1 Samuel · Historical Books

1 Samuel 12

Samuel’s farewell address calls Israel to fear and serve the LORD despite the sin of asking for a king.

12:24

“Only fear the LORD and serve him faithfully with all your heart. For consider what great things he has done for you.”

1 Samuel 12:24, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–5Samuel’s integrityThe outgoing judge is cleared before the LORD and His anointed
  2. 6–12The righteous deeds of the LORDIsrael’s history of sin, cry and rescue, then a king
  3. 13–15The terms for king and peopleBoth stand under the LORD’s command
  4. 16–18Thunder in wheat harvestA sign exposes the evil of asking for a king
  5. 19–25“Do not be afraid”Grace for the guilty, prayer, and a warning

The chapter in brief

At Gilgal Samuel speaks to all Israel. He has obeyed their voice and made a king over them; now he is old and gray. He asks them to testify against him before the LORD and before His anointed: “Whose ox have I taken? Or whose donkey have I taken? Or whom have I defrauded?” They answer that he has defrauded and oppressed no one, and taken nothing from any man’s hand, and the LORD is called as witness. Then Samuel pleads with them “concerning all the righteous deeds of the LORD”: the LORD sent Moses and Aaron and brought their fathers out of Egypt; when they forgot Him, He sold them into the hands of their enemies; when they cried out and confessed, He sent deliverers. Yet when Nahash came against them, they said, “No, but a king shall reign over us,” when the LORD their God was their king. Now the king they asked for stands before them, set over them by the LORD. If both they and their king fear, serve and obey the LORD, it will be well; if they rebel, His hand will be against them. As a sign, Samuel calls on the LORD in wheat harvest, and the LORD sends thunder and rain. The people fear greatly and beg Samuel to pray for them, for they have added to all their sins the evil of asking for a king. Samuel answers, “Do not be afraid; you have done all this evil. Yet do not turn aside from following the LORD.” The LORD will not forsake His people “for his great name’s sake,” and Samuel will not sin by ceasing to pray for them. But if they still do wickedly, they will be swept away, both they and their king.

Samuel’s farewell is a covenant sermon at a turning point in Israel’s history, and it places the new king firmly under the old covenant: the king is not a replacement for the LORD but a servant who, with the people, must fear and obey Him. The chapter’s heart is grace for the guilty. The people have done evil, and the sign confirms it; yet Samuel tells them not to be afraid, because the LORD’s keeping of His people rests on His own name and His own pleasure (v. 22), not on their record. And the old prophet refuses to stop praying for them. In this he points ahead to the greater Prophet and Intercessor, Jesus, who “always lives to make intercession” for those who draw near to God through Him (Hebrews 7:25), and who keeps His people for His name’s sake.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–5

“Whose ox have I taken?”

Samuel’s questions are pointed. In chapter 8 he warned that a king would “take”: sons, daughters, fields, a tenth of their grain and flocks (8:11-17). Now he asks whether he has ever taken anything, and the people agree he has not. He also asks about bribes “to blind my eyes,” the language of the law (Deuteronomy 16:19), and the very sin of his own sons (8:3). Before he hands over to a king, Samuel shows what godly leadership has looked like: open to examination, clean-handed, accountable before God and the people. Paul made the same appeal when he left Ephesus (Acts 20:33). Leaders in the church are rightly asked such questions, and a leader who will not bear them is a warning sign, not a model.

vv. 6–12

Pleading the LORD’s righteous deeds

Samuel stands “that I may plead with you before the LORD” (v. 7), the language of a court case, and the case he brings is a history. The pattern is the pattern of Judges: forgetting the LORD, being sold into the enemy’s hand, crying out, confessing, and being delivered (Judges 2:11-19). The list of deliverers includes Jerubbaal (Gideon), Jephthah and Samuel himself; the Hebrew reads “Bedan” where the Greek and Syriac read “Barak,” and the ESV follows them, noting the Hebrew in its footnote. The sting comes at the end. When Nahash threatened, the people did not cry to the LORD as their fathers had; they asked for a king, “when the LORD your God was your king” (v. 12). Their sin was not wanting order but turning from the King who had saved them again and again.

vv. 13–15

King and people under the same command

“And now behold the king whom you have chosen, for whom you have asked; behold, the LORD has set a king over you” (v. 13). Both are true. The people chose in sin, and the LORD set the king over them in His purpose. God takes a sinful request and works it into His plan, which will lead through David’s line to Christ. But the king is not above the covenant: “both you and the king who reigns over you” must follow the LORD (v. 14), as the law of the king in Deuteronomy 17:14-20 required. Israel’s obedience was never the ground of their being God’s people; that rests on His choice (v. 22). Obedience was the fitting response of a people He had already saved, and the curse for rebellion was real.

vv. 16–18

Thunder in wheat harvest

Wheat harvest came in the dry season of late spring and early summer, when rain is rare and, if heavy, could damage a standing crop. Samuel calls on the LORD, and the thunder and rain come “that day.” The sign is not random weather; it is a sign from God that the prophet announces beforehand, so that the people “shall know and see that your wickedness is great” (v. 17). Readers should not turn every storm into a verdict on the people it falls on (Luke 13:1-5); this sign was named and given by a prophet for a purpose. Its purpose was to bring the people to see their sin, and it worked.

vv. 19–25

“Do not be afraid; you have done all this evil”

This is one of the most gospel-shaped sentences in the book. Samuel does not tell the people their sin is small; he agrees it is evil. But he tells them not to be afraid, and gives the reason: “the LORD will not forsake his people, for his great name’s sake, because it has pleased the LORD to make you a people for himself” (v. 22). Their hope rests on God’s name and God’s pleasure, not on undoing the past. The way forward is not despair but to “serve the LORD with all your heart” and not to turn aside after “empty things” (v. 21), the same word used of the formless earth in Genesis 1:2. Then Samuel says that to cease praying for them would be a sin against the LORD (v. 23). Prayerlessness for those in our care is not a small lapse. Samuel the intercessor of Mizpah (7:8-9) points here to Christ, who intercedes for His people without ceasing (Hebrews 7:25; Romans 8:34). The final warning (v. 25) is just as real: the covenant had teeth, and Israel’s later exile shows it.

For discussion

Samuel says, “Do not be afraid; you have done all this evil.” How can both halves of that sentence be true at once? Compare 1 John 1:8-9 and Romans 8:1.

Threads across the chapter

  • Witness. The LORD and His anointed witness to Samuel’s integrity (vv. 3-5), the LORD’s deeds witness against Israel (vv. 6-12), and the thunder witnesses to their sin (vv. 16-18).

  • Asking for a king. The request is named as rejecting the LORD (v. 12), as wickedness (v. 17), and as an evil added to all their sins (v. 19), yet the LORD sets the king over them (v. 13).

  • Fear. The call to fear the LORD (vv. 14, 24) meets the people’s terror (v. 18) and Samuel’s “Do not be afraid” (v. 20).

  • Turning aside. Samuel has walked before them from youth (v. 2), and he warns them not to turn aside from the LORD (v. 20) after empty things (v. 21).

Key words

12:7
שָׁפַט shaphat“Plead, enter into judgment”; Samuel brings a covenant case before the LORD
12:21
תֹּהוּ tohu“Empty things”; the word for the formless earth in Genesis 1:2, used of idols that cannot profit or deliver
12:22
נָטַשׁ natash“Forsake”; the LORD will not abandon His people, for His name’s sake

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does Samuel begin his farewell by inviting accusation, and how does that prepare for what he says about the king?

  2. 2

    In verse 13 the people chose the king, and the LORD set him over them. How does God work through even our sinful choices without approving them?

  3. 3

    What reasons does verse 22 give for the LORD not forsaking His people, and why is that better news than “because you have repented enough”?

  4. 4

    Samuel calls ceasing to pray for others a sin. Who has God placed in your care to pray for, and what keeps you from doing it?

  5. 5

    What are the “empty things” that cannot profit or deliver that we are tempted to turn aside after today?

My notes