4:17
“Can mortal man be in the right before God? Can a man be pure before his Maker?”
The chapter at a glance
The chapter in brief
Eliphaz the Temanite speaks first, carefully: “If one ventures a word with you, will you be impatient?” (v. 2). He reminds Job that he has instructed many and strengthened weak hands, but now that trouble has touched him he is dismayed. Should not his fear of God be his confidence? Then he states his principle: “Remember: who that was innocent ever perished? Or where were the upright cut off?” (v. 7). Those who plow iniquity reap trouble. He tells of a word that came to him “stealthily” in the night: dread, trembling, a spirit gliding past his face, a form he could not make out, and a voice: “Can mortal man be in the right before God? Can a man be pure before his Maker?” (v. 17). If God puts no trust even in His servants and charges His angels with error, how much more those who dwell in houses of clay, crushed like the moth.
Eliphaz is the most courteous of the friends, and much of what he says is true. No mortal is righteous before God (Romans 3:23), and people do reap what they sow (Galatians 6:7). His error is in the application. He turns a true principle into a formula, reads the formula backward from Job’s suffering to Job’s guilt, and supports it with a private experience no one can test. God will say of him, “you have not spoken of me what is right, as my servant Job has” (42:7). The gospel answers Eliphaz’s best question better than he could: a man can be in the right before God, not by his own purity but because God is “just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus” (Romans 3:26). And the innocent did perish: Abel, the prophets, and above all the Righteous One, whom God raised from the dead (Acts 2:24).
Points for discussion
vv. 1–6
Kind words with a sting
Eliphaz begins well. He honors Job’s past ministry: “you have strengthened the weak hands” (v. 3). But the compliment carries a rebuke: you comforted others, and now you cannot take your own medicine (v. 5). Verse 6 sounds like encouragement, asking whether Job’s “fear of God” is not his “confidence,” but it sets up the argument that follows. If Job is truly God-fearing, he has nothing to fear; if he is suffering, something must be wrong. Comfort that starts by correcting the sufferer’s reaction to pain has already gone astray (6:26).
vv. 7–11
The retribution formula
“Who that was innocent ever perished?” (v. 7) is meant to be unanswerable, and the reader knows it is false, because chapter 1 has just shown an innocent man ruined. Eliphaz has taken something true, that God judges sin and that sowing and reaping are real (Galatians 6:7), and made it a rule that runs both ways and on a short schedule: if you suffer, you sowed it. Jesus rejected exactly that inference: the Galileans killed by Pilate and the eighteen crushed by the tower were not “worse offenders than all the others” (Luke 13:2-5), and the man born blind was not blind because “this man sinned, or his parents” (John 9:2-3).
For discussion
Where do Christians still reason like Eliphaz, assuming that illness, loss, or a child’s wandering must trace back to a particular sin? What do Luke 13:1-5 and John 9:1-3 say to that?
vv. 12–21
The night vision
This is the most eerie passage in the book: a word that came “stealthily,” a spirit that glided past, a form he could not discern, and silence before the voice. Readers weigh it differently. Some take it as a genuine message from God, since its content is largely true (v. 17; compare 9:2; 15:14; 25:4). Others notice that it is vague, frightening, secret, and used to support a conclusion God later rejects (42:7), and ask whether Eliphaz has dressed his own theology in a vision. This commentary does not settle the source, but it notes the method. Eliphaz’s authority rests on a private experience that no one else can test, and he uses it to press guilt on a sufferer. Scripture tells us to test what claims to be revelation (1 John 4:1), and to test it by the Word God has given (Isaiah 8:20).
vv. 17–21
Houses of clay
The voice’s question, “Can mortal man be in the right before God?” is the right question; Job will ask it himself (9:2). Human beings are “those who dwell in houses of clay, whose foundation is in the dust” (v. 19), and God knows it: “he remembers that we are dust” (Psalm 103:14). But Eliphaz uses human frailty to crush rather than to comfort. The gospel takes the same truth and turns it to mercy: the One who made us from dust took our flesh, so that sinners might be counted righteous in Him (2 Corinthians 5:21).
Threads across the chapter
Fear and confidence. Job’s “fear of God” is his confidence (v. 6), while the vision brings “dread” and “trembling” (v. 14).
True words, wrong use. Sowing and reaping (v. 8) and human impurity before God (v. 17) are true, and both are pressed into a verdict on Job (vv. 5-7).
Frailty. Weak hands and feeble knees (vv. 3-4), the lion’s broken teeth (vv. 10-11), and houses of clay crushed like the moth (v. 19).
Key words
- 4:6
- יִרְאָה yir'ah“fear”; the Hebrew lacks “of God” (ESV footnote), but the sense is the reverent fear of 1:1
- 4:7
- נָקִי naqi“innocent”; clean, free of guilt; Eliphaz denies that such a one ever perishes
- 4:17
- צָדַק tsadaq“be in the right”; a legal word for being in the right before a judge, the question the whole book argues
Cross-references
- Job 42:7God’s verdict on Eliphaz and his friends
- Luke 13:2-5Not worse sinners than all the others
- John 9:2-3“It was not that this man sinned, or his parents”
- Galatians 6:7Whatever one sows, that will he also reap
- Psalm 103:14He remembers that we are dust
- Romans 3:26God just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus
- 1 John 4:1Test the spirits
- Acts 2:24God raised up the One who was put to death
- 1
Eliphaz speaks first and most gently. Why might the book put the most reasonable friend first?
- 2
Which of Eliphaz’s statements are true, and where exactly does his reasoning go wrong?
- 3
How should we weigh someone’s claim to a private message from God, especially when it is used to judge another person?
- 4
When you are suffering, what kind of comfort has helped you, and what kind has hurt?
- 5
How does the gospel answer the question of verse 17 in a way Eliphaz could not?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.