2 Corinthians · Epistles

2 Corinthians 2

Paul urges forgiveness of the repentant offender and describes ministry as a fragrant offering leading to life or death.

Lechaeum, at sea levelFrom the harbor at Lechaeum up through Corinth to Acrocorinth, about 3 milesAcrocorinth, about 1,500 ft

2:14

“But thanks be to God, who in Christ always leads us in triumphal procession, and through us spreads the fragrance of the knowledge of him everywhere.”

2 Corinthians 2:14, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–4The tearful letterPaul wrote in anguish to show his love
  2. 5–11Forgive the offenderDiscipline has done its work; now restore him
  3. 12–13No rest at TroasPaul’s anxiety for Titus and the church
  4. 14–17The fragrance of ChristGod leads His servants in Christ’s triumph

The chapter in brief

Paul continues to explain why he did not come again. He had decided not to make another painful visit, and he wrote instead, out of much affliction and with many tears, not to cause them pain but to show them his abundant love. That letter dealt with a man who had caused grief, and the church had disciplined him. Now, Paul says, the punishment by the majority is enough: they should forgive and comfort him so that he is not overwhelmed by excessive sorrow, and reaffirm their love for him, so that Satan does not outwit them. Paul tells how at Troas, though a door was open for the gospel, his spirit had no rest because he did not find Titus, so he went on to Macedonia. Then, abruptly, he breaks into thanks: God in Christ always leads us in triumphal procession and spreads through us the fragrance of the knowledge of Him, an aroma of death to some and of life to others. Who is sufficient for this? Paul insists he is not a peddler of God’s Word but speaks in Christ, sincerely, before God.

The chapter holds two kinds of grace together. One is the hard grace of church discipline that ends in restoration, not in exile; the other is the gospel ministry that seems weak and is carried in tears yet is God’s own victory march. The story of Titus breaks off at verse 13 and does not resume until 7:5. Between them lies a long reflection on what gospel ministry is (2:14-7:4), and this chapter is the hinge into it. That ministry is “in Christ” from first to last: He is the conqueror who leads the procession, the knowledge whose fragrance spreads, and the One in whom Paul speaks. The gospel of Christ crucified is never neutral; it is life to those being saved and death to those who refuse it.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–4

The tearful letter

Paul had made one painful visit already (v. 1), and rather than make another he wrote a letter “out of much affliction and anguish of heart and with many tears” (v. 4). Many readers think this letter is now lost; others have identified it with 1 Corinthians. Either way, the purpose is the striking thing: “not to cause you pain but to let you know the abundant love that I have for you.” Confrontation in the church, done rightly, is a form of love, and Paul’s tears show that it cost him. A leader who rebukes easily and without grief has missed the pattern.

vv. 5–11

Forgive the offender

Who the offender was is debated. The traditional view identifies him with the man in 1 Corinthians 5; many modern readers think he was someone who wronged Paul or his delegate during the painful visit (compare 7:12). The point holds either way. Discipline had a goal, and the goal has been reached: the man has felt the weight of it, and now the church must “turn to forgive and comfort him, or he may be overwhelmed by excessive sorrow” (v. 7). Discipline that never ends stops being discipline and becomes a weapon, and Satan, Paul warns, would gladly use it (v. 11). Church discipline exists to restore, and reaffirmed love is its last step (Galatians 6:1; Matthew 18:15).

Two cautions keep this from misuse. Discipline is never a tool for leaders to silence those who have been harmed or to protect the powerful; Paul’s concern in 7:12 includes “the one who suffered the wrong.” And a church’s forgiveness of a repentant man does not mean his victims must be put in his path again, or that crimes go unreported; the civil authorities bear the sword for wrongdoing (Romans 13:4).

For discussion

What does “reaffirm your love for him” (v. 8) look like in a real congregation? How do we restore a repentant person while protecting the vulnerable?

vv. 12–13

No rest at Troas

A door for the gospel stood open at Troas, and Paul left it. That surprises readers who think an open door always means stay. Paul’s care for the Corinthians, and his worry over Titus who carried news of them, outweighed the opportunity. The apostle was a man with a pastor’s anxiety (11:28), and he does not pretend otherwise. The story stops here mid-journey and picks up again at 7:5, where God comforts him by the coming of Titus.

vv. 14–17

The fragrance of Christ

The thanksgiving bursts in. The verb (thriambeuō) pictures a Roman triumph, the victory parade in which a general led his army, his spoils, and his captives through the city. Readers differ on Paul’s place in the picture. Some see him as a soldier sharing the victory; many see him as one of the captives, conquered by Christ and displayed in His train, which fits the letter’s theme of weakness and the way the verb is used of defeated powers in Colossians 2:15. This commentary leans toward the captive reading, but on either reading the triumph is Christ’s, not Paul’s. Incense was burned along such processions, and the image may also recall the “pleasing aroma” of sacrifice (Genesis 8:21; Ephesians 5:2). The same message is an aroma “from death to death” to some and “from life to life” to others (v. 16). The gospel divides because it is Christ Himself, and no one stays neutral before Him (Luke 2:34). “Who is sufficient for these things?” The answer comes in 3:5: our sufficiency is from God. Unlike the “peddlers” (kapēleuō, a word used of hucksters who watered down their wine), Paul does not dilute the Word for profit (v. 17; 4:2).

For discussion

If the same gospel smells of death to some, how should that shape the way we judge the “success” of faithful preaching? Compare Isaiah 6:9-10.

Threads across the chapter

  • Grief and love. The tearful letter (vv. 1-4), the grieving offender (v. 7), and Paul’s restless spirit (v. 13) all show love that costs.

  • Restoration. Discipline gives way to forgiveness and comfort (vv. 5-11), echoing the comfort of chapter 1.

  • Satan’s designs. Unforgiving severity is one of the enemy’s tools (v. 11), and the gospel is God’s triumph over every such design (v. 14).

  • Sincerity. Paul’s honest tears (v. 4) and his refusal to peddle the Word (v. 17) answer the charge that he cannot be trusted.

Key words

2:1–7
λύπη lypē“Grief, sorrow, pain”; the word that runs through Paul’s explanation of the painful visit and letter
2:14
θριαμβεύω thriambeuō“Lead in triumphal procession”; the imagery of a Roman victory parade
2:14, 16
ὀσμή osmē“Fragrance”; the gospel spreading like incense, life to some and death to others
2:17
καπηλεύω kapēleuō“Peddle”; to hawk goods for gain, often with the suggestion of adulterating them

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why might Paul break off the story of Titus at verse 13 and launch into praise? What does the long section that follows (2:14-7:4) gain by being placed there?

  2. 2

    How can discipline in a church be both serious and restorative? Where do churches tend to err on one side or the other?

  3. 3

    How does unforgiveness give Satan an advantage, in a church or in a family?

  4. 4

    What does it mean to you to be the “aroma of Christ” (v. 15) in a place where many find the gospel distasteful?

  5. 5

    Paul left an open door at Troas. How do we discern between an opportunity and a calling?

My notes