13:19
“And Tamar put ashes on her head and tore the long robe that she wore. And she laid her hand on her head and went away, crying aloud as she went.”
The chapter at a glance
- 1–6Amnon’s obsession and Jonadab’s planDesire dressed as love, helped by a crafty friend
- 7–14The violation of TamarShe said no; he overpowered her
- 15–19Hatred and the bolted doorTamar refuses to disappear quietly
- 20–22Silence in David’s houseAbsalom hushes her; David is angry and does nothing
- 23–29Absalom’s revengeTwo years of hatred end in murder
- 30–36The false reportThe schemer explains what he knew all along
- 37–39Absalom in GeshurThe king longs for the son who killed
The chapter in brief
Amnon, David’s firstborn, becomes obsessed with his half-sister Tamar, Absalom’s full sister. His cousin Jonadab, “a very crafty man,” shows him how to get her alone: pretend to be ill and ask the king to send her to cook for him. David sends her. When the room is cleared, Amnon seizes her. Tamar pleads with him, “No, my brother, do not violate me, for such a thing is not done in Israel,” but he will not listen, “and being stronger than she, he violated her and lay with her” (v. 14). At once his desire turns to hatred, and he has her thrown out and the door bolted behind her. Tamar tears her royal robe, puts ashes on her head, and goes away crying aloud. Absalom tells her to hold her peace, and she lives on in his house, “a desolate woman.” David is very angry, but does nothing. Two years later Absalom has Amnon murdered at a sheepshearing feast, a false report tells David all his sons are dead, and Absalom flees to his grandfather, the king of Geshur, for three years.
This is where the LORD’s Word through Nathan begins to come true: the sword would not depart from David’s house, and evil would rise against him from within it (2 Samuel 12:10-11). The sins of the father reappear in the sons. David took a woman who was not his and arranged a man’s death; now one son takes his sister by force and another arranges his brother’s death. The chapter is also a portrait of a king who fails to do justice. Israel prayed for a king who would defend the cause of the poor (Psalm 72:4), and David, angry as he was, protected the guilty son and left the wronged daughter in silence. Every reader who has been failed like Tamar should see that the Bible does not hide it, and that it sets this failure beside the promise of a King who will judge the poor with righteousness (Isaiah 11:4) and whose own body was stripped and shamed by stronger men, so that the shame others put on the wronged would not have the last word (Hebrews 12:2).
Points for discussion
vv. 1–6
A love that was never love
The narrator lets Amnon’s word stand at first: he “loved” her (v. 1). Verse 15 will expose it. What he felt made him ill and haggard, and it was satisfied by taking, which is the opposite of love (1 Corinthians 13:4-5). Jonadab is called “a very crafty man” (v. 3); the Hebrew word is the ordinary word for wise (chakam), and the chapter shows what cleverness becomes without the fear of the LORD. Notice too how David is used. Amnon asks the king to send Tamar, and the king sends her (v. 7), just as David once sent for Bathsheba and sent Uriah to his death (2 Samuel 11:4, 14). The king’s word, the instrument of his own sin, is now turned against his daughter by his son.
vv. 7–14
Tamar’s no
Tamar has the longest speeches in the scene, and everything she says is clear and right. She names the act a violation, calls it a thing “not done in Israel,” and calls it an “outrageous thing” (nevalah), the word used for the violence against Dinah (Genesis 34:7) and the crime at Gibeah (Judges 19:23). She thinks of her own shame and of his ruin. Her plea, “speak to the king, for he will not withhold me from you” (v. 13), is read two ways: as a desperate attempt to get out of the room, or as a sign that such a marriage was still thought possible at court, though the law forbade it (Leviticus 18:9, 11). Either way the main point is plain: she refused, and “being stronger than she, he violated her” (v. 14). The text lays the whole guilt on him.
If this has happened to you, hear what the Word says here: it was not your fault. You did not cause it by being kind, by going where you were sent, or by failing to fight harder. The shame belongs to the one who did it, not to you, and God does not see you as defiled. A crime like this belongs with the civil authorities, whom God has set to punish wrongdoers (Romans 13:3-4), and you are free to tell them and to tell someone you trust. If you are in danger now, you are not required to stay; get to a safe place first. And if anyone told you to keep quiet, as Absalom told Tamar, that silence was never what God asks of you. The Bible tells her story out loud, and God saw her.
vv. 15–19
The bolted door
Amnon’s hatred is “greater than the love with which he had loved her” (v. 15). Using a person ends in despising her, because she is a reminder of what was done. He no longer uses her name; she is “this woman” (v. 17). Tamar’s words in verse 16 (the Hebrew is uncertain here, as the ESV notes) say that sending her away is a greater wrong than the first. Under Deuteronomy 22:28-29 a man who seized an unbetrothed virgin was bound to provide for her for life; Amnon throws her out with nothing. Then Tamar does something the chapter honors: she will not disappear quietly. She tears the long robe of the king’s virgin daughters, puts ashes on her head, and goes away “crying aloud as she went” (v. 19). Grief and protest in the open are not a sin.
vv. 20–22
The silence
Absalom’s words sound like comfort but they work as a gag: “Now hold your peace, my sister. He is your brother; do not take this to heart” (v. 20). The silence enforced on Tamar was wrong, and she lived “a desolate woman” (shomemah), the word used of a land laid waste. David “was very angry” (v. 21), and that is all. The Dead Sea Scroll and the Greek add that he would not punish Amnon because he loved him as his firstborn. Many readers also think David’s own sin had taken away his voice: how could he punish what he had done? Whatever the reason, anger without justice did nothing for Tamar. When a family or a church tells someone who has been abused to stay quiet for the sake of the family, the ministry, or the abuser, it repeats Absalom’s wrong and David’s. Crimes go to the authorities, not to an in-house process that protects the powerful.
For discussion
Why is anger not enough? Read Psalm 82:3-4 and ask what doing justice would have required of David.
vv. 23–29
Revenge is not justice
Absalom says nothing to Amnon “neither good nor bad” (v. 22) and waits two full years. The plan echoes his father: a feast, wine to make the victim careless (compare 2 Samuel 11:13), and servants given the order to kill. “Have I not commanded you?” (v. 28) is the voice of a man taking the sword into his own hands. Some readers also see ambition at work: Amnon was the heir, and his death clears Absalom’s way to the throne (2 Samuel 3:2-3). Private vengeance belongs to God, who says, “Vengeance is mine” (Romans 12:19), and He gives the sword of justice to rulers, not to brothers with long memories.
vv. 30–36
The crafty friend explains
The first report is that all the king’s sons are dead. Jonadab corrects it, and he knows exactly why: “by the command of Absalom this has been determined from the day he violated his sister Tamar” (v. 32). The man who designed the crime now reads the court like a book, and no one asks him anything. Those who enable abuse often stand close to power and come through untouched.
vv. 37–39
The longing king
David mourns “for his son day after day” (v. 37), and the text leaves it open whether that is Amnon or Absalom. Verse 39 is also difficult (the ESV notes another rendering, that David’s spirit “ceased to go out” to Absalom), but the ESV reads it as longing. That longing drives the next chapter.
Threads across the chapter
“My sister,” “my brother.” The family words are used to trap (vv. 5-6), pleaded (vv. 12, 16), and used to silence (v. 20), and each time the family fails the one who trusted it.
Sending. David sends Tamar (v. 7), Amnon sends her out (vv. 9, 17), and David lets Amnon go to his death (v. 27): the king’s word carries the harm each time.
Voice and silence. Tamar speaks and cries aloud (vv. 12-13, 16, 19), while Absalom hushes her and David says nothing (vv. 20-22).
The father’s sins in the sons. Taking a woman and arranging a death (2 Samuel 11) return as Amnon’s crime (vv. 11-14) and Absalom’s murder (vv. 28-29).
Key words
- 13:12, 14, 22, 32
- עָנָה anah“Violate,” humiliate; the same verb used of Shechem’s crime against Dinah (Genesis 34:2)
- 13:12
- נְבָלָה nevalah“Outrageous thing,” a disgraceful folly; Israel’s word for a crime that breaks the covenant community
- 13:20
- שֹׁמֵמָה shomemah“Desolate”; a word used of a land laid waste
- 13:3
- חָכָם chakam“Crafty,” literally “wise”; cleverness without the fear of the LORD
Cross-references
- 2 Samuel 12:10-11the LORD’s Word through Nathan that the sword would not depart from David’s house
- Genesis 34:1-7Dinah violated, and her brothers’ anger
- Leviticus 18:9The law forbidding a union with a half-sister
- Deuteronomy 22:25-29The law that protected a woman who was seized
- Judges 19:22-24The outrage at Gibeah, called by the same word
- Psalm 82:3-4Rulers charged to give justice to the weak
- Romans 12:19Vengeance belongs to God
- Isaiah 11:3-4The coming King who judges the poor with righteousness
- 1
How does this chapter show the LORD’s Word through Nathan in 2 Samuel 12:10-11 beginning to come true, and why does the narrator tell it so fully?
- 2
What does Tamar’s own speech (vv. 12-13, 16) show about her, and why does it matter that the Bible records her words?
- 3
Absalom told Tamar to keep quiet, and David did nothing. What does it look like for a family or a church to do the opposite?
- 4
Where are we tempted to let anger stand in for doing what is right?
- 5
How does the promise of a King who judges the poor with righteousness speak to someone who has been failed by those meant to protect them?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.