2 Samuel · Historical Books

2 Samuel 21

A famine for Saul’s bloodguilt is ended, and Israel battles Philistine giants.

21:10

“Then Rizpah the daughter of Aiah took sackcloth and spread it for herself on the rock, from the beginning of harvest until rain fell upon them from the heavens. And she did not allow the birds of the air to come upon them by day, or the beasts of the field by night.”

2 Samuel 21:10, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–6Famine and its causeA broken oath and innocent blood
  2. 7–9The seven handed overMephibosheth spared for Jonathan’s sake
  3. 10–14Rizpah’s vigil and the burialA mother’s watch moves the king
  4. 15–17The lamp of IsraelThe giant-killer grows weary
  5. 18–22Four giants fallDavid’s servants finish what he began

The chapter in brief

A famine lasts three years, and when David seeks the LORD, the answer is, “There is bloodguilt on Saul and on his house, because he put the Gibeonites to death” (v. 1). Israel had sworn to spare the Gibeonites in Joshua’s day, but Saul in his zeal had tried to wipe them out. David asks the Gibeonites how he can make atonement. They refuse silver and gold and ask for seven of Saul’s sons to hang before the LORD at Gibeah. David spares Mephibosheth because of his oath to Jonathan, and hands over two sons of Saul’s concubine Rizpah and five grandsons of Saul. They are put to death at the beginning of barley harvest. Rizpah spreads sackcloth on the rock and guards their bodies from birds and beasts until the rains come. When David hears, he brings the bones of Saul and Jonathan from Jabesh-gilead, has the bones of the seven gathered, and buries Saul and Jonathan in the tomb of Kish, “and after that God responded to the plea for the land” (v. 14). Then come four short battle reports: David, grown weary, is saved by Abishai, his men forbid him to fight again lest the “lamp of Israel” be quenched, and four descendants of the giants of Gath fall to David’s servants.

With this chapter the book turns to its closing section, a collection of episodes, songs and lists not in time order. Many readers see it arranged in pairs around a center: a national crisis (21:1-14), warriors (21:15-22), a song (22), a song (23:1-7), warriors (23:8-39), and a national crisis (24). This chapter is one of the hardest in the Old Testament, and it should be read honestly. It shows how seriously God takes an oath, even one made to a foreign people centuries before and obtained by deception (Joshua 9:15-20), and how seriously He takes innocent blood. That is good news, because the gospel rests on God’s oath (Hebrews 6:17-18). It also shows the limits of every atonement man can offer. Seven men died and a mother kept watch for months. The only death that removes guilt once for all is Christ’s, who hung on the tree and bore the curse in our place (Galatians 3:13), and in Him no child bears a father’s guilt.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–2

A broken oath

The Gibeonites had tricked Joshua into a treaty, yet Israel swore by the LORD to let them live, and the oath held (Joshua 9:15-20). Saul broke it “in his zeal for the people of Israel and Judah” (v. 2). The narrator wants us to see that zeal for one’s own people is no excuse for breaking faith or shedding innocent blood. The famine came in David’s day, not Saul’s: an oath sworn in the LORD’s name bound the nation that swore it, and its breaking was not forgotten when Saul died. God keeps His word, and He holds His people to theirs.

vv. 3–9

“How shall I make atonement?”

This is the hard center of the chapter. The law forbade putting children to death for their fathers’ sins (Deuteronomy 24:16), and it said blood that pollutes the land is atoned only by the blood of the one who shed it (Numbers 35:33). Readers have taken this in several ways. Many hold that Saul’s “house” shared in the massacre (v. 1 lays the bloodguilt “on Saul and on his house”), so the seven were not innocent bystanders. Others note that God named the cause, but the remedy was the Gibeonites’ demand and David’s decision, which the narrator reports without praising, and that God’s answer is dated “after that” (v. 14), after Rizpah’s vigil and the honorable burial, not simply after the hanging. Others stress the ancient sense that a king’s house stood or fell together. This commentary reads the chapter this way: God was just in judging a broken oath and innocent blood, the text does not tell us God commanded the executions, and Deuteronomy 24:16 and Ezekiel 18:20 still stand. No one may use this passage to justify punishing children for what their parents did, or to take vengeance in God’s name today. David’s sparing of Mephibosheth “because of the oath of the LORD” (v. 7) shows mercy for the sake of a covenant made with another, which is how every believer is spared in Christ.

For discussion

How do Deuteronomy 24:16 and Ezekiel 18:20 help us read this chapter, and what does it mean that in Christ the curse of the hanged man has been borne once for all (Galatians 3:13)?

vv. 10–14

Rizpah

Rizpah had been Saul’s concubine and was once a pawn in a quarrel between men (2 Samuel 3:7). Now she spreads sackcloth on the rock and keeps watch, day and night, “from the beginning of harvest until rain fell upon them from the heavens” (v. 10), driving off birds and beasts. The law said a hanged body must not stay on the tree overnight (Deuteronomy 21:22-23), and her watch protests in the only way open to her. It works. When the king hears, he does what should have been done long before: he brings home the bones of Saul and Jonathan, has the bones of the seven gathered, and buries Saul and Jonathan in Kish’s tomb. Grieving mothers will find a sister in Rizpah. God saw her watch, and her persistence moved a king, as the persistent widow moves the judge in Jesus’ parable (Luke 18:1-8).

vv. 15–17

The lamp of Israel

David “grew weary” (v. 15), and a giant with a new sword nearly kills him. The young man who ran at Goliath is now an older king who must be rescued. His men swear he will not go out again, “lest you quench the lamp of Israel” (v. 17). The lamp is the king’s life and line, which God promised to keep burning (1 Kings 11:36; Psalm 132:17). Even the greatest of God’s servants grows old and weak; the light of Israel does not finally rest on David but on the God who keeps His promise to him.

vv. 18–22

Elhanan and Goliath

Verse 19 says Elhanan of Bethlehem killed “Goliath the Gittite.” The parallel in 1 Chronicles 20:5 says he killed Lahmi, the brother of Goliath, and the ESV notes that Chronicles may preserve the original reading. Readers explain it in three ways: a copying slip in the Hebrew of Samuel, which Chronicles helps correct; a second giant named Goliath, since Goliath may have been a family name; or Elhanan as another name for David, which few now hold. This commentary reads it as most likely a scribal slip in the copying of Samuel, which Chronicles preserves correctly. That is the kind of difference the careful comparison of manuscripts exists to catch, and it touches no doctrine. The point of the unit is plain either way: the giants of Gath fall “by the hand of David and by the hand of his servants” (v. 22). The victory begun by the king is finished by his people.

Threads across the chapter

  • Oaths kept and broken. Israel’s oath to the Gibeonites (v. 2), broken by Saul and honored by David, and David’s oath to Jonathan (v. 7), kept.

  • Bones and burial. The seven exposed (vv. 9-10), Rizpah’s guard (v. 10), and the bones of Saul and Jonathan brought home (vv. 12-14).

  • The king’s weakness. David asks the Gibeonites what to do (vv. 3-4), is moved by Rizpah (v. 11), and grows weary in battle (v. 15).

  • Giants. The descendants of the giants fall one by one (vv. 16-22), finishing the story that began with Goliath (1 Samuel 17).

Key words

21:1
דָּמִים damim“Bloodguilt,” literally “bloods”; guilt for innocent blood shed
21:3
כָּפַר kaphar“Make atonement”; to cover or wipe away guilt, the word of the sacrifices
21:6, 9
יָקַע yaqa“Hang,” perhaps to expose; the same verb used at Baal-peor (Numbers 25:4)
21:17
נֵר יִשְׂרָאֵל ner yisra'el“Lamp of Israel”; the king’s life and line, kept burning by God’s promise

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why might these closing chapters be gathered out of time order, and what does placing this hard episode first do to the end of the book?

  2. 2

    What does the chapter teach about how seriously God takes an oath, and why is that good news for us?

  3. 3

    How should we hold this chapter together with Deuteronomy 24:16 and with the cross?

  4. 4

    What does Rizpah’s vigil teach about grief, protest, and how God sees the powerless?

  5. 5

    David grows weary and must be rescued. Where do we see our need for others in the work God gives us?

My notes