Job · Wisdom & Poetry

Job 8

Bildad appeals to tradition, insisting God does not pervert justice and implying that Job’s children died for their sin.

8:3

“Does God pervert justice? Or does the Almighty pervert the right?”

Job 8:3, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–7Does God pervert justice?Your children sinned; seek God and be restored
  2. 8–10Ask the fathersTradition outweighs one man’s experience
  3. 11–19Papyrus and the spider’s webThe godless wither and fall
  4. 20–22God will not reject the blamelessLaughter is coming if you are upright

The chapter in brief

Bildad the Shuhite answers more bluntly. Job’s words are “a great wind” (v. 2). “Does God pervert justice? Or does the Almighty pervert the right?” (v. 3). “If your children have sinned against him, he has delivered them into the hand of their transgression” (v. 4). If Job will seek God and plead for mercy, and if he is pure and upright, God will rouse Himself and restore him, and his latter days will be very great. Bildad appeals to the fathers: “we are but of yesterday and know nothing” (v. 9), so ask the bygone ages. Papyrus without a marsh withers before any other plant; such are “the paths of all who forget God” (v. 13). The godless man’s trust is a spider’s web, his flourishing plant is torn from its place. “Behold, God will not reject a blameless man, nor take the hand of evildoers” (v. 20). God will yet fill Job’s mouth with laughter.

Bildad defends God’s justice, and he is right that God does not pervert it: “Shall not the Judge of all the earth do what is just?” (Genesis 18:25). His error is the shortcut from God’s justice to a verdict on Job’s children and on Job, as though justice must always be visible on our schedule. The reader knows that the children died under the Accuser’s blow, which God allowed for a purpose that was not punishment (2:3). Bildad’s own last promise, “God will not reject a blameless man” (v. 20), turns out to be truer than he knows. The blameless Son was “despised and rejected by men” (Isaiah 53:3) and bore the judgment our sins deserved, and God did not leave Him in the grave: “God raised him up, loosing the pangs of death” (Acts 2:24). Justice and mercy meet at the cross, not in Bildad’s formula.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–7

Justice and the children

Bildad’s question in verse 3 is right, and every believer must answer it the way he does: no, God does not pervert justice. But he moves straight from that truth to Job’s ten children: “If your children have sinned against him, he has delivered them into the hand of their transgression” (v. 4). The “if” is thin cover. He is telling a bereaved father that his children died for their sins. Chapter 1 has already shown Job praying for those children (1:5), and God’s own words in 2:3 deny that the disaster came as punishment. This verse is no verdict on any family who has lost a child. Jesus refused that reasoning about the dead (Luke 13:2-5), and so must we.

For discussion

How would you answer a grieving parent who has been told, or fears, that a child’s death was punishment? Begin with Job 2:3 and John 9:2-3.

vv. 8–10

The wisdom of the fathers

Bildad appeals to tradition: “inquire, please, of bygone ages” (v. 8). Tradition is a gift; Scripture tells God’s people to remember and to ask (Deuteronomy 32:7). But tradition is not infallible, and here it is used to overrule a man’s real situation. The book is not against the wisdom of the past; it is against any wisdom, old or new, that claims to know more than God has revealed. The Berean rule applies to the fathers too: the Word wins (Acts 17:11).

vv. 11–19

Papyrus and the spider’s web

The images are vivid and true in their place. Papyrus without water dies quickly; a man who forgets God leans on something as flimsy as a spider’s web (vv. 13-14); a flourishing plant can be torn out until its own place says, “I have never seen you” (v. 18). Psalm 1 says something similar. But Bildad’s hidden premise is that a man who has withered must have forgotten God. Job withered while remembering Him.

vv. 20–22

“God will not reject a blameless man”

Bildad means it as a condition: be blameless, and you will laugh again. The irony is that God has already called Job “blameless” (1:8; 2:3), and in the end God does fill Job’s mouth with good things (42:10-17), though not on Bildad’s terms. The deeper fulfillment is in Christ. He was the truly blameless One, and for a time it looked to every onlooker as though God had rejected Him (Isaiah 53:4). Yet the Father did not abandon His Holy One to corruption, and raised Him (Acts 2:24-27). Those who belong to Him are not rejected either, whatever they suffer: “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus” (Romans 8:1).

Threads across the chapter

  • Justice. God does not pervert justice (v. 3), will not reject the blameless (v. 20), and will clothe the enemies of the upright with shame (v. 22).

  • Conditions. “If your children have sinned” (v. 4), “If you will seek God” (v. 5), and “if you are pure and upright” (v. 6) frame Bildad’s whole speech as a formula.

  • Rootedness. Papyrus without a marsh (v. 11), a house that does not stand (v. 15), and roots torn from the stone heap (vv. 17-18) picture a life without God.

Key words

8:3
עָוַת avat“pervert”; to bend or make crooked; Bildad denies that God ever bends justice
8:3
מִשְׁפָּט mishpat“justice”; right judgment, the word that runs through the book’s legal debate
8:13
חָנֵף chanef“godless”; profane, one who has turned from God, the role Bildad quietly assigns to Job

Cross-references

  • Genesis 18:25“Shall not the Judge of all the earth do what is just?”
  • Job 1:5Job’s prayers and offerings for his children
  • Job 2:3God says Job was ruined “without reason”
  • Luke 13:2-5Not worse offenders than all the others
  • Psalm 1:3-4The tree by streams of water and the chaff
  • Isaiah 53:3-4Despised, rejected, and esteemed stricken by God
  • Acts 2:24God raised Him, loosing the pangs of death
  • Romans 8:1No condemnation in Christ Jesus

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    How does Bildad’s speech build on Eliphaz’s, and what does he add?

  2. 2

    Bildad is right that God does not pervert justice. Where exactly does his argument go wrong?

  3. 3

    What role should the wisdom of past generations play when it seems to collide with someone’s real experience?

  4. 4

    How do we hold firmly to God’s justice without using it to explain someone else’s tragedy?

  5. 5

    How does the cross show that God did not reject the blameless One, even when it looked as though He had?

My notes