Mark · Gospels & Acts

Mark 12

The parable of the tenants, questions on taxes and resurrection, the greatest commandment, and the widow’s offering.

Nazareth, about 1,150 ftDown from Nazareth to the Sea of Galilee (Matthew 4:13), about 21 milesCapernaum, about 650 ft below sea level

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–12The wicked tenantsThe beloved son is killed and becomes the cornerstone
  2. 13–17Taxes to CaesarGive God what bears His image
  3. 18–27The resurrection questionGod is the God of the living
  4. 28–34The great commandmentLove God wholly and neighbor as self
  5. 35–37David’s son and LordThe Christ is more than David’s heir
  6. 38–40Beware the scribesPublic piety that preys on the weak
  7. 41–44The widow’s offeringShe gave all she had

The chapter in brief

In the temple courts Jesus tells the parable of a vineyard owner whose tenants beat and kill his servants and finally his beloved son, and He applies to Himself the psalm of the rejected stone that became the cornerstone. The leaders know the parable is about them. A series of challenges follows: Pharisees and Herodians ask about taxes to Caesar, Sadducees pose a riddle about the resurrection, and a scribe asks which commandment is first. Jesus answers each, then poses His own question about how the Christ can be David’s son when David calls Him Lord. He warns against scribes who devour widows’ houses, and as He watches the offering box He commends a poor widow who gives two small coins, all she had to live on.

The chapter answers the question that ended chapter 11: by what authority does He act? He is the beloved Son, the heir sent last, the cornerstone the builders reject. Every attempt to trap Him only reveals more of who He is and how little His questioners know of the Scriptures and the power of God. The scribe is told he is not far from the kingdom, and the throng hears Jesus gladly, but the leaders’ hostility is fixed. The chapter closes with a widow who gives everything, just before the Son gives Himself.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–12

The tenants

The details of the vineyard (hedge, winepress pit, tower) come from Isaiah 5:1-7, the song of the vineyard, so every hearer knew the vineyard was Israel. The servants are the prophets. Then the owner had still one other, “a beloved son,” the same word the Father spoke at the baptism and the transfiguration (Mark 1:11; 9:7). The tenants reason that killing the heir will give them the inheritance. Jesus answers the leaders’ question about His authority (Mark 11:28) by telling them who He is and what they will do to Him. Then He quotes Psalm 118:22-23: the stone the builders rejected has become the cornerstone. The rejection is not the end of the story; God makes the rejected Son the foundation of a new house.

vv. 13–17

Caesar’s coin

The trap is clever: say yes and lose the people, say no and be charged with sedition. Jesus asks for a denarius, which bore Caesar’s image and an inscription calling him son of the divine. “Whose likeness and inscription is this?” Then: “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar’s, and to God the things that are God’s.” Taxes are owed to the state (Romans 13:6-7), but the coin’s limit is the point. What bears Caesar’s image goes to Caesar. Many readers hear the implication: what bears God’s image, which is the human person (Genesis 1:27), belongs wholly to God. Because Caesar’s claim is limited, Romans 13 describes rulers as God’s servants for good and gives no ruler a warrant to do evil. Christians differ on what follows when a ruler turns tyrant. Some hold that a believer should refuse to sin and accept the penalty, and they are faithful brothers. This commentary holds that Christians may also resist a tyrant through lawful lesser authorities, especially to protect those in their care, because a tyrant’s abuse falls on the weak whom God calls His people to protect (Acts 5:29; Exodus 1:17).

For discussion

Where does Caesar’s claim end and God’s begin? Test the line against Acts 5:29 and 1 Peter 2:13-17.

vv. 18–27

The resurrection

The Sadducees accepted the books of Moses but denied the resurrection, and they use the levirate law (Deuteronomy 25:5-6) to make it look absurd. Jesus’ reply is blunt: “Is this not the reason you are wrong, because you know neither the Scriptures nor the power of God?” The life to come is not this life extended; there is no marrying there. And He argues from their own Moses: at the burning bush God called Himself the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob (Exodus 3:6), long after they died. God does not bind His name to the dead. The covenant itself requires resurrection.

vv. 28–34

The great commandment

Only Mark includes the opening of the Shema, “Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one” (Deuteronomy 6:4), and only Mark records the scribe’s warm reply that love is worth more than all burnt offerings (compare 1 Samuel 15:22; Hosea 6:6). Jesus tells him he is “not far from the kingdom of God.” Not far, but not in. The scribe has seen what the law asks; he has not yet seen that the One speaking to him is the only one who has ever kept it, and who will give His life for those who have not.

For discussion

Why is “not far from the kingdom” both a hopeful and a sobering verdict? Consider Romans 3:19-22.

vv. 35–37

David’s son and Lord

Now Jesus asks the question. Psalm 110:1 has David, speaking by the Holy Spirit, call the Messiah “my Lord.” No father calls his son lord. The Christ must be David’s descendant and yet greater than David, which only makes sense if He is the Son of God. Psalm 110 is among the Old Testament texts the New Testament quotes most often, and Jesus will cite it again before the high priest (Mark 14:62). The great throng heard Him gladly.

vv. 38–44

The scribes and the widow

Jesus warns against scribes who love long robes and best seats while they devour widows’ houses and make long prayers for show. Immediately a widow appears and puts in two small copper coins, everything she had. Readers split here. The usual reading hears pure commendation: God measures a gift by what it costs, not by its size. Others hear a lament as well: here is a widow whose house is being devoured, giving her last coins to a temple Jesus is about to say will be thrown down (Mark 13:2). This commentary holds both. Jesus truly honors her whole-hearted giving, and the setting condemns a religious system that would take it from her. Either way she gave all she had to live on, days before Jesus gave all He had, His very life.

Threads across the chapter

  • The beloved Son. The parable’s heir (vv. 6-8) is the Christ who is David’s Lord (vv. 35-37), the answer to the leaders’ question about authority.

  • Knowing the Scriptures. Jesus answers from Isaiah, Psalm 118, Exodus, Deuteronomy, and Psalm 110 (vv. 1-37), while His questioners misuse the very texts they cite.

  • What belongs to God. The coin with Caesar’s image (vv. 15-17), the whole heart, soul, mind, and strength (v. 30), and the widow’s whole living (v. 44) all ask what we owe to God.

  • Religion that devours. The tenants who seize the vineyard (vv. 7-8) and the scribes who devour widows’ houses (v. 40) are the same sin in two forms.

Key words

12:6
ἀγαπητός agapētos“Beloved”; the Father’s word for the Son at the baptism and transfiguration
12:16
εἰκών eikōn“Likeness, image”; Caesar’s image on the coin, God’s image on the person
12:10
κεφαλὴ γωνίας kephalē gōnias“Cornerstone”; the head of the corner, from Psalm 118:22
12:42
λεπτόν lepton“Small copper coin”; the smallest coin in circulation

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    How does the parable of the tenants answer the question about authority that closed chapter 11?

  2. 2

    What does the coin bearing Caesar’s image teach about what bears God’s image?

  3. 3

    Jesus told the scribe he was not far from the kingdom. What would it have taken for him to enter?

  4. 4

    Where are we tempted to use outward religion, as the scribes did, to gain standing with others?

  5. 5

    Is the widow’s offering mainly an example to follow, a warning about religious systems, or both? What do you think Jesus wanted His disciples to see?

My notes