11:13
“But Saul said, ’Not a man shall be put to death this day, for today the LORD has worked salvation in Israel.’”
The chapter at a glance
The chapter in brief
Nahash the Ammonite besieges Jabesh-gilead, east of the Jordan. The men of the town offer to make a treaty and serve him, but Nahash names his condition: he will gouge out all their right eyes “and thus bring disgrace on all Israel.” The elders ask for seven days to send messengers through Israel: “if there is no one to save us, we will give ourselves up to you.” The news reaches Gibeah of Saul, and the people weep aloud. Saul comes in from the field behind the oxen, hears what has happened, and “the Spirit of God rushed upon Saul,” and his anger burns. He cuts a yoke of oxen in pieces and sends them through Israel with a warning, “Whoever does not come out after Saul and Samuel, so shall it be done to his oxen!” The dread of the LORD falls on the people, and they come out “as one man.” Saul sends word to Jabesh: “Tomorrow, by the time the sun is hot, you shall have salvation.” He attacks the Ammonite camp in three companies in the morning watch and scatters them so that no two are left together. The people want to put to death those who had despised Saul, but Saul refuses: “today the LORD has worked salvation in Israel.” Samuel calls the people to Gilgal to “renew the kingdom,” and there they make Saul king before the LORD, offer peace offerings, and rejoice greatly.
This is Saul at his best, and the chapter lets us see what a king under God was meant to be: a man on whom the Spirit comes, who hears the cry of the helpless, gathers the people as one, saves, and then gives the glory to the LORD and shows mercy to his critics. The town’s desperate words, “if there is no one to save us,” hang over the chapter, and the answer is a deliverer anointed and empowered by God’s Spirit. That is the shape of the hope that runs through the whole book toward the Anointed One, the Christ, on whom the Spirit rests (Isaiah 11:2; Luke 4:18), who saves those who have no one else to save them, and who prayed for those who despised Him (Luke 23:34). Saul’s mercy here is real, but it does not last; the King it points to does not fail.
Points for discussion
vv. 1–4
No one to save us
Gouging out the right eye is often explained as both cruelty and strategy: a soldier who held his shield on the left and looked past it with the right would be useless in battle. But Nahash states his real aim plainly: to “bring disgrace on all Israel.” Chapter 12 reveals something the narrative has kept back. Samuel tells the people that when they saw Nahash coming against them, they said, “No, but a king shall reign over us,” when the LORD their God was their king (12:12). So the Ammonite threat helps explain the demand for a king in chapter 8. Jabesh-gilead also had a history with Benjamin, Saul’s tribe: after the civil war of Judges 20-21, wives for the surviving Benjaminites were taken from Jabesh-gilead (Judges 21:8-14). A Benjaminite king has kin to rescue there.
vv. 5–11
The Spirit and the oxen
The newly chosen king is still plowing. He has been anointed (10:1) and publicly chosen (10:24), but he goes home to his fields until a need arises, like the judges before him. Then “the Spirit of God rushed upon Saul” (v. 6), the same language used of the judges (Judges 14:6) and of Saul at his anointing (10:6, 10). Many readers note a striking echo in the oxen cut in pieces and sent through Israel. In Judges 19:29 a Levite cut up the body of his concubine, abused to death at Gibeah, and sent the pieces through Israel; that summons led to war against Benjamin and to the destruction of Jabesh-gilead itself (Judges 21:10). Now a man of Gibeah sends a summons in pieces to save Jabesh. What once tore Israel apart is answered by a call that gathers it “as one man” (v. 7). Notice who moves the people: “the dread of the LORD fell upon the people.” The king’s threat is fierce, but the gathering is God’s work.
vv. 12–13
Mercy on the day of salvation
At his anointing some worthless men had despised Saul and asked how this man could save them (10:27). Now the crowd wants them dead, and it is Samuel they ask. Saul himself answers, and he answers well: no one will die on a day when the LORD has saved. He gives the victory to God, and he refuses to use it to settle scores. This is the Saul who could have been. The contrast with what follows is sharp: in chapter 14 he is ready to put his own son to death over a rash oath, and in chapter 22 he will slaughter the priests of Nob. The same man can be gracious in victory and murderous in fear. The gospel’s King shows mercy not only on the day of triumph but in the hour of His own suffering (Luke 23:34), and His mercy does not change.
For discussion
Saul refuses to punish those who had despised him. Why is mercy often easiest right after a victory, and what does it take to keep showing it when we feel threatened? Compare Romans 12:19-21.
vv. 14–15
Renewing the kingdom at Gilgal
Saul’s kingship comes in three steps: a private anointing (10:1), a public choice by lot at Mizpah (10:17-24), and now a confirmation after a victory has shown him to be God’s deliverer. Some scholars see two accounts of Saul’s rise placed side by side; read as it stands, the sequence is coherent, and “renew” fits a kingship already given and now confirmed by all the people. Gilgal matters. It was Israel’s first camp in the land, where the generation of the conquest was circumcised and kept the Passover (Joshua 4:19-20; 5:9-10). There “they made Saul king before the LORD” (v. 15), with peace offerings. The phrase “before the LORD” is the point: the king reigns under the true King. Chapter 12 will make that explicit, and chapter 13, also at Gilgal, will show what happens when the king forgets it.
Threads across the chapter
Salvation. Jabesh asks for anyone “to save us” (v. 3), Saul promises “salvation” by tomorrow (v. 9), and Saul confesses that “the LORD has worked salvation” (v. 13).
Disgrace and honor. Nahash seeks to disgrace all Israel (v. 2), the disgraced town is delivered (v. 11), and the king who was despised is honored before the LORD (vv. 12-15).
One people. Israel weeps together (v. 4), comes out “as one man” (v. 7), and rejoices together at Gilgal (v. 15).
Key words
- 11:6
- צָלַח tsalach“Rushed upon”; the Spirit’s sudden coming to empower a leader for a task, used of the judges and of Saul and David
- 11:9, 13
- תְּשׁוּעָה teshu'ah“Salvation, deliverance”; from the same root as the names Joshua and Jesus
- 11:14
- חָדַשׁ chadash“Renew”; to make new or confirm, here a kingship already given and now publicly affirmed
Cross-references
- Judges 19:29The Levite’s grim summons in pieces from Gibeah
- Judges 21:8-14Jabesh-gilead and Benjamin after the civil war
- 1 Samuel 10:27The worthless men who despised Saul
- 1 Samuel 12:12Nahash’s threat behind the demand for a king
- 1 Samuel 31:11-13The men of Jabesh-gilead remember Saul at his death
- Joshua 5:9-10Gilgal, the place of the conquest generation’s renewal
- Isaiah 11:2The Spirit of the LORD resting on the coming King
- Luke 23:34The King who prays for those who reject Him
- 1
Chapter 10 ended with some despising Saul. How does chapter 11 answer them, and why do you think the narrator shows us Saul at his best here, before chapters 13-15?
- 2
What does Saul’s answer in verse 13 show about how a leader under God should handle success?
- 3
Jabesh said, “if there is no one to save us.” When have you felt that, and where does this chapter point you to look?
- 4
The same Saul who spares his critics here will later try to kill his own son and his loyal servant. What does that warn us about trusting our good moments?
- 5
The people make Saul king “before the LORD.” What would it look like for those who lead in our homes and churches to lead “before the LORD”?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.