14:6
“Jonathan said to the young man who carried his armor, ’Come, let us go over to the garrison of these uncircumcised. It may be that the LORD will work for us, for nothing can hinder the LORD from saving by many or by few.’”
The chapter at a glance
- 1–5Jonathan sets outThe son goes out while the king sits
- 6–15By many or by fewFaith acts, and God sends panic
- 16–23The LORD saved IsraelThe rout spreads; Saul breaks off his inquiry
- 24–30Saul’s oathA rash curse weakens the army
- 31–35Eating with the bloodHunger drives the people to break God’s law
- 36–46Jonathan condemned and ransomedThe king would kill the son who saved Israel
- 47–52Saul’s wars and householdReal victories, and constant war
The chapter in brief
Without telling his father, Jonathan and his armor-bearer set out for the Philistine garrison across the pass between two crags, Bozez and Seneh. Saul stays in the outskirts of Gibeah with about six hundred men and the priest Ahijah, of Eli’s line, wearing an ephod. Jonathan says, “It may be that the LORD will work for us, for nothing can hinder the LORD from saving by many or by few.” They agree on a sign: if the Philistines say “Come up to us,” they will go. The Philistines mock them as Hebrews coming out of their holes and call them up. Jonathan climbs on hands and feet, and the two kill about twenty men; panic spreads through the Philistine camp, the earth quakes, and it becomes “a very great panic.” Saul’s watchmen see the army melting away. Saul begins to inquire of God through the priest, then breaks off, “Withdraw your hand,” and joins the battle, where every Philistine’s sword is against his fellow. Hebrews who had served the Philistines and Israelites who had hidden join in. “So the LORD saved Israel that day.” But Saul had laid an oath on the people: “Cursed be the man who eats food until it is evening and I am avenged on my enemies.” Jonathan, who had not heard, eats a little honey, and his eyes brighten; told of the oath, he says, “My father has troubled the land.” The famished people later slaughter captured animals on the ground and eat them with the blood, and Saul has a great stone rolled up for proper slaughter and builds his first altar. When Saul plans a night pursuit, God does not answer him. Saul swears that the guilty one will die, though it be Jonathan, and the lot falls on Jonathan. Saul swears that Jonathan “shall surely die,” but the people refuse: Jonathan “has worked with God this day.” They ransom him. The chapter closes with a summary of Saul’s wars against enemies on every side, his family, and Abner his commander, and with hard fighting against the Philistines all his days.
The chapter sets two men side by side. Jonathan acts in faith with no human advantage, sure not of the outcome but of the LORD’s power, and God works a great salvation through him. Saul, by contrast, inquires and then stops, swears a rash oath that weakens the army and leads the people into breaking God’s law, and is ready to put to death the son through whom God saved Israel. The verdict of the narrator is plain: “So the LORD saved Israel that day” (v. 23). Salvation is the LORD’s, by many or by few, and in the end by One. A father who would kill his son to keep his own word throws into relief the Father who “did not spare his own Son but gave him up for us all” (Romans 8:32), and a son ransomed by the people points by contrast to the Son who came “to give his life as a ransom for many” (Mark 10:45).
Points for discussion
vv. 1–5
The king under the pomegranate
The narrator sets the scene with care. Jonathan goes out; Saul sits under a pomegranate tree (or in a cave) with six hundred men. Beside him is Ahijah, and the narrator traces his line back through Ichabod and Phinehas to Eli (v. 3), the house God had said He would judge (2:30-36). Many readers notice the irony: the king God has just rejected (13:13-14) sits with a priest from the house God has rejected, while his son acts.
vv. 6–15
Nothing can hinder the LORD
Jonathan’s words are a model of faith without presumption. “It may be that the LORD will work for us” is not doubt about God’s power but humility about His will; what is certain is that “nothing can hinder the LORD from saving by many or by few” (v. 6). This is the lesson of Gideon’s three hundred (Judges 7:2). Jonathan asks for a sign, and readers differ on whether such signs are a pattern for believers today. The sign here was given within a battle for God’s people, by a man already acting in faith; it is not a license to demand that God prove Himself before we obey what He has already said. The armor-bearer’s words, “I am with you heart and soul” (v. 7), are their own small picture of loyalty. The result is God’s: “the earth quaked, and it became a very great panic,” which the ESV footnote notes can be rendered “a panic from God” (v. 15).
vv. 16–23
“Withdraw your hand”
Saul counts his men and finds Jonathan missing; he calls for the ark of God (the Greek reads the ephod) to inquire. But as the noise grows, he tells the priest to stop. As at Gilgal, Saul begins to seek God and then acts before God answers. The battle is won anyway, and the narrator’s summary leaves no doubt who won it: “So the LORD saved Israel that day” (v. 23). Even the Hebrews who had gone over to the Philistines and the men hiding in the hills come back. When God moves, the faint-hearted find courage.
vv. 24–30
“Cursed be the man who eats”
Saul’s oath is about himself: “until it is evening and I am avenged on my enemies” (v. 24). It looks like zeal, but it weakens the army on the very day it needs strength. Jonathan’s verdict is sharp: “My father has troubled the land” (v. 29). Many readers note that the verb is the one used of Achan, whose sin “troubled” Israel (Joshua 7:25). Rules that God did not give, laid on His people by a leader’s pride, do not make them holier; they make them faint (Colossians 2:20-23).
vv. 31–35
Eating with the blood
The consequence follows at once. The starving people fall on the spoil and eat meat “with the blood,” which God’s law forbade (Leviticus 17:10-14; Deuteronomy 12:23). Saul’s man-made rule has pushed the people into breaking God’s real command, the pattern Jesus exposed: “You have a fine way of rejecting the commandment of God in order to establish your tradition” (Mark 7:9). Saul acts quickly to correct it and builds his first altar to the LORD (v. 35). Readers differ on whether the note is praise or quiet irony; given the chapter, it may be both: a real act of piety from a king whose piety keeps arriving late.
vv. 36–46
Jonathan condemned and ransomed
When God is silent, Saul assumes someone else is guilty, and swears that the guilty one will die “though it be in Jonathan my son” (v. 39). The people are silent, a silence that speaks. The lot falls on Jonathan, who says simply, “Here I am; I will die” (v. 43). Was Jonathan guilty? He broke an oath he never heard, laid by his father in pride. Saul is ready to kill his son rather than lose face, as Jephthah once held to a vow that cost his daughter (Judges 11:30-35). The people refuse: Jonathan “has worked with God this day,” and they ransom him (v. 45). The text does not say how. Here the contrast with the gospel is striking. Saul would sacrifice his son to protect his pride; the Father gave His Son to save others (Romans 8:32). Jonathan was ransomed by the people; Christ ransomed His people by giving Himself (Mark 10:45). No parent’s rage and no rash vow binds anyone to harm a child, and no oath binds a person to sin.
For discussion
Why do you think God did not answer Saul (v. 37)? Was the problem Jonathan’s honey, Saul’s oath, or Saul himself? Compare 1 Samuel 28:6 and Proverbs 20:25.
vv. 47–52
Saul’s wars
The narrator is fair to Saul. He fought enemies on every side, “did valiantly,” struck the Amalekites, and delivered Israel from those who plundered them (vv. 47-48). Real victories are recorded alongside real failures. Abner, his cousin and commander, is introduced here and will matter long after Saul. The last line is quietly sad: hard fighting all Saul’s days, and every strong man he saw, he took for himself (v. 52), just as Samuel had warned a king would do (8:11).
Threads across the chapter
Saving. “nothing can hinder the LORD from saving” (v. 6), “the LORD saved Israel” (v. 23), and Jonathan “has worked this great salvation” with God (v. 45).
Father and son. Jonathan acts without his father’s knowledge (v. 1), names his father’s harm (v. 29), and is condemned by his father and saved by the people (vv. 39-45).
Seeking God by halves. Saul calls for the ark and stops (vv. 18-19), builds an altar after the sin (v. 35), and inquires only to meet silence (v. 37).
Rash words. Saul’s curse (v. 24), his oath against Jonathan (vv. 39, 44), and the people’s answering oath (v. 45).
Key words
- 14:6, 23
- יָשַׁע yasha'“Save”; the root behind “salvation” in verse 45 and behind the names Joshua and Jesus
- 14:29
- עָכַר akar“Troubled”; to bring disaster on a community, the verb used of Achan in Joshua 7:25
- 14:45
- פָּדָה padah“Ransomed”; to redeem by a payment or substitute, used of the firstborn and of Israel brought out of Egypt
Cross-references
- Judges 7:2The LORD saves by few, so that Israel cannot boast
- Joshua 7:25Achan troubles Israel
- Leviticus 17:10-14The life is in the blood
- Mark 7:9Rejecting God’s command to keep a human tradition
- Judges 11:30-35Jephthah’s rash vow
- Proverbs 20:25The snare of rash vows
- Romans 8:32The Father who did not spare His own Son
- Mark 10:45The Son of Man gives His life as a ransom for many
- 1
Chapter 13 ended with Israel having no swords. How does chapter 14 answer the question that leaves hanging?
- 2
Jonathan says “It may be” and also “nothing can hinder the LORD.” How do humility and confidence fit together in faith?
- 3
How did Saul’s oath, meant to look zealous, actually lead the people into sin? Where do rules we add to God’s Word do the same?
- 4
Compare Saul’s willingness to kill Jonathan with the Father’s giving of His Son. What does the contrast show you about God?
- 5
What does it look like to be “with you heart and soul” (v. 7) for someone stepping out in faith?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.