15:22
“Has the LORD as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to listen than the fat of rams.”
The chapter at a glance
- 1–3The commandJudgment on Amalek, long delayed, now commanded
- 4–9Obedience by halvesSaul spares the king and the best
- 10–11The LORD regretsGod grieves, and Samuel cries all night
- 12–23To obey is better than sacrificeReligion cannot cover disobedience
- 24–31Saul’s confessionSorry for the cost, anxious for honor
- 32–33AgagThe sentence Saul would not carry out
- 34–35Samuel grievesThe prophet mourns the king God has rejected
The chapter in brief
Samuel brings Saul a message from the LORD of hosts: “I have noted what Amalek did to Israel in opposing them on the way when they came up out of Egypt.” Saul is to strike Amalek and devote to destruction all they have, sparing nothing. Saul musters the army, warns the Kenites to leave because they showed kindness to Israel, and defeats the Amalekites from Havilah to Shur. But he takes Agag the king alive, and he and the people spare the best of the sheep and oxen “and all that was good,” destroying only what was despised and worthless. Then the LORD speaks to Samuel: “I regret that I have made Saul king, for he has turned back from following me.” Samuel is angry and cries to the LORD all night. In the morning he learns that Saul has set up a monument for himself at Carmel. Saul greets him, “I have performed the commandment of the LORD.” Samuel asks, “What then is this bleating of the sheep in my ears and the lowing of the oxen that I hear?” Saul blames the people and says the best was kept to sacrifice to “the LORD your God.” Samuel answers that to obey is better than sacrifice: “Because you have rejected the word of the LORD, he has also rejected you from being king.” Saul confesses, “I have sinned... because I feared the people,” and asks Samuel to return with him. When Samuel turns, Saul seizes his robe and it tears, and Samuel says the LORD has torn the kingdom from him and given it to a neighbor better than he, and “the Glory of Israel will not lie or have regret, for he is not a man, that he should have regret.” Saul pleads, “honor me now before the elders,” and Samuel goes back with him. Then Samuel has Agag brought and puts him to death before the LORD at Gilgal: “As your sword has made women childless, so shall your mother be childless among women.” Samuel never sees Saul again until his death, but he grieves over him, “And the LORD regretted that he had made Saul king over Israel.”
This is the chapter of Saul’s final rejection, and it turns on one line: “to obey is better than sacrifice.” Saul’s failure is not lack of religion. He talks of the commandment, of sacrifice, of bowing before the LORD; what he will not do is listen. He obeys where it suits him, keeps what he values, raises a monument to himself, blames the people, and confesses sin while asking for honor. Against that stands the God who does not change, who grieves over sin and judges it, and who will give the kingdom to another. The chapter drives us to the only King who perfectly obeyed, Jesus, who humbled Himself and was “obedient to the point of death” (Philippians 2:8), so that “by the one man’s obedience the many will be made righteous” (Romans 5:19). His obedience, not ours, is the ground of our standing before God, and it is credited to all who trust Him.
Points for discussion
vv. 1–3
Judgment on Amalek
Amalek attacked Israel on the way out of Egypt, falling on those at the rear when Israel was “faint and weary” (Deuteronomy 25:17-18), and the LORD swore He would “utterly blot out the memory of Amalek from under heaven” (Exodus 17:14). Amalek kept raiding Israel through the judges’ days (Judges 3:13; 6:3). The LORD had waited centuries. The command is among the hardest in Scripture: “kill both man and woman, child and infant” (v. 3). This commentary does not apologize for what God did. He is just, and the conquest and its wars were His judgment on peoples whose wickedness He had long borne (Genesis 15:16; Deuteronomy 9:5). The command was His, given once to Israel for that judgment, and it gives no one a warrant for violence in God’s name today. Even here there is mercy: the Kenites are warned and spared because they showed kindness (v. 6). And for the little ones, we leave them to the Judge of all the earth who does what is just (Genesis 18:25), with hope and not dread. The ESV footnote explains “devote to destruction”: the spoil was set apart as the LORD’s. That is why keeping the best “to sacrifice” (v. 15) was not a gift to God; it was keeping what already belonged to Him.
vv. 4–9
Obedience by halves
Saul does a great deal. He musters two hundred thousand, wins a sweeping victory, and destroys much. But the narrator chooses his words: “All that was despised and worthless they devoted to destruction” (v. 9). Saul obeyed where obedience cost nothing and kept what he valued, including a captive king, the ancient world’s trophy. Partial obedience is a quiet way of keeping the final word for ourselves.
vv. 10–11, 29, 35
“I regret” and “not a man, that he should have regret”
The same Hebrew verb appears three times in the chapter, and the ESV footnote ties them together. The LORD says, “I regret that I have made Saul king” (v. 11); Samuel says the Glory of Israel “will not lie or have regret, for he is not a man, that he should have regret” (v. 29); and the narrator ends, “the LORD regretted that he had made Saul king” (v. 35). The chapter itself puts both side by side, and so must we. Scripture says plainly that God does not change: “God is not man, that he should lie, or a son of man, that he should change his mind” (Numbers 23:19); “For I the LORD do not change” (Malachi 3:6). God did not learn something about Saul He had not known, and He did not wish He had planned otherwise. His “regret” is His real grief at sin and His changed dealing toward a man who has changed. Jeremiah states the principle: when a nation God has promised to build “does evil in my sight,” He will “relent of the good” He intended (Jeremiah 18:10). God’s holiness is the same yesterday and today, and that is exactly why it meets faithfulness and rebellion differently. Some read verses like verse 11 to mean God did not know how Saul would turn out; verse 29, in the same chapter, rules that out. And the grief is not a figure of speech for nothing at all: God is not indifferent to the ruin of a man He set over His people.
For discussion
How can God “regret” (v. 11) and also be the One who does not “have regret” (v. 29)? Read Numbers 23:19 and Jeremiah 18:7-10 together, and talk about what each kind of language protects.
vv. 12–23
To obey is better than sacrifice
Saul’s greeting is warm and religious, “Blessed be you to the LORD,” and his claim is false. Then the animals give him away. He shifts blame to “the people” and dresses the disobedience in worship: they kept the best “to sacrifice to the LORD your God” (v. 15). Many readers notice that Saul keeps saying “your God” to Samuel (vv. 15, 21, 30). Samuel’s answer in verses 22-23 is poetry, one of the Old Testament’s great sayings. It is not a rejection of sacrifice, which God Himself commanded, but of sacrifice used as a cover for disobedience. The prophets would say it again (Hosea 6:6, “I desire steadfast love and not sacrifice”; Psalm 51:16-17), and Jesus quoted Hosea against those who kept the rituals and despised the sinners (Matthew 9:13). Rebellion is “as the sin of divination” and presumption “as iniquity and idolatry” (v. 23), because each puts a human will in the place of God’s Word. This is not a call to earn God’s favor by obeying. Saul’s problem was precisely that he thought religious acts could secure God’s favor while he ruled his own life. The answer to Saul is not a better performance but the obedient King whose obedience is given to us (Romans 5:19).
vv. 24–31
Saul’s plea: “honor me now”
Saul’s confession sounds right: “I have sinned, for I have transgressed the commandment of the LORD” (v. 24). But he gives his reason, “because I feared the people,” and in the same breath asks Samuel to come with him, and then, “honor me now before the elders of my people” (v. 30). His sorrow is about losing the kingdom and his standing. Paul names the difference: “godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation without regret, whereas worldly grief produces death” (2 Corinthians 7:10). Compare David’s “I have sinned against the LORD” (2 Samuel 12:13) and Psalm 51. The torn robe becomes a sign: the kingdom torn from Saul and given to “a neighbor of yours, who is better than you” (v. 28). A word for the anxious reader: if you fear your repentance is not real, notice that Saul’s sorrow was about his honor before men. Grief over having wronged God Himself, and a turning to Him for mercy, is the mark of the repentance He gives, not the mark of a heart He has rejected.
vv. 32–33
Agag
Agag comes “cheerfully” (or “haltingly,” the ESV footnote notes), thinking the danger is past. Samuel carries out the sentence Saul would not, and names its justice: “As your sword has made women childless, so shall your mother be childless among women” (v. 33). It is grim, and Scripture does not soften it. It is also not a pattern for anyone today; it was the prophet executing a sentence God had pronounced on a people under His judgment. Amalekites appear again in David’s story (1 Samuel 30), and many readers connect Haman “the Agagite” in Esther 3:1 with this king’s line.
vv. 34–35
Samuel grieves
The chapter ends with two griefs. Samuel never sees Saul again, “but Samuel grieved over Saul,” and “the LORD regretted that he had made Saul king.” The prophet does not gloat over the king’s fall; he mourns. The next chapter opens with the LORD asking him, “How long will you grieve over Saul” (16:1). Grief over those who reject God is right, but it is not meant to keep us from the next thing God is doing.
Threads across the chapter
Listening. “listen to the words of the LORD” (v. 1), “Why then did you not obey the voice of the LORD?” (v. 19), “to listen than the fat of rams” (v. 22), and Saul “obeyed their voice” (v. 24).
Rejection. Saul rejected the Word of the LORD, and the LORD rejected him from being king (vv. 23, 26).
Regret and grief. The LORD’s regret (vv. 11, 35), His not having regret as a man does (v. 29), Samuel’s anger and all-night cry (v. 11), and Samuel’s grief (v. 35).
Honor. Saul’s monument to himself (v. 12), his plea for honor before the elders (v. 30), and the kingdom given to one “better than you” (v. 28).
Key words
- 15:3
- חֵרֶם cherem“Devote to destruction”; set apart wholly to the LORD in judgment, so that nothing devoted could be kept for oneself
- 15:11, 29, 35
- נִחַם nicham“Regret”; God’s grief and changed dealing toward sin, spoken in human terms without any change in God’s nature or purpose
- 15:22
- שָׁמַע shama'“Obey, listen”; in Hebrew to hear rightly is to obey
- 15:29
- נֵצַח יִשְׂרָאֵל netsach Yisra'el“The Glory of Israel”; a title for God stressing His enduring constancy
Cross-references
- Exodus 17:14-16The LORD’s war with Amalek from generation to generation
- Deuteronomy 25:17-19Amalek attacked the faint and weary
- Numbers 23:19God is not man, that He should change His mind
- Jeremiah 18:7-10The LORD relents in response to a nation’s turning
- Hosea 6:6Steadfast love and not sacrifice
- 2 Corinthians 7:10Godly grief and worldly grief
- Romans 5:19Many made righteous by one Man’s obedience
- Esther 3:1Haman the Agagite
- 1
How does chapter 15 confirm what chapter 13 began, and why is this the moment of final rejection?
- 2
What does “to obey is better than sacrifice” mean, and what does it not mean?
- 3
How do verses 11, 29 and 35 together teach both that God does not change and that He truly grieves over sin?
- 4
Compare Saul’s “I have sinned” with David’s in 2 Samuel 12:13. How can we tell the difference in ourselves between sorrow for sin and sorrow for its cost?
- 5
Where are we tempted to obey God in the parts that cost us nothing and keep “the best” for ourselves?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.