1 John · Epistles

1 John 3

See the Father’s love in making us His children; the children of God practice righteousness and love in deed.

3:1

“See what kind of love the Father has given to us, that we should be called children of God; and so we are. The reason why the world does not know us is that it did not know him.”

1 John 3:1, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–3Children of God nowAdopted now, made like Him when He appears
  2. 4–10Born of GodThe Son appeared to take away sin; His children do not live in it
  3. 11–15Not like CainHatred is murder at the root; love shows life
  4. 16–18Love definedChrist laid down His life; love opens the hand
  5. 19–24Greater than our heartAssurance before God, confidence in prayer, the Spirit given

The chapter in brief

John bursts out in wonder at the Father’s love: we are called children of God, “and so we are.” We are His children now, and though what we will be has not yet appeared, we know that when He appears we shall be like Him, for we shall see Him as He is; and everyone who hopes in Him purifies himself. John then contrasts the one who makes a practice of sinning with the one who practices righteousness. Christ appeared to take away sins and to destroy the works of the devil, and no one born of God keeps on sinning, because God’s seed abides in him. The children of God and the children of the devil are known by righteousness and by love. Cain, who was of the evil one, murdered his brother; whoever hates his brother is a murderer. But we know love by this: Christ laid down His life for us, and we ought to lay down our lives for the brothers, which begins with opening our hearts and hands to a brother in need. Such love reassures our hearts before God, who is greater than our heart and knows everything, and gives confidence in prayer. His commandment is that we believe in the name of His Son Jesus Christ and love one another, and the Spirit He has given assures us that He abides in us.

Every line of the chapter rests on what Christ has done. He appeared to take away sins and to destroy the devil’s works, fulfilling the first promise that the woman’s offspring would crush the serpent (Genesis 3:15). He laid down His life, and that act defines love. He will appear again, and the sight of Him will finish what His first appearing began. The new birth is the link between His work and our lives: those born of God share His family likeness. The chapter’s sharp lines between God’s children and the devil’s are not meant to frighten believers but to unmask teachers who said sin did not matter, and the chapter closes by comforting the believer whose own heart condemns him.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–3

And so we are

“See what kind of love” translates a word that means “of what sort” and that in older Greek meant “from what country.” Many readers hear in it a love foreign to anything the world knows. Being called God’s children is not a courtesy title; “and so we are.” The chapter holds two times together. “We are God’s children now” (v. 2), fully, already. But “what we will be has not yet appeared.” When He appears we shall be like Him, “because we shall see him as he is.” Seeing Christ finishes the work of making us like Him (2 Corinthians 3:18). Verse 3 draws the practical line: everyone who hopes in Him purifies himself, as He is pure. The hope does not wait passively; it begins now to resemble what it waits for. And the purifying is the fruit of being His children, never the price of it.

vv. 4–10

Cannot keep on sinning

These verses have troubled many tender consciences, so read them closely. “No one who abides in him keeps on sinning” (v. 6), and the one born of God “cannot keep on sinning” (v. 9). Three readings are common. Some have taken them to teach that a true Christian can reach sinless perfection, but John has already said that anyone who claims to be without sin deceives himself (1:8) and that believers who sin have an Advocate (2:1). Others take them as describing the new nature, which does not sin, as distinct from the old. Many read John’s present tenses, as the ESV does (“makes a practice,” “keeps on sinning”), of the settled direction of a life. This commentary reads them so: a believer still sins, and grieves, and confesses, but cannot settle at home in sin, because “God’s seed abides in him” (v. 9), the new life He has implanted by His Word and Spirit (1 Peter 1:23). The verses are aimed at teachers who said sin did not matter. They are no verdict on an anxious believer who fears they keep failing; the very grief over sin shows that God’s seed is alive in them. A person “of the devil” (v. 8) is at peace with his sin; a child of God is at war with it, and the Son appeared “to destroy the works of the devil.”

For discussion

How can a believer tell the difference between losing battles against sin and having made peace with it? Compare Romans 7:15-25 with Romans 8:1-4.

vv. 11–15

Not like Cain

Cain was “of the evil one” (v. 12), and the reason he killed Abel is chilling: “his own deeds were evil and his brother’s righteous.” Goodness exposed him, and he hated it. Jesus taught that anger and contempt are murder at the root (Matthew 5:21-22), and John says the same: whoever hates his brother is a murderer (v. 15). “No murderer has eternal life abiding in him” does not mean that a person who has taken a life can never be forgiven. Moses and David both had blood on their hands and were forgiven, and Paul once breathed “threats and murder” against the church (Acts 9:1). It means that settled, unrepented hatred cannot live alongside the life of God. So “do not be surprised” (v. 13) when the world hates you. It hated Christ first (John 15:18).

vv. 16–18

Love defined

“By this we know love, that he laid down his life for us” (v. 16). John does not define love by a feeling but by an event, the cross (John 15:13). And then, after the highest call (“we ought to lay down our lives for the brothers”), he descends at once to the ordinary: a brother in need, a person with “the world’s goods,” and a heart closed against him (v. 17). Few of us will be asked to die for a brother; most of us are asked to share. The word “heart” there is literally the inward parts, the seat of compassion. Love “in deed and in truth,” not only “in word or talk” (v. 18), is love that costs something.

vv. 19–24

Greater than our heart

Verse 20 has been read two ways. Some take it as a warning: if our own heart condemns us, God, who is greater and knows everything, condemns us all the more. But the context is reassurance (“reassure our heart before him,” v. 19), and many readers take it as comfort, as this commentary does: when our heart accuses us, God is greater than our heart. He knows everything, including the sins we fear and the love for Him that His Spirit has planted, and above all His Son’s finished work. Our assurance does not finally rest on how we feel about ourselves. Confidence in prayer follows (vv. 21-22). Receiving what we ask “because we keep his commandments” does not mean that obedience earns answers; it describes children whose wills are being shaped to their Father’s (John 15:7). And His commandment is one with two sides: believe in the name of His Son and love one another (v. 23). The Spirit He has given is His own witness that He abides in us (v. 24).

Threads across the chapter

  • He appeared. Christ appeared to take away sins (v. 5) and to destroy the devil’s works (v. 8), and He will appear again (v. 2).

  • Two families. Children of God and children of the devil (vv. 1, 10), Abel and Cain (v. 12), love and hatred (vv. 14-15) divide the chapter.

  • Born of God. The new birth (v. 9) explains why God’s children practice righteousness (vv. 7, 10) and love (v. 14).

  • “By this we know.” Love (v. 16), assurance of being of the truth (v. 19), and the Spirit’s witness (v. 24) give the believer grounds to know.

Key words

3:1–2, 10
τέκνα θεοῦ tekna theou“Children of God”; those born of Him, sharing His family likeness
3:4
ἀνομία anomia“Lawlessness”; sin as rebellion against God, not only a mistake
3:9
σπέρμα sperma“Seed”; the new life God implants, which abides
3:17
σπλάγχνα splanchna“Heart”; literally the inward parts, the seat of compassion

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does John put the Father’s love and our future likeness to Christ before his hard words about sinning?

  2. 2

    How would you explain verses 6 and 9 to a believer who fears they cannot be a Christian because they keep sinning?

  3. 3

    Why does John move straight from laying down our lives to sharing the world’s goods? What does that suggest about how love usually looks?

  4. 4

    When our heart condemns us, what does it mean in practice that “God is greater than our heart”?

  5. 5

    Who is a brother or sister in need near us, and what would love “in deed and in truth” look like this week?

My notes