The chapter shows two ways a kingdom can be built. David waits on the LORD, is anointed by the people, and honors those who were loyal to his rival. Abner sets up a king by his own strength, and the result is brothers killing brothers. The sword that “devours” will become one of the book’s great themes (11:25; 12:10). David is a king in waiting, anointed but not yet ruling all Israel, and so a picture of the One whom God anointed and enthroned, who still waits for the day every enemy is put under His feet (Psalm 110:1; Hebrews 10:12-13), and whose kingdom brings the peace that the sword never could.
Points for discussion
vv. 1–4a
David inquires
The opening words, “After this David inquired of the LORD,” set the pattern for the first half of the book (5:19, 23). David is already anointed by Samuel (1 Samuel 16:13), but he does not take the kingdom by force when Saul dies; he asks where to go and goes. Hebron is no accident. It is where Abraham bought the field and cave to bury Sarah (Genesis 23) and the city Caleb claimed in faith (Joshua 14:13-14). Judah, the tribe of the scepter (Genesis 49:10), now anoints its king. This is the second of David’s three anointings (1 Samuel 16:13; 2 Samuel 2:4; 5:3): God’s choice, then Judah’s recognition, then all Israel’s.
vv. 4b-7
Blessing the men of Jabesh
Saul had once rescued Jabesh-gilead (1 Samuel 11), and its men repaid him by taking his body from the wall of Beth-shan at the risk of their lives (1 Samuel 31:11-13). David blesses them for the “loyalty” they showed, the word chesed, and prays that the LORD will show them “steadfast love and faithfulness,” the same word again. Some readers see shrewd politics here, an approach to a town loyal to Saul. That may be part of it, but David’s praise of covenant loyalty, even loyalty to his rival, is real, and it anticipates his kindness to Saul’s house in chapter 9.
vv. 8–11
A divided kingdom
The real power in the north is Abner, who “took” Ish-bosheth and “made him king.” His name was probably Eshbaal (1 Chronicles 8:33), “man of Baal” in the sense of “the lord’s man”; the writer of Samuel seems to have replaced baal with bosheth, “shame,” as also happens with Mephibosheth (compare 1 Chronicles 8:34, Merib-baal). The two numbers in verses 10-11 do not obviously line up: Ish-bosheth reigns two years, David seven and a half in Hebron. Many explain it by a delay of some years before Ish-bosheth was made king while Israel recovered from the Philistines, or by a gap after his death before the northern tribes came to David; the text does not say.
vv. 12–17
The pool of Gibeon
Abner proposes that the young men “compete before us,” as if war were a game. The contest is over in a moment: each man seizes his opponent by the head and drives his sword into his side, and all fall together. The place is named Helkath-hazzurim, “the field of sword-edges.” What began as a show becomes a battle. Gibeon itself was the city Israel had sworn to spare (Joshua 9:15), and now Israel fights Israel beside its pool.
vv. 18–23
Asahel
Asahel’s single-mindedness, turning “neither to the right hand nor to the left,” is the language Scripture often uses of faithful obedience (Deuteronomy 5:32), here spent on a reckless chase. Abner twice urges him to turn aside and take an easier prize, and even then strikes with the butt of his spear, apparently to stop him rather than kill him. Abner did not murder Asahel; he killed a pursuing soldier in battle after warning him. That distinction matters in chapter 3, when Joab treats it as a blood debt.
vv. 24–32
“Shall the sword devour forever?”
As the sun sets, Abner calls on Joab to stop “the pursuit of their brothers.” It is the right question asked by the man who began the fight. Joab answers with an oath and sounds the trumpet. The tally is grim: nineteen of David’s men and Asahel, three hundred sixty of Benjamin. Civil war, the chapter says, is a sword that devours brothers. The question Abner asks is answered only in the gospel, where the Son of David makes peace “by the blood of his cross” between those who were enemies (Colossians 1:20; Ephesians 2:14-16).
Threads across the chapter
Two kings, two ways. David inquires of the LORD and is anointed (vv. 1-4), while Ish-bosheth is “taken” and “made king” by Abner (vv. 8-9).
Loyalty. David blesses the chesed of Jabesh toward Saul (vv. 5-6), and Abner’s men stand by Saul’s son even into a war they lose (vv. 12-17, 25).
The devouring sword. The sword enters at Gibeon (v. 16), takes Asahel (v. 23), and is named in Abner’s question at sunset (v. 26).
Brothers. Israel against Israel (vv. 12-17), Joab’s brother killed (vv. 18-23), and the plea to stop pursuing “their brothers” (v. 26) set up the blood feud of chapter 3.
Key words
- 2:4
- מָשַׁח mashach“Anointed”; the act that sets apart a king, from which comes mashiach, the anointed one
- 2:5–6
- חֶסֶד chesed“Loyalty,” “steadfast love”; covenant faithfulness, praised in the men of Jabesh and prayed for from the LORD
- 2:8
- בֹּשֶׁת bosheth“Shame”; likely substituted for baal in the name Ish-bosheth (Eshbaal in 1 Chronicles 8:33)
Cross-references
- 1 Samuel 16:13David’s first anointing by Samuel at Bethlehem
- 1 Samuel 11:1-11Saul rescues Jabesh-gilead
- 1 Samuel 31:11-13The men of Jabesh take Saul’s body and bury his bones
- Genesis 49:10The scepter shall not depart from Judah
- Joshua 14:13-14Caleb receives Hebron for following the LORD fully
- 1 Chronicles 8:33Saul’s son Eshbaal
- Colossians 1:19-20Peace made by the blood of His cross
- 1
Chapter 1 shows David refusing a crown brought by violence. How does chapter 2 show him receiving the kingdom instead?
- 2
Why might David’s first message as king be a blessing on men who were loyal to Saul?
- 3
Abner treats the fighting at Gibeon as a contest to watch. Where do we treat conflict among believers as a game until it wounds someone?
- 4
Abner asks, “Shall the sword devour forever?” only after he started the fight. What does it take to stop a quarrel we began?
- 5
How does the division between Judah and Israel point ahead to the need for a king who could truly unite God’s people?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.