Hebrews · Epistles

Hebrews 5

Christ is a high priest appointed by God after the order of Melchizedek; a warning against spiritual dullness.

5:8

“Although he was a son, he learned obedience through what he suffered.”

Hebrews 5:8, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–4Every high priestTaken from among men, gentle, and called by God
  2. 5–6Christ appointedThe Father who names Him Son names Him priest
  3. 7–10The days of His fleshHe learned obedience and became the source of salvation
  4. 11–14Dull of hearingMilk for children, solid food for the trained

The chapter in brief

Chapter 5 begins to explain the great High Priest of 4:14-16. Every high priest is chosen from among men, deals gently with the ignorant and wayward because he is beset with weakness himself, and does not take the honor for himself but is called by God, as Aaron was. So Christ did not exalt Himself. The God who said to Him, “You are my Son,” also said, “You are a priest forever, after the order of Melchizedek.” In the days of His flesh He offered prayers with loud cries and tears, and although He was a son He learned obedience through what He suffered; being made perfect, He became the source of eternal salvation to all who obey Him. Then the author stops short. He has much to say about Melchizedek, but his hearers have become dull of hearing, needing milk when they ought to be teachers.

The chapter sets the terms for the long argument of chapters 7 to 10. A priest must be one of us, must be gentle, and must be called by God, and Jesus fits each test in a way no son of Aaron could. He is one of us, for He took our flesh and prayed with tears. He is gentle, not because He shares our sin, but because He has walked the road of obedience through suffering. And He is called, by the same Father who declares Him Son. The last unit turns the light on the hearers: the trouble is not that Christ’s priesthood is too hard to grasp, but that they have stopped growing. So the chapter is both doctrine and diagnosis, and the cure for the second is more of the first.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–4

What a high priest is

The author gives three marks of a priest under the old covenant. He is chosen “from among men” to act for men toward God. He “can deal gently with the ignorant and wayward,” and the verb (metriopatheō) means to keep one’s feelings in measure, neither harsh toward the sinner nor indulgent toward the sin. And he is called by God, as Aaron was (Exodus 28:1). Israel’s history showed what happened to those who reached for the office uncalled: Korah’s rebellion (Numbers 16) and King Uzziah struck with leprosy in the temple (2 Chronicles 26:16-21). The phrase “ignorant and wayward” may reflect the law’s line between unintentional sins, for which sacrifice was provided, and sins done “with a high hand” (Numbers 15:27-31). Christ fits the pattern with one great difference: the old priest offered first “for his own sins” (v. 3), and Christ has none (Hebrews 4:15; 7:27).

vv. 5–6

Appointed, not self-exalted

The author sets two psalms side by side. Psalm 2:7, “You are my Son, today I have begotten you” (v. 5), was already quoted in 1:5, and Psalm 110:4 now adds, “You are a priest forever, after the order of Melchizedek” (v. 6). The same voice speaks both: the Father who declares the Son also installs Him as priest. As at 1:5, “today I have begotten you” is not the moment the Son began to be the Son. He is eternally the Son, “begotten, not made,” and the psalm speaks of the Father’s public declaration and installation of the incarnate Son in His saving office, which the apostles tie to the resurrection (Acts 13:33; Romans 1:4). Psalm 110 also joins king and priest in one person (Psalm 110:1, 4), something the law kept apart, and Zechariah 6:13 had looked for “a priest on his throne.”

v. 7

Prayers with loud cries and tears

Many readers hear Gethsemane here (Mark 14:32-36; Luke 22:39-46), though the author may have in mind the whole of Jesus’ praying life in “the days of his flesh.” He prayed to the One “able to save him from death,” and “he was heard because of his reverence.” But He died. Readers answer the puzzle in two ways. Some take His prayer to be heard as He Himself framed it, “not what I will, but what you will” (Mark 14:36). Others note that the Greek can mean saved out of death, not kept from dying, and that the answer was the resurrection. Both readings are true to the gospel. Either way, the One who now sympathizes with our weakness (4:15) knows from the inside what it is to pray in anguish and to wait on the Father.

vv. 8–10

“He learned obedience” and “being made perfect”

These verses must be read with care, and the author himself supplies the guardrails. “Although he was a son” tells us this was not expected: the Son is not someone who needs to be taught. What He learned, He learned “in the days of his flesh” (v. 7) and “through what he suffered” (v. 8), which belong to His human nature. He did not move from disobedience to obedience, for He was “without sin” (4:15). He learned, as a true man, what obedience costs when it leads to a cross, and He walked it to the end (Philippians 2:8). “Being made perfect” (teleioō) is the same thought. It does not mean He was morally flawed and improved, or that His deity gained anything. It means He was brought to completion as our Mediator and fitted for His office through suffering (2:10). As at 2:10, the verb may also carry the sense of a priest’s consecration. This is why the letter can call Him “a Son who has been made perfect forever” (7:28) and also “the same yesterday and today and forever” (13:8). The Son never changed in who He is. His human obedience and His exaltation as Mediator belong to the saving office He took up for us.

Some Reformed brothers hold that the Son eternally submits to the Father in role, and they read verses like this one as a window onto that. This commentary reads Hebrews 5:8 the classic Nicene way: the verse itself ties the Son’s learning of obedience to His flesh and His suffering, so it speaks of the incarnate Mediator, the God-man in His saving work, and never makes the Son less than the Father.

The result is that He became “the source of eternal salvation to all who obey him” (v. 9). The obedience in view is the obedience of faith (Romans 1:5). Hebrews has just set disobedience and unbelief side by side as the same failure (3:18-19), so to obey Him here is to trust Him. His obedience is the ground of salvation; ours is the response.

For discussion

If Christ learned obedience through suffering, what does that say about the believer who suffers? Compare Hebrews 12:2-3 and 1 Peter 2:21-24, and notice that His suffering saves while ours only follows.

vv. 11–14

Milk and solid food

The author breaks off: “About this we have much to say,” but his hearers have become “dull of hearing.” The word (nōthros, sluggish) returns in 6:12, framing the warning that follows. The rebuke is not aimed at new believers, who rightly need milk (1 Peter 2:2). It is aimed at those who by now “ought to be teachers” and have stopped growing. The measure of maturity is not how much one knows but discernment “trained by constant practice to distinguish good from evil” (v. 14); the verb gives us “gymnasium.” Notice what the author does next. He does not wait for them to be ready. After the warning of chapter 6 he goes on to Melchizedek (6:20; 7:1), because solid food is itself the cure for a dull appetite, and the solid food is Christ’s priesthood.

Threads across the chapter

  • Called, not grasping. Aaron did not take the honor for himself (vv. 1-4), and neither did Christ, who was appointed by the Father (vv. 5-6, 10).

  • Weakness and gentleness. The old priest was gentle because he shared the people’s weakness (v. 2); Christ is gentle because He prayed with tears and suffered as a true man, yet without sin (vv. 7-8).

  • Son and priest. The two psalms of verses 5-6 meet in verses 8-10, where the Son learns obedience and is designated high priest.

  • Growth. The perfecting of the Mediator (v. 9) stands against the stalled growth of the hearers (vv. 11-14), and only the first can cure the second.

Key words

5:2
μετριοπαθέω metriopatheō“Deal gently”; to keep one’s feelings in measure, neither harsh nor indulgent toward the wayward
5:9
τελειόω teleioō“Make perfect”; to bring to completion or fit for an office, never moral improvement in the Son
5:11; 6:12
νωθρός nōthros“Dull,” “sluggish”; the word that frames the warning of 5:11-6:12
5:12
στοιχεῖα stoicheia“Basic principles”; the ABCs, the first letters of the faith

Cross-references

  • Exodus 28:1Aaron and his sons called to serve as priests
  • Numbers 16:1-11Korah reaches for a priesthood God had not given him
  • Psalm 2:7“You are my Son,” the declaration quoted in verse 5
  • Psalm 110:4The oath that makes the king a priest forever after Melchizedek
  • Mark 14:32-36Jesus prays in Gethsemane, “not what I will, but what you will”
  • Philippians 2:6-8He humbled Himself by becoming obedient to the point of death
  • Hebrews 4:14-16The hinge this chapter unfolds: a high priest who sympathizes with our weakness
  • 1 Corinthians 3:1-3Paul too must feed with milk those who should be ready for solid food

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does the author unfold the “great high priest” of 4:14-16 by first describing what every high priest under the law had to be?

  2. 2

    How can the eternal Son have “learned obedience” and be “made perfect” without ever being less than God or changing in who He is?

  3. 3

    What comfort is there in knowing that Jesus prayed “with loud cries and tears,” and how should it shape the way we pray in anguish?

  4. 4

    By the measure of verse 14, where are we still living on milk, and what would “constant practice” look like for us?

  5. 5

    Why might the author keep teaching the hard thing to people he has just called dull, instead of waiting until they are ready?

My notes