Matthew · Gospels & Acts

Matthew 16

Peter confesses Jesus as the Christ, and Jesus foretells His death and calls disciples to take up the cross.

Nazareth, about 1,150 ftDown from Nazareth to the Sea of Galilee (Matthew 4:13), about 21 milesCapernaum, about 650 ft below sea level

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–4Demand for a signOnly the sign of Jonah will be given
  2. 5–12Leaven of the Pharisees and SadduceesBeware their teaching; remember His provision
  3. 13–20Peter’s confessionThe Father reveals the Christ; Christ builds His church
  4. 21–23First passion predictionThe Christ must suffer, and Peter resists
  5. 24–28The cost of followingLosing life for Christ is finding it

The chapter in brief

The Pharisees and Sadducees, normally rivals, come together to test Jesus by asking for a sign from heaven. He tells them they can read the sky but not the signs of the times, and that no sign will be given to an evil and adulterous generation except the sign of Jonah. In the boat the disciples realize they forgot bread, and when Jesus warns them about the leaven of the Pharisees and Sadducees, they think He is talking about bread, until He reminds them of the two feedings and they understand He means their teaching. At Caesarea Philippi, Jesus asks who people say the Son of Man is, and then, “But who do you say that I am?” Peter answers, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.” Jesus calls him blessed, promises to build His church on this rock, and gives him the keys of the kingdom. From that time He begins to show His disciples that He must suffer, be killed, and be raised on the third day. Peter rebukes Him, and Jesus rebukes Peter, “Get behind me, Satan!” He then calls anyone who would follow Him to deny himself, take up his cross, and follow.

This is the hinge of Matthew’s Gospel. Everything so far has pressed the question of who Jesus is; now it is answered, and the answer is a revelation from the Father, not a human deduction. But the moment the right title is spoken, Jesus fills it with the cross. Peter can confess the Christ and still recoil from a crucified one, and in that recoil he speaks for Satan, who offered Jesus the kingdoms of the world without the cross (Matthew 4:8-9). The church Jesus builds rests on the confession of who He is, and it lives by the way He walks: through death to resurrection. The disciple loses his life by following, and finds it only in the One who first laid down His.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–4

Signs of the times

The Pharisees and Sadducees disagreed on almost everything, including the resurrection (Acts 23:8), yet they unite against Jesus. Their request for a sign “from heaven” asks for proof on their terms after a long string of healings and two feedings. Jesus’ answer repeats Matthew 12:39 almost word for word. In chapter 12 He explained the sign as three days and three nights in the heart of the earth; here He simply names it. The sign they will get is His death and resurrection, the one sign that will not compel belief from those who will not see.

vv. 5–12

The leaven

The disciples’ misunderstanding is almost comic: Jesus speaks of leaven and they inventory the bread. His rebuke is not mainly about the metaphor but about worry. Having watched Him feed five thousand and four thousand, they still fret over one forgotten loaf. Leaven works quietly and spreads through the whole lump (1 Corinthians 5:6-8). The teaching of the Pharisees (tradition over God’s Word, chapter 15) and the Sadducees (no resurrection, no angels) works the same way. Matthew notes that the disciples finally understand (v. 12), a sign that Jesus’ patience with slow disciples is part of His teaching.

vv. 13–20

The confession

Caesarea Philippi lay near a grotto dedicated to the god Pan and a temple Herod the Great built for Caesar Augustus. The setting sharpens the question of who is truly Lord. The crowds call Jesus a prophet, even a returned John, Elijah, or Jeremiah. Peter goes further: the Christ, and “the Son of the living God.” Jesus’ reply is the doctrinal center: “flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my Father who is in heaven.” Saving knowledge of Christ is a gift of grace, as Matthew 11:25-27 has already said. No one argues his way into it.

vv. 18–19

The rock and the keys

There is a play on words: Peter is Petros, the rock is petra. Readers have taken the rock as Peter himself, as Peter’s confession, or as Christ. This commentary leans toward Peter as the confessing apostle: the play on words points at him, and the New Testament describes the church as built on the foundation of the apostles and prophets with Christ as cornerstone (Ephesians 2:20). That reading gives no warrant for a line of successors. Peter is first among equals, and the binding and loosing given to him here is given to the whole church in Matthew 18:18. In Acts he opens the door to Jews (Acts 2) and to Gentiles (Acts 10). The Heidelberg Catechism (Q&A 83-85) names the keys as the preaching of the gospel and church discipline, which open and shut the kingdom by declaring what heaven has already settled. The main point holds on every reading: the church is Christ’s (“my church”), He builds it, and death itself cannot hold it.

For discussion

Who uses the keys today, and how? Compare Matthew 18:15-20 and John 20:22-23.

vv. 21–23

“Get behind me, Satan”

“From that time” (v. 21) marks a new stage, just as the same phrase did in Matthew 4:17. Jesus “must” go to Jerusalem: the necessity is the Father’s plan and the Scriptures (Isaiah 53). Peter, just called blessed, takes Jesus aside to rebuke Him. Jesus’ reply echoes His word to the devil in the wilderness (Matthew 4:10). Peter has become a skandalon, a stumbling stone, to the very rock he was named for. The shock is that the same disciple can speak by the Father’s revelation and then with Satan’s mind within a few verses. Right words about Jesus do not yet mean a heart that accepts His way.

vv. 24–28

The cross and the soul

Jesus spoke of taking up the cross in Matthew 10:38; now the call follows directly on the first announcement of His own. The call is not to self-improvement but to self-denial: to stop treating one’s own life as the thing to be saved. The logic is the exchange in verse 26: the whole world is worth less than one soul, and no one can buy his soul back. Christ alone will pay that price (Matthew 20:28). Verse 28 is debated. Some take it of the transfiguration that immediately follows, others of the resurrection or Pentecost. The transfiguration, six days later, is the most natural first fulfillment, a preview of the glory the Son of Man will show at His coming.

For discussion

How does denying ourselves for Christ differ from the moralism of “try harder”? Test it against Galatians 2:20.

Threads across the chapter

  • Seeing and not seeing. The leaders cannot read the signs of the times (vv. 1-4), the disciples misread the leaven (vv. 5-12), and Peter sees who Jesus is but not what He must do (vv. 13-23).

  • Revelation from the Father. The leaders demand a sign from heaven (v. 1) while Peter receives his confession from the Father in heaven (v. 17).

  • The rock and the stumbling stone. Peter is named the rock (v. 18) and, a few verses later, a stone to stumble over (v. 23).

  • The sign of Jonah and the third day. Jesus promises only the sign of Jonah (v. 4) and then spells it out as death and rising on the third day (v. 21).

Key words

16:18
πέτρα petra“Rock”; the wordplay with Peter’s name, Petros
16:18
ἐκκλησία ekklēsia“Church”; the assembly Jesus calls His own, the first use of the word in the Gospels
16:23
σκάνδαλον skandalon“Hindrance,” stumbling stone; what Peter becomes when he resists the cross

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does Jesus wait until this point in Matthew to ask, “Who do you say that I am?” and why tell of His death immediately after Peter answers?

  2. 2

    What does verse 17 teach about how anyone comes to know Jesus truly, and how should that shape the way we pray for those who don’t yet believe?

  3. 3

    Where are we most tempted, like Peter, to want Jesus without His cross?

  4. 4

    How do you read “this rock,” and what is at stake in the different readings for how we understand the church?

  5. 5

    What would it look like this week to “lose” our life for Christ’s sake in some ordinary place?

My notes