1 Corinthians · Epistles

1 Corinthians 8

On food offered to idols, knowledge must yield to love, so as not to wound a weaker brother’s conscience.

Lechaeum, at sea levelFrom the harbor at Lechaeum up through Corinth to Acrocorinth, about 3 milesAcrocorinth, about 1,500 ft

8:6

“yet for us there is one God, the Father, from whom are all things and for whom we exist, and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom are all things and through whom we exist.”

1 Corinthians 8:6, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–3Knowledge and loveKnowledge puffs up; love builds up
  2. 4–6One God, one LordIdols are nothing; Christ is Creator
  3. 7–13The weak brotherFreedom yields to the one for whom Christ died

The chapter in brief

“Now concerning food offered to idols.” Much of the meat sold in a city like Corinth had passed through a temple, and social and civic life often met in temple dining rooms. Some Corinthians reasoned that because an idol is nothing and there is only one God, they were free to eat anything anywhere. Paul agrees with the theology but not with the conclusion. Knowledge puffs up, but love builds up. Not every believer has this knowledge: some, long used to idols, still eat such food as truly offered to an idol, and their weak conscience is defiled. If a believer with knowledge is seen eating in an idol’s temple, the weaker brother may be emboldened to do what his own conscience condemns, and so he is destroyed, “the brother for whom Christ died.” To sin against him is to sin against Christ. So Paul concludes that if food makes his brother stumble, he will never eat meat.

The chapter holds together two things the Corinthians had pulled apart: true doctrine and love. Its theology is high. Paul takes the confession at the heart of Israel’s faith, that the LORD is one (Deuteronomy 6:4), and confesses one God the Father and one Lord Jesus Christ, through whom all things were made. The Son is not a lesser god beside the Father; He is named within the one God’s confession, the Creator active from Genesis 1:1. Yet the same chapter measures knowledge by love, and the measure of love is the cross: the weak brother is one “for whom Christ died.” The one through whom all things exist gave Himself for the weakest believer, and that is why no believer may treat him as expendable.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–3

Knowledge and love

The ESV puts “all of us possess knowledge” in quotation marks, and many readers take it as another Corinthian slogan. Paul does not dispute it; he weighs it. Knowledge (gnōsis) inflates, but love (agapē) builds up, like a house rising stone on stone. Then he turns the question around: if anyone loves God, “he is known by God” (v. 3). The most important knowledge is not what we know about God but that God knows us, which is His gracious choice and claim (Galatians 4:9; 2 Timothy 2:19). That truth humbles the knower and leaves no room for the pride that looks down on a weaker believer.

vv. 4–6

One God, one Lord

Paul grants that an idol has no real existence and that there is no God but one, while acknowledging there are many so-called gods and lords in the world (and in 10:20 he will say that demons stand behind them). Then comes one of the high points of the New Testament’s teaching on Christ. The Shema confessed “The LORD our God, the LORD is one” (Deuteronomy 6:4). Many readers see Paul confessing that same oneness with Jesus inside it: one God, the Father, and one Lord, Jesus Christ. The Father is the one “from whom” all things are; the Son is the one “through whom” all things are (John 1:3; Colossians 1:16; Hebrews 1:2). The Son does not stand among the created things; all things were made through Him. This is the Christ of Genesis 1:1, the Word by whom the world was spoken into being, and He is the Lord the Corinthians serve at their table.

For discussion

How does verse 6 answer those who say Jesus was a great teacher but not God? Compare John 1:1-3 and Colossians 1:15-17.

vv. 7–13

The weak brother

The weak believer is not someone who merely dislikes what another does. He is a former idolater for whom eating sacrificed food still carries the meaning of worship, so that eating it would be, for him, an act against his own conscience. Paul’s concern is that the strong believer’s example might embolden him to act against his conscience (v. 10; the ESV’s “encouraged” renders the same verb as “build up” in verse 1, used with irony), and so he is “destroyed” (v. 11). Readers differ on how strong that word is, but Paul’s argument does not depend on settling it: the strong should treat the weak as Christ did, as someone worth dying for. Food itself does not commend us to God (v. 8); love does not demand that everyone else’s conscience be like ours.

This principle has sometimes been turned into a veto, as though anyone who disapproves of another believer’s freedom could forbid it by saying, “You make me stumble.” That is not Paul’s meaning. Stumbling here is being led into sin against one’s own conscience, not being offended. And where the gospel itself is at stake, Paul refuses to yield to those who would bind consciences (Galatians 2:3-5). The rule of verse 13 is a voluntary limit love places on itself, not a lever to be pulled on someone else.

For discussion

Paul says that to sin against a brother is to sin against Christ (v. 12). Where else does Scripture identify Christ with His people this way? Consider Acts 9:4 and Matthew 25:40.

Threads across the chapter

  • Knowledge measured by love. Knowledge that puffs up (vv. 1-2) is set against love that builds (v. 1) and that limits its own freedom for a brother (v. 13).

  • Known before knowing. Being known by God (v. 3) and confessing the one God and one Lord (v. 6) come before any knowledge the strong possess (vv. 1, 7).

  • Christ the Creator and the Crucified. The one through whom all things exist (v. 6) is the one who died for the weak brother (v. 11).

  • Conscience. The weak conscience is defiled (v. 7), emboldened (v. 10), and wounded (v. 12), and love protects it.

Key words

8:1
εἰδωλόθυτος eidōlothytos“Food offered to idols”; meat that had passed through a pagan sacrifice, the question that runs through chapters 8-10
8:1
γνῶσις gnōsis“Knowledge”; true but proud knowledge, which puffs up without love
8:1, 10
οἰκοδομέω oikodomeō“Build up”; what love does, and ironically what the strong do to the weak conscience in verse 10 (“encouraged”)
8:7
συνείδησις syneidēsis“Conscience”; the inner witness that a believer must not be led to violate

Cross-references

  • Deuteronomy 6:4The Shema, which Paul confesses with Jesus as the one Lord
  • John 1:1-3All things were made through the Word
  • Colossians 1:16-17By Him all things were created, and in Him all things hold together
  • Romans 14:13-23Paul’s fuller teaching on the strong and the weak
  • Acts 15:28-29The Jerusalem council’s word on food sacrificed to idols
  • Galatians 4:9Now that you have come to know God, or rather to be known by God
  • Galatians 2:3-5Paul refuses to yield where the gospel’s freedom is at stake
  • Romans 15:1-3The strong bear with the weak, for Christ did not please Himself

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why might Paul open his answer on idol food by contrasting knowledge and love, before he says a word about food?

  2. 2

    What does verse 6 teach about who Jesus is, and why would it matter at a Corinthian dinner table?

  3. 3

    What is the difference between causing a brother to stumble and simply doing something he dislikes?

  4. 4

    Where might our own “knowledge” about Christian freedom be puffing us up rather than building others up?

  5. 5

    What freedom might love ask us to set aside for a weaker believer in our family or church?

My notes