1 Samuel · Historical Books

1 Samuel 13

Saul presumptuously offers sacrifice at Gilgal, and Samuel foretells that his kingdom will not endure.

13:14

“But now your kingdom shall not continue. The LORD has sought out a man after his own heart, and the LORD has commanded him to be prince over his people, because you have not kept what the LORD commanded you.”

1 Samuel 13:14, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1Saul’s reign introducedA royal formula whose numbers the Hebrew has lost
  2. 2–7The Philistines musterJonathan’s strike provokes overwhelming force, and Israel hides
  3. 8–12Saul’s offeringFear of losing the people drives Saul to act
  4. 13–15Samuel’s verdictThe kingdom will not continue; a man after God’s heart
  5. 16–23No sword in IsraelIsrael stands without weapons before its enemy

The chapter in brief

Saul chooses three thousand men, two thousand with himself at Michmash and a thousand with Jonathan at Gibeah. Jonathan strikes the Philistine garrison at Geba, and all Israel hears that Saul has done it, and that Israel has become a stench to the Philistines. The Philistines muster a huge force with chariots and horsemen and troops “like the sand on the seashore,” and the men of Israel hide in caves, holes, rocks, tombs and cisterns; some cross the Jordan. Saul waits seven days at Gilgal, the time Samuel appointed, but Samuel does not come and the people are scattering. So Saul offers the burnt offering himself. As soon as he finishes, Samuel arrives: “What have you done?” Saul explains that the people were leaving, Samuel was late, and the Philistines were gathering, “So I forced myself, and offered the burnt offering.” Samuel answers, “You have done foolishly. You have not kept the command of the LORD your God.” The LORD would have established Saul’s kingdom forever, but now it will not continue; the LORD has sought out “a man after his own heart.” Samuel leaves, and Saul counts about six hundred men left with him. Philistine raiders go out in three companies, and Israel has no blacksmith, for the Philistines have kept iron-working to themselves; on the day of battle only Saul and Jonathan have sword or spear.

The chapter is the first crack in Saul’s reign, and the fault line is the Word of the LORD. Under pressure, with his army melting away, Saul reaches for a religious act to hold things together, and does it in disobedience to the command he was given (10:8). The king was meant to reign under God’s Word spoken through the prophet; instead he acts as though the sacrifice in his own hands could secure God’s favor. The chapter also shows Israel stripped of every human resource, which sets up the next chapter’s truth that the LORD saves “by many or by few.” It points to Christ in two ways: in the “man after his own heart,” who will be David and through David’s line the Messiah; and in the one King who also is the true Priest, combining both offices without presumption, because God Himself appointed Him a priest forever after the order of Melchizedek (Psalm 110:4; Hebrews 7).

Points for discussion

v. 1

A verse with missing numbers

Verse 1 follows the pattern later used for every king: his age when he began to reign and how long he reigned. But the Hebrew, as we have it, reads literally that Saul was “one year old” and reigned “two years,” which cannot be what was meant (the ESV footnote gives this; some Greek manuscripts give thirty for his age). Translations handle it differently; the ESV renders it as Saul living a year before his reign was established. Acts 13:21 says Saul reigned forty years. The likeliest explanation is that numbers dropped out in copying. Scripture’s inspiration belongs to what God gave, and faithful readers have always been honest about the places where copies differ. Nothing in the faith hangs on this verse, and the honesty of our English Bibles in footnoting it is a gift.

vv. 2–7

Credit and fear

Jonathan strikes the garrison (v. 3), but the report that goes through Israel is that “Saul had defeated the garrison” (v. 4). Whether Saul claimed it or the people simply assumed it, the king gets the credit for his son’s courage, a small detail that foreshadows much. The Philistine response is overwhelming, and Israel’s men hide in caves and holes, and many readers note a sad reversal of Joshua’s day, when Israel’s enemies hid in a cave (Joshua 10:16). Saul is still at Gilgal, and “all the people followed him trembling” (v. 7). The question of the chapter is whether the king will trust the LORD when everything visible is against him.

vv. 8–12

“I forced myself”

Samuel had told Saul to go to Gilgal and wait seven days until he came to offer the sacrifices and show him what to do (10:8). Saul waited, but not to the end; Samuel arrives just as the offering is finished. Readers have asked what exactly Saul’s sin was. Some stress that he took a priest’s role (compare King Uzziah, 2 Chronicles 26:16-21). Others point out that Samuel’s charge is simply disobedience to the command (v. 13), and that the deeper issue was a king who would not wait for God’s Word through the prophet. The text’s own emphasis is on the command, and the two readings fit together: Saul used worship as a tool to manage a crisis, on his own terms. His explanation is revealing. He saw the people scattering, he blamed Samuel’s lateness, and he said he had not “sought the favor of the LORD” (v. 12), as though the offering were a lever to move God. The fear of man drives him here, as it will in chapter 15 (15:24; Proverbs 29:25).

For discussion

Saul’s sin was done under real pressure and with a religious act. When are we most tempted to do “the right thing” in the wrong way because we will not wait for God? Compare Isaiah 40:31 and Psalm 27:14.

vv. 13–15

The man after God’s heart

The penalty seems severe for one offering, but the offering exposed a heart that would not be ruled by God’s Word, and chapter 15 confirms it. Samuel says the LORD “would have established your kingdom over Israel forever” (v. 13). Readers have long asked how that fits Jacob’s prophecy that the scepter would belong to Judah (Genesis 49:10). Some take it as a real offer within God’s dealings with Saul, others as a statement of what obedience would have meant, with God’s plan for Judah unchanged; the passage does not say how both would have worked, and it does not need to. The phrase “a man after his own heart” can mean a man whose heart is like God’s, or a man of God’s own choosing (“according to his heart”). Acts 13:22 draws on it: “a man after my heart, who will do all my will.” Both are true of David, but the choice is God’s first. David will not be sinless, as 2 Samuel 11 makes painfully clear. God’s king is chosen by grace and given a heart to follow Him, and the line runs to the Son of David who did all the Father’s will perfectly.

vv. 16–23

No sword in Israel

The Philistines kept iron-working to themselves, so Israelites had to go down to them even to sharpen farm tools, and pay for it. The “pim” in verse 21 (see the ESV footnote) is a weight archaeologists have found inscribed on small stones, about two-thirds of a shekel, a small detail that roots the story in its world. The result: on the day of battle, only Saul and Jonathan have sword or spear. Israel has an army of six hundred and almost no weapons. The narrator is setting the stage. Everything human is gone, and in the next chapter one man and his armor-bearer will act on the conviction that the LORD’s power does not depend on Israel’s arsenal (Zechariah 4:6).

Threads across the chapter

  • Waiting. Saul waits seven days (v. 8) but not for Samuel, and the man after God’s heart is the one who waits for God’s command (vv. 13-14).

  • Fear and scattering. Israel hides and trembles (vv. 6-7), the people scatter from Saul (vv. 8, 11), and fear drives his offering (v. 12).

  • The command of the LORD. “You have not kept the command” (v. 13) and “not kept what the LORD commanded you” (v. 14) frame the verdict, and the LORD “commanded” the new prince (v. 14).

  • Means and might. Thousands of Philistine chariots (v. 5) stand against six hundred men (v. 15) with two swords (v. 22).

Key words

13:12
אָפַק aphaq“Forced myself”; to restrain or compel oneself, used of Joseph controlling himself in Genesis 43:31, here of Saul pushing past his conscience
13:13
סָכַל sakal“Done foolishly”; in Scripture folly is a moral failure toward God, not a lack of intelligence
13:14
נָגִיד nagid“Prince, leader”; the title given to Saul (9:16) and now to the man God has chosen in his place

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Chapter 12 ended with “both you and your king” under the LORD’s command. How does chapter 13 put that to the test immediately?

  2. 2

    What did Saul think the burnt offering would do for him, and why was that a wrong view of worship?

  3. 3

    What does “a man after his own heart” mean, and how does Acts 13:22 help answer it?

  4. 4

    Saul acted because “the people were scattering.” Where does the fear of losing people’s approval push you to act against what God has said?

  5. 5

    Why do you think the narrator ends the chapter with Israel’s lack of swords?

My notes