Hosea · Minor Prophets

Hosea 1

Hosea marries Gomer, and their children’s names signify judgment on unfaithful Israel.

1:10

“Yet the number of the children of Israel shall be like the sand of the sea, which cannot be measured or numbered. And in the place where it was said to them, ’You are not my people,’ it shall be said to them, ’Children of the living God.’”

Hosea 1:10, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1The superscriptionA prophet to Israel across four Judean reigns
  2. 2–3“A wife of whoredom”The prophet’s marriage mirrors the land’s unfaithfulness
  3. 4–5JezreelJudgment on Jehu’s house and Israel’s bow broken
  4. 6–7No MercyMercy withdrawn from Israel; Judah saved by the LORD
  5. 8–9Not My PeopleThe covenant formula reversed
  6. 10–11Children of the living GodThe names undone; one people under one head

The chapter in brief

The book opens by placing Hosea son of Beeri in the days of four kings of Judah, Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz, and Hezekiah, and of Jeroboam son of Joash, king of Israel (v. 1), a ministry of several decades in the eighth century BC to the northern kingdom in its last prosperous years. The LORD’s first command to him has troubled readers ever since: “Go, take to yourself a wife of whoredom and have children of whoredom, for the land commits great whoredom by forsaking the LORD” (v. 2). Hosea marries Gomer, the daughter of Diblaim, and three children are born. Each receives a name that is a sermon. Jezreel announces judgment on the house of Jehu for the blood shed at Jezreel and the end of the northern kingdom (vv. 4-5). Lo-ruhamah, “No Mercy,” declares that God will no longer have mercy on Israel, though He will save Judah, and not by bow or sword or horsemen (vv. 6-7). Lo-ammi, “Not My People,” pronounces the covenant broken: “you are not my people, and I am not your God” (v. 9). Then, without warning, the darkness breaks. Israel will be as numberless as the sand of the sea, and where it was said, “You are not my people,” it will be said, “Children of the living God.” Judah and Israel will be gathered under one head, “for great shall be the day of Jezreel” (vv. 10-11).

The chapter sets the pattern of the whole book: a household that preaches, a judgment that is real, and a promise that refuses to stay buried under it. The names are not God’s final verdict on His people; they are the sentences He means to reverse. The New Testament takes up that reversal directly. Paul quotes verse 10 with Hosea 2:23 to show that God has called a people “not from the Jews only but also from the Gentiles” (Romans 9:24-26), and Peter tells scattered believers that they who once were not a people are now God’s people (1 Peter 2:10). The “one head” under whom God’s divided people are gathered (v. 11) is, in the light of Hosea 3:5, the coming King from David’s line, and the gospel names Him: Jesus Christ, in whom God gathers His children from every nation into one (John 11:51-52; Ephesians 1:10).

Points for discussion

v. 1

A prophet to the north, dated by the south

Hosea preached to Israel, the northern kingdom, yet the superscription lists four kings of Judah and only one king of Israel, Jeroboam II. The six northern kings who followed Jeroboam, four of them assassinated (2 Kings 15), are passed over in silence; many readers take the silence as a judgment on their claim to the throne (compare 8:4, “They made kings, but not through me”). Many readers also take the list as a sign that the book was gathered and kept in Judah after Samaria fell in 722 BC. This commentary reads the book with its traditional authorship, as the words of Hosea son of Beeri, written in his own lifetime or gathered from his ministry. Some scholars hold that later editors in Judah shaped the book and added the references to Judah; that view is held by careful readers and is named here with respect, but the book presents itself as one prophet’s message, and the New Testament quotes it as Hosea’s (Romans 9:25).

vv. 2–3

“A wife of whoredom”

Faithful interpreters have read this command in three main ways. Some take it as a real marriage to a woman already known for unfaithfulness, perhaps one caught up in the sexual rites of Baal worship. Others take it as a real marriage to a woman who later proved unfaithful, so that “wife of whoredom” describes her as Hosea came to know her; the opening words, “When the LORD first spoke through Hosea,” suggest the account was written looking back. Still others read chapters 1 and 3 as a vision or a parable told in action rather than lived. This commentary reads it as a real marriage: Gomer is named with her father, the children are born in order, and the book’s force rests on a prophet who felt what he preached. Whether she was unfaithful before the wedding or after, the main point holds either way: God called His prophet to carry in his own home the grief God bears over His people. “Children of whoredom” does not blame the children; it names the household they were born into, as every Israelite was born into an unfaithful nation. A care line belongs here. The marriage is a picture of God’s covenant with His people, in which the unfaithful party is Israel; it is not a rule for any human marriage, and Hosea’s costly faithfulness is no pattern for staying in danger in a marriage today. No one should read this passage as a command to remain in danger. A person being harmed should seek safety, the church’s help, and, where a crime is involved, the civil authorities.

For discussion

Why might God teach His people through a prophet’s household rather than through words alone? Compare Isaiah 8:18 and Ezekiel 24:15-24.

vv. 4–5

Jezreel

The first son’s name points to a place and an event. At Jezreel, Jehu had wiped out the house of Ahab at the LORD’s command (2 Kings 9-10), and God had even commended him (2 Kings 10:30). So why judge Jehu’s house “for the blood of Jezreel”? Readers answer in two ways. Some see Jehu going beyond the command, killing for his own throne with a zeal that was more for himself than for God, and the text adds that he “was not careful to walk in the law of the LORD” with all his heart (2 Kings 10:31). Others take “the blood of Jezreel” more broadly, as the bloodshed on which the dynasty was founded and by which the northern throne kept changing hands. Either way, a command obeyed in the wrong spirit does not make the servant righteous. Jehu’s dynasty ended when his great-great-grandson Zechariah was murdered after six months (2 Kings 15:8-12). The name Jezreel means “God sows,” and the book will turn that meaning from scattering to planting (1:11; 2:22-23).

vv. 6–7

No Mercy, and Judah spared

The daughter’s name, Lo-ruhamah, is built on the word for tender, motherly compassion. Some readers notice that Hosea is said to father the first child (“bore him a son,” v. 3) but not the second and third, and wonder whether they were his; the text does not say, and it is wiser not to build on its silence. Verse 7 sets Judah apart: God will save Judah “by the LORD their God,” not by weapons. Many readers see this fulfilled when the Assyrian army fell outside Jerusalem in Hezekiah’s day without a battle (2 Kings 19:35). The principle reaches further: salvation belongs to the LORD, and it is never won by the strength of those He saves (Psalm 20:7; Zechariah 4:6).

vv. 8–9

Not My People

The third name reverses the covenant formula God gave at Sinai, “I will take you to be my people, and I will be your God” (Exodus 6:7). The Hebrew of verse 9 reads literally “I am not EHYEH to you,” and many readers hear in it the name God gave at the bush, I AM (Exodus 3:14). If so, the sentence is as severe as any in the prophets: the God who bound Himself to Israel by His name now names the bond broken.

vv. 10–11

Children of the living God

The promise comes before any repentance is recorded. God returns to His promise to Abraham, descendants like the sand (Genesis 22:17), and says that in the very place where “Not my people” was spoken, “Children of the living God” will be spoken instead. Its first meaning is the restoration of the scattered northern tribes. Paul sees the same mercy reaching the Gentiles: the God who can make “not my people” His people can do it for the nations (Romans 9:25-26). That reading does not cancel God’s faithfulness to Israel, and it gives no ground for contempt toward Jewish people; Paul himself insists that “the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable” (Romans 11:29). “One head” (v. 11) points ahead to “David their king” (3:5) and, many readers see, to the gathering of God’s people under Christ.

Threads across the chapter

  • Names that preach. Jezreel, No Mercy, and Not My People (vv. 4-9) are announced and then begin to be reversed (vv. 10-11).

  • Whoredom and covenant. The prophet’s marriage (vv. 2-3) mirrors the land forsaking the LORD, and the broken covenant formula (v. 9) states it plainly.

  • Salvation from the LORD. Judah saved without bow or sword (v. 7) and Israel made “children of the living God” (v. 10) are both God’s work, not human strength.

  • Jezreel, scattering and sowing. The place of bloodshed (vv. 4-5) becomes “the day of Jezreel,” a day of gathering (v. 11).

Key words

1:2
זְנוּנִים zenunim“whoredom”; sexual unfaithfulness, and in the prophets a picture of idolatry as betrayal of the covenant
1:4, 11
יִזְרְעֶאל Yizre'el“Jezreel”; “God sows,” a place of bloodshed whose name becomes a promise of planting
1:6
לֹא רֻחָמָה Lo-ruchamah“No Mercy”; from the root of tender, womb-like compassion
1:9
לֹא עַמִּי Lo-ammi“Not My People”; the covenant formula of Exodus 6:7 reversed

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    The book opens with judgment named in three children and ends the chapter with a promise. Why do you think God puts the promise so early, before Israel has repented?

  2. 2

    What does the command to Hosea (v. 2) tell us about how God feels the unfaithfulness of His people?

  3. 3

    Jehu did what God commanded and was still judged (v. 4). What does that teach about obeying God with a divided heart?

  4. 4

    Paul and Peter apply “Children of the living God” to believers from the nations. How does it change the way you see yourself to know that God’s mercy found you where “Not my people” had been spoken?

  5. 5

    Readers differ on whether Gomer was unfaithful before or after the marriage, and on whether it was a vision. Why does the main point hold on any of these readings?

My notes