15:11
“Are the comforts of God too small for you, or the word that deals gently with you?”
The chapter at a glance
The chapter in brief
Eliphaz opens the second cycle of speeches, and his early courtesy (chapter 4) is gone. Job’s words, he says, are “windy knowledge,” unprofitable talk that is “doing away with the fear of God”; his own mouth condemns him. Eliphaz asks whether Job thinks himself the first man born or a hearer in the council of God, reminds him that the gray-haired are on the friends’ side, and accuses him of turning his spirit against God when he has been offered “the comforts of God.” He repeats the lesson of his night vision (4:17-19): no man is pure before God, who does not even trust His holy ones. Then he paints at length the inner torment and certain ruin of the wicked man who stretches out his hand against God.
Much of what Eliphaz says is true, and that is what makes the chapter dangerous. No one is pure before God, guilt does haunt the wicked, and sin is barren. But Eliphaz uses these truths to read a verdict into a sufferer’s pain, and he calls his own reading “the word that deals gently with you.” The reader, who has seen the heavenly council of chapters 1-2, knows that his diagnosis is false (42:7). The chapter points to Christ by contrast: Eliphaz has the doctrine of human impurity with no remedy in it, while the gospel takes that same truth and answers it, for sinners “are justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus” (Romans 3:24). And it points to Him as the true Comforter, who does not crush the bruised reed (Matthew 12:20).
Points for discussion
vv. 1–6
Windy words
Eliphaz now calls Job’s speech “the east wind,” the hot desert wind that withers everything and nourishes nothing. His gravest charge is in verse 4: Job is “doing away with the fear of God” (the ESV notes that the Hebrew lacks “of God”). That is the very thing the narrator and the LORD credited to Job at the start, a man “who fears God and turns away from evil” (1:8). Eliphaz then reasons from words to heart: “your iniquity teaches your mouth” (v. 5). There is a true principle here, for the mouth does speak out of the heart (Matthew 12:34), but Eliphaz turns it into a way of making a sufferer’s cries of pain into evidence against him. Raw lament is not the same thing as impiety. The Psalms are full of it, and in the end the LORD says that Job, not Eliphaz, spoke of Him what is right (42:7).
vv. 7–16
The council of God
“Have you listened in the council of God?” (v. 8). The reader has, in a sense: chapters 1-2 drew back the curtain on the heavenly council where Job’s trial was set, and neither Job nor Eliphaz was there. The question cuts against the man asking it. Eliphaz’s own authorities are the aged among the friends (v. 10) and his vision, closely echoed from 4:17-19 (vv. 14-16). Then comes verse 11: he calls his counsel “the comforts of God” and “the word that deals gently with you.” Here is the danger every counselor faces, confusing a reading of someone else’s life with God’s own Word. That confusion is how Scripture becomes a weapon, and this commentary names it plainly: a true doctrine pressed on a hurting person to prove a charge God has not made bears false witness about God. The doctrine of verses 14-16 is sound (Romans 3:23). What is missing is any door of mercy in it.
vv. 17–35
The wicked man’s torment
The long portrait has real truth in it: the wicked do live with “dreadful sounds” in their ears (v. 21), and those who “conceive trouble and give birth to evil” (v. 35) reap what they sow (compare Psalm 7:14; James 1:15). But the details are aimed. “In prosperity the destroyer will come upon him” (v. 21) and “fire consumes the tents of bribery” (v. 34) sound very like Job’s own losses (1:16-19). Eliphaz is wrong twice: as a rule, because the wicked often prosper, which Job will answer in chapter 21; and as a diagnosis of this man. Christians make the same mistake whenever they assume that illness, loss, or grief must reveal a hidden sin. Jesus refused that reasoning (John 9:2-3; Luke 13:2-3), and so must we.
Threads across the chapter
Who speaks for God. Eliphaz claims the fear of God (v. 4), the council of God (v. 8), and the comforts of God (v. 11), while the reader knows from chapters 1-2 that God has said the opposite about Job.
True words, wrong target. The doctrine of human impurity (vv. 14-16) and the portrait of the wicked (vv. 17-35) are true in themselves and false as a verdict on Job.
The fear of God. Eliphaz says Job has abandoned it (v. 4); the prologue (1:1, 8) and the hymn of chapter 28 (28:28) say it is the very heart of wisdom, and Job’s.
Key words
- 15:2
- דַּעַת־רוּחַ da'at-ruach“Windy knowledge”; knowledge that is only air, Eliphaz’s dismissal of Job’s words
- 15:8
- סוֹד sod“Council”; the intimate circle of counsel, ironic after the heavenly scene of chapters 1-2
- 15:34
- חָנֵף chaneph“Godless”; the profane man, a word the friends keep pointing at Job
Cross-references
- Job 1:8The LORD’s own testimony that Job fears God and turns away from evil
- Job 4:17-19Eliphaz’s night vision, repeated in verses 14-16
- Job 42:7The LORD’s verdict that the friends did not speak of Him what is right
- Romans 3:23-24All have sinned, and are justified by grace through the redemption in Christ
- Matthew 12:34Out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaks
- John 9:2-3Jesus refuses to trace a man’s blindness to his sin
- Psalm 88A lament that Scripture itself preserves as prayer
- 1
Eliphaz began gently in chapter 4; what has changed by chapter 15, and why do arguments with sufferers so often harden this way?
- 2
Eliphaz calls his own counsel “the comforts of God” (v. 11). How can we tell the difference between sharing God’s Word with a hurting friend and using it against them?
- 3
Which of Eliphaz’s statements are true in themselves, and what makes them false as he uses them?
- 4
When someone we love suffers, what assumptions about the reason do we carry, and where did we learn them?
- 5
How does the gospel’s answer to “What is man, that he can be pure?” (v. 14) differ from Eliphaz’s?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.