2 Samuel · Historical Books

2 Samuel 17

Ahithophel’s shrewd advice is overruled by Hushai’s, and Ahithophel hangs himself.

17:14

“And Absalom and all the men of Israel said, ’The counsel of Hushai the Archite is better than the counsel of Ahithophel.’ For the LORD had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel, so that the LORD might bring harm upon Absalom.”

2 Samuel 17:14, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–4Ahithophel’s counselStrike only the king tonight
  2. 5–13Hushai’s counselDelay dressed in grandeur
  3. 14The LORD ordainedGod defeats good counsel to save His king
  4. 15–22The message gets throughTwo messengers in a well, and the Jordan crossed
  5. 23Ahithophel’s deathThe counselor’s despair
  6. 24–29MahanaimOld kindnesses repaid in the wilderness

The chapter in brief

Ahithophel proposes to take twelve thousand men that very night, catch David weary and discouraged, strike down only the king, and bring the people back to Absalom. Absalom and the elders like it, but Absalom also asks Hushai. Hushai paints David and his men as enraged like a bear robbed of her cubs, warns that one early setback will melt every heart, and urges a vast muster of all Israel with Absalom leading in person. Absalom and his men prefer Hushai’s counsel, “for the LORD had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel” (v. 14). Hushai sends word through the priests; their sons, spotted at En-rogel, hide in a well at Bahurim under a woman’s covering of grain, and David crosses the Jordan by daybreak. Ahithophel, seeing his counsel rejected, goes home, sets his house in order and hangs himself. David reaches Mahanaim, where Shobi, Machir and old Barzillai bring beds, food and supplies for his weary people.

David’s prayer on the Mount of Olives (2 Samuel 15:31) is answered here, and not by a miracle but by a vain prince choosing the worse advice. That is how God usually rules the world: through ordinary human choices, without ceasing to be the One who rules them (Proverbs 21:30). Many readers also see shadows of the Passion here. Ahithophel’s plan was that one man should die and all the people be at peace (vv. 2-3), the logic Caiaphas would speak over Jesus (John 11:49-52), and the trusted counselor who betrayed the Lord’s anointed went out and hanged himself, as Judas would (Matthew 27:5). What one betrayer meant as strategy, and another as despair, God turned to the saving of His people.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–4

“I will strike down only the king”

Ahithophel’s plan is fast, focused and sound. Hit David while he is “weary and discouraged” (v. 2), kill only him, and the people will come home “as a bride comes home to her husband” (v. 3). The aim is one death, so that “all the people will be at peace.” Many readers hear this logic again when Caiaphas says it is better for one man to die for the people (John 11:49-52). In both places a schemer means it as politics, and in the second God meant it as salvation.

vv. 5–13

Hushai’s counsel and the question of deception

Hushai’s speech is a masterpiece of persuasion. He uses vivid pictures (a bear robbed of her cubs, dew falling on the ground, a city dragged into a valley) and he feeds Absalom’s vanity: “you go to battle in person” (v. 11). Readers differ on how to judge his deception. Some hold that, like the Hebrew midwives (Exodus 1:19-20) and Rahab (Joshua 2:4-6), he practiced a lawful stratagem in war against a usurper seeking an innocent man’s life. Others hold that God used Hushai’s deception without approving it, as He uses many things He does not commend. The text itself does not stop to judge Hushai; its spotlight is on the LORD who ordained the outcome.

For discussion

Is deceiving an enemy in war or to protect the innocent the same as lying? Weigh Exodus 1:15-21 and Joshua 2:1-14 against Ephesians 4:25.

v. 14

The LORD ordained

This verse is the hinge of the whole revolt. The narrator, who has rarely spoken of God’s direct action since chapter 12, now says plainly that “the LORD had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel.” Note the word “good”: God did not defeat a foolish plan but a wise one. David’s prayer of 2 Samuel 15:31 is answered through a prince’s pride and a friend’s speech. “No wisdom, no understanding, no counsel can avail against the LORD” (Proverbs 21:30). That is a comfort for anyone who feels outmaneuvered: the cleverest plan against God’s people is not the last word.

vv. 15–22

The well at Bahurim

Jonathan and Ahimaaz are seen and must hide. A woman at Bahurim, Shimei’s own town, covers the well’s mouth, scatters grain on it, and sends the searchers the wrong way (vv. 19-20). The scene recalls Rahab hiding the spies (Joshua 2:4-6). God has unnamed friends in hostile places, and the kingdom is kept by a woman with a cloth and a handful of grain as much as by armies.

v. 23

Ahithophel’s death

He saw that his counsel was not followed, rode home, “set his house in order and hanged himself.” He was clear-sighted: he knew the revolt was finished, and he knew what David would do to a traitor. The verse is told without comment, and many readers set it beside Judas, who also betrayed the Lord’s anointed and also hanged himself (Matthew 27:3-5). The difference between them and Peter, who also failed his master, is not the size of the failure but where each turned: worldly grief produces death, and godly grief leads to repentance and life (2 Corinthians 7:10). If you have ever felt that a failure has ended your life and that there is no way back, hear this: that is despair speaking, not God. Tell someone you trust today, or call or text 988 (in the US). And if you grieve someone who died this way, this verse is not a verdict on them; Scripture does not treat this as a sin beyond the reach of Christ’s forgiveness, and your loved one is in the hands of a God who is both just and merciful.

vv. 24–29

Mahanaim

At Mahanaim three men meet David with “beds, basins, and earthen vessels” and food (v. 28). Shobi is a son of Nahash of the Ammonites, whose family David had once tried to comfort (2 Samuel 10:2). Machir of Lo-debar is the man who had sheltered Mephibosheth (2 Samuel 9:4-5). Barzillai is a wealthy old Gileadite. Old kindness comes back to the king in his worst week. Their reason is simple compassion: “The people are hungry and weary and thirsty in the wilderness” (v. 29).

Threads across the chapter

  • Counsel. Ahithophel’s good counsel (vv. 1-4), Hushai’s persuasive counsel (vv. 5-13), and the LORD’s ordaining over both (v. 14).

  • Hidden and found. Hushai says David is hidden in a pit (v. 9); the messengers hide in a well (vv. 18-20); the searchers find nothing (v. 20).

  • Crossing over. “Pass over” (v. 16), across the water (v. 21), and by daybreak all had crossed the Jordan (v. 22), while Absalom crosses after them (v. 24).

  • Betrayal and kindness. The counselor’s betrayal ends in his death (v. 23), while old friends and former enemies feed the king (vv. 27-29).

Key words

17:7, 14
עֵצָה etsah“Counsel”; the word that runs through the chapter, God’s counsel standing over man’s
17:14
צִוָּה tsivvah“Ordained,” literally “commanded”; God’s decree working through human choices
17:23
חָנַק chanaq“Hanged himself,” literally strangled; the end of the counselor’s despair

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does the narrator say God defeated the “good” counsel of Ahithophel, and what does that teach about God’s rule over human plans?

  2. 2

    How does verse 14 answer David’s prayer in 2 Samuel 15:31?

  3. 3

    What separates Ahithophel’s and Judas’s ends from Peter’s, and what hope does that give someone who feels their failure is final?

  4. 4

    How do the women and the old friends in this chapter show God keeping His king by small means?

  5. 5

    How should Christians think about Hushai’s deception in a time of war?

My notes