2 Samuel · Historical Books

2 Samuel 18

Absalom is defeated and killed by Joab, and David grieves, “O Absalom, my son, my son!”

18:33

“And the king was deeply moved and went up to the chamber over the gate and wept. And as he went, he said, ’O my son Absalom, my son, my son Absalom! Would I had died instead of you, O Absalom, my son, my son!’”

2 Samuel 18:33, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–5The muster and the charge“Deal gently for my sake with the young man”
  2. 6–8The battle in the forestThe forest devours more than the sword
  3. 9–15Absalom in the oakA soldier’s restraint and Joab’s three javelins
  4. 16–18The pit and the pillarA shameful grave and a monument to himself
  5. 19–32Two runnersGood news for the kingdom, heavy news for the father
  6. 33The king’s lament“Would I had died instead of you”

The chapter in brief

David divides his army under Joab, Abishai and Ittai and means to march with them, but his men refuse: “you are worth ten thousand of us” (v. 3). In the hearing of all, he orders the commanders, “Deal gently for my sake with the young man Absalom” (v. 5). The battle in the forest of Ephraim is a rout; twenty thousand fall, and “the forest devoured more people that day than the sword” (v. 8). Absalom, riding his mule under a great oak, is caught by the head and left hanging “between heaven and earth” (v. 9). A soldier who sees it will not touch the king’s son, but Joab thrusts three javelins into his heart and his armor-bearers finish him. They throw him into a pit and heap stones over him, while the narrator recalls the pillar Absalom had set up to his own name. Ahimaaz and a Cushite run with the news. When the Cushite tells the truth, David goes up to the chamber over the gate and weeps: “O my son Absalom, my son, my son Absalom! Would I had died instead of you” (v. 33).

The kingdom is saved and the king’s heart is broken. The chapter will not let us celebrate. It sets Joab’s hard efficiency against David’s tender, compromised love, and it ends not with a victory song but with a father’s cry, the sword that Nathan foretold now in David’s own heart (2 Samuel 12:10). David’s wish could not be granted, and if it had been, his death could not have saved his son. But the Son of David did what David could only wish. Christ died in the place of rebels, “while we were enemies” (Romans 5:10), and He hung on the tree under the curse that belonged to rebellious sons (Deuteronomy 21:22-23; Galatians 3:13), so that they might be brought home as children.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–5

“Deal gently”

David’s men will not let him go out: “you are worth ten thousand of us” (v. 3). It is the exact opposite of Ahithophel’s plan to strike “only the king” (2 Samuel 17:2): the people protect the king rather than the king being given up for the people. Then the king gives an order no general wants to hear, and gives it publicly so no one can claim ignorance: “Deal gently (le’at) for my sake with the young man Absalom” (v. 5). He still calls him “the young man,” as if the rebel were a boy in trouble. It is love, and it is also the same failure to deal with his son’s sin that has run through chapters 13-15.

vv. 6–8

The forest devoured

The rugged forest of Ephraim, across the Jordan, turns the battle into a scattered rout, and more die in its terrain than by the sword. Israel’s songs had told of creation itself fighting on the LORD’s side (Judges 5:20; Joshua 10:11). Many readers see the same here: the land itself refuses to carry Absalom’s rebellion.

vv. 9–15

Between heaven and earth

“His head caught fast in the oak, and he was suspended between heaven and earth” (v. 9). Popular retellings say his hair caught, and the hair of 2 Samuel 14:26 may be in the narrator’s mind, but the text says his head. The prince whose beauty was his glory hangs helpless while his mule goes on without him. An unnamed soldier refuses ten pieces of silver, or a thousand, to touch the king’s son, and he sees clearly that Joab would have left him to take the blame (vv. 12-13). Joab, who had once brought Absalom home, now kills him against the king’s order. Readers differ on Joab: a hard man who did what the kingdom’s peace required, or a law to himself who defied his king. The text records it without approving, and David will later charge Solomon with Joab’s other killings (1 Kings 2:5-6). Many readers also note the law of the rebellious son and of the hanged man cursed by God (Deuteronomy 21:18-23): Absalom dies as a son under the covenant’s curse. That curse is exactly what Christ took on Himself for us (Galatians 3:13).

vv. 16–18

The pit and the pillar

They throw Absalom “into a great pit in the forest” and raise “a very great heap of stones” (v. 17), the kind of grave Israel gave to Achan and to the king of Ai (Joshua 7:26; 8:29). Meanwhile in the King’s Valley stands the pillar Absalom set up for himself, “Absalom’s monument,” because “I have no son to keep my name in remembrance” (v. 18). The man who built a monument to his own name ends under a heap of stones in the woods. “The name of the wicked will rot” (Proverbs 10:7).

vv. 19–32

Two runners

Ahimaaz wants to carry news (basar, the word Isaiah uses for the messenger of good news, Isaiah 52:7) that the LORD has delivered the king. Joab sends a Cushite instead, a foreigner in David’s service, because “the king’s son is dead” (v. 20). Ahimaaz runs anyway, arrives first, cries “All is well,” and when David asks his only question, “Is it well with the young man Absalom?” (v. 29), he evades. The Cushite tells the truth, gently and with honor to the king (v. 32). For the kingdom it is good news; for the father it is the worst.

v. 33

“Would I had died instead of you”

David goes up to the room over the gate, weeping, and says “my son” five times in one verse. It is grief, and many readers hear guilt in it too: his own sin had set this sword in motion, and his own neglect had let it fall. The text does not scold his grief, though the next chapter will show its cost. Parents who grieve a child who went astray, or who died in rebellion, may find their own cry here; the Bible gives it room, and it is not a verdict on that child or on them. David’s wish to die in his son’s place is the deepest thing in the chapter, and it could not be granted. But God did not leave it as a wish. The Son of David died for rebels (Romans 5:6-10), the righteous for the unrighteous, to bring them to God (1 Peter 3:18).

For discussion

David wanted to die in Absalom’s place but could not, and could not have saved him if he had. What made Christ’s death in the place of sinners able to do what David’s could not? Read 1 Peter 3:18 and 2 Corinthians 5:21.

Threads across the chapter

  • Gentleness and hardness. David’s “deal gently” (v. 5) and the soldier’s restraint (vv. 12-13) stand against Joab’s javelins (v. 14).

  • The king’s life and the son’s. The people say the king is worth ten thousand (v. 3), and the king wishes he had died for his son (v. 33).

  • Hanging and heaps. Absalom hangs in the oak (vv. 9-10), lies under a heap of stones (v. 17), and is remembered by a pillar (v. 18).

  • News. Good news for the kingdom (vv. 19, 28, 31) and one question from the father (vv. 29, 32).

Key words

18:5
לְאַט le'at“Gently,” softly; the king’s public charge on behalf of his rebel son
18:19–31
בָּשַׂר basar“Carry news,” bring good news; the root Isaiah uses for the herald of salvation (Isaiah 52:7)
18:33
בְּנִי beni“My son”; repeated five times in David’s lament

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    How does this chapter answer the questions raised in chapters 13-15 about David’s love for his sons?

  2. 2

    What do the soldier who would not touch Absalom and Joab who killed him each show about obedience and conscience?

  3. 3

    Why does the narrator set Absalom’s pit beside his pillar?

  4. 4

    What has grief cost you, and what does it mean to you that the Bible gives a father’s cry this much room?

  5. 5

    How does David’s wish, “Would I had died instead of you,” help us understand what Christ has done?

My notes