Matthew · Gospels & Acts

Matthew 15

Jesus exposes the traditions that nullify God’s Word, and shows mercy to a Canaanite woman’s faith.

Nazareth, about 1,150 ftDown from Nazareth to the Sea of Galilee (Matthew 4:13), about 21 milesCapernaum, about 650 ft below sea level

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–9Tradition of the eldersHuman tradition can nullify God’s command
  2. 10–20What defilesDefilement comes from the heart
  3. 21–28The Canaanite womanFaith pleads mercy, and is answered
  4. 29–31Healings on the mountainThe crowds glorify the God of Israel
  5. 32–39Feeding the four thousandThe Shepherd’s compassion feeds again

The chapter in brief

Pharisees and scribes come down from Jerusalem to ask why Jesus’ disciples break the tradition of the elders by eating with unwashed hands. Jesus turns the charge around: they break the commandment of God for the sake of their tradition, using a vow of dedication to escape the duty of honoring father and mother, and Isaiah’s words fit them, “This people honors me with their lips, but their heart is far from me.” He tells the crowd that what defiles a person comes out of the mouth, not what goes into it, and explains to the disciples that evil thoughts, murder, adultery, and the rest come from the heart. Then He withdraws to the district of Tyre and Sidon, where a Canaanite woman cries for mercy for her demonized daughter; after silence and two refusals, her answer about the crumbs under the table wins His praise, “O woman, great is your faith!” Returning to the Sea of Galilee, He heals the lame, blind, crippled, and mute, and feeds four thousand men, besides women and children, with seven loaves and a few small fish.

The chapter sets two kinds of religion side by side. The experts from Jerusalem have clean hands and distant hearts, and their tradition has made void the very Word they claim to guard. A Gentile woman from the old enemy country has nothing to bring but her need and her trust that the Son of David has enough mercy to spare a crumb. Jesus names the real problem as the heart itself: the source of defilement is inside us, and no washing reaches it. Only One who can make the heart clean can help, and He is already spreading a table that reaches beyond Israel, where even outsiders end up glorifying the God of Israel.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–9

The tradition of the elders

The washing in question is not hygiene but ritual purity, an extension of priestly washing laws to every meal, handed down in the oral “tradition of the elders.” Jesus does not argue about washing at all. He picks a case where tradition collides with the fifth commandment: a man declares his property dedicated to God, and the declaration conveniently frees him from supporting his parents. Mark 7:11 gives the technical word, Corban; Matthew gives only the formula, which is enough for his Jewish readers. The danger is not that tradition exists but that it slowly takes the place of God’s Word while looking like reverence for it. Isaiah 29:13 diagnoses the result: lips near, heart far.

For discussion

Where might a church’s habits, however good in themselves, begin to excuse disobedience to a plain command? Test it against Colossians 2:20-23.

vv. 10–20

What defiles

Jesus calls the crowd back to hear a principle, then explains it privately when Peter asks. Food passes through the body; the heart produces the list in verse 19, which follows the second table of the Ten Commandments (murder, adultery, theft, false witness). Matthew ends on the original question, eating with unwashed hands (v. 20), and does not add Mark’s editorial note that Jesus declared all foods clean (Mark 7:19). Each writer keeps his own emphasis: Mark, writing for Gentiles, draws out the consequence for food laws; Matthew stays with the dispute over tradition. The doctrinal weight is plain either way. The source of sin is within, so the remedy cannot be external. This is why the gospel promises a new heart (Ezekiel 36:26), not better rituals.

vv. 21–28

The Canaanite woman

Matthew alone calls her a “Canaanite,” the name of Israel’s ancient enemies in the land, though Mark’s “Syrophoenician” (Mark 7:26) was the usual term in his day. The old word sharpens the scandal. Yet she addresses Jesus as “Son of David,” which Israel’s teachers have just refused to do. Jesus’ silence and His words about the children’s bread and the dogs are hard to hear. Two things soften them without explaining them away. The word is the diminutive kynarion, household dogs under the table, and His mission really was to Israel first (v. 24; Romans 1:16). She does not dispute either point. She accepts her place and claims the mercy that falls even there. Jesus’ delay draws out a faith that He then praises publicly, the opposite of the Pharisees’ lip service.

For discussion

Was Jesus testing her faith, or revealing it to the disciples, or both? Compare the centurion in Matthew 8:5-13, the other Gentile whose faith Jesus singles out.

vv. 29–39

Healings and the second feeding

Jesus goes up on a mountain and sits, the posture of the Sermon on the Mount (Matthew 5:1). The crowds bring the lame, blind, crippled, and mute, fulfilling Isaiah 35:5-6, and “they glorified the God of Israel” (v. 31), a phrase that suggests a mixed or Gentile crowd, though Matthew does not say so outright. The feeding of the four thousand is not a retelling of the five thousand. The disciples’ question in verse 33 shows they have forgotten the first miracle already, which Jesus will press in Matthew 16:9-10. Some see the twelve baskets of Matthew 14 as pointing to Israel and the seven here to fullness or the nations; that is suggestive, not certain. What is certain is that the One who feeds His people in the wilderness is doing what only God did for Israel (Exodus 16).

Threads across the chapter

  • Lips and heart. The Pharisees honor God with their lips while their hearts are far (vv. 1-9), Jesus traces evil to the heart (vv. 10-20), and the Canaanite woman’s few words come from a heart that trusts Him (vv. 21-28).

  • Insiders and outsiders. The teachers from Jerusalem take offense (v. 12) while a Canaanite woman and a crowd by the sea glorify the God of Israel (vv. 21-31).

  • Bread. The disciples are accused over how they eat bread (v. 2), the woman asks for the crumbs of the children’s bread (vv. 26-27), and Jesus breaks bread for thousands (vv. 32-39).

  • Mercy that will not send people away. The disciples want the woman sent away (v. 23) and see no way to feed the crowd (v. 33); in both units Jesus does not send them away hungry (vv. 28, 32).

Key words

15:2–3
παράδοσις paradosis“Tradition”; what is handed down, here the oral rulings of the elders set beside God’s command
15:11, 15:18
κοινόω koinoō“Defile,” make common or unclean; the ritual category Jesus relocates to the heart
15:26–27
κυνάριον kynarion“Dogs,” the diminutive; household dogs under the table, which the woman turns into her plea

Cross-references

  • Mark 7:1-30The parallel, with Corban named and the note that Jesus declared all foods clean
  • Exodus 20:12The fifth commandment the tradition was undoing
  • Isaiah 29:13The prophet’s charge of lips near and heart far
  • Ezekiel 36:25-27God’s promise of a new heart and spirit, the remedy for defilement from within
  • Matthew 8:5-13The centurion, the other Gentile whose faith Jesus praises
  • Romans 1:16The gospel to the Jew first and also to the Greek
  • Isaiah 35:5-6The lame leap and the mute sing when God comes to save
  • Matthew 14:13-21The feeding of the five thousand the disciples have already forgotten

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why might Matthew place a dispute about clean hands right before Jesus travels into unclean Gentile territory?

  2. 2

    What does Jesus’ list in verse 19 tell us about where our own sin starts, and why can no outward practice fix it?

  3. 3

    Jesus’ silence toward the Canaanite woman troubles many readers. What does her persistence show about how faith treats God’s apparent silence?

  4. 4

    Which traditions in our own church or family life could quietly crowd out a plain command of Scripture?

  5. 5

    What does it mean that the woman asks only for crumbs, and what does that teach us about coming to Christ with nothing?

My notes