1 Samuel · Historical Books

1 Samuel 1

Hannah, barren and grieved, prays for a son and vows to give him to the LORD, and Samuel is born.

1:27

“For this child I prayed, and the LORD has granted me my petition that I made to him.”

1 Samuel 1:27, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–2Elkanah’s householdTwo wives, one with children, one without
  2. 3–8Year after year at ShilohWorship, a rival’s cruelty, and a husband’s partial comfort
  3. 9–18Hannah’s prayer and EliShe pours out her soul and is misjudged, then blessed
  4. 19–20Samuel bornThe LORD remembers her; “I have asked for him from the LORD”
  5. 21–28Samuel given at ShilohThe asked-for child is given back to the LORD

The chapter in brief

Elkanah, a man of the hill country of Ephraim, has two wives: Peninnah, who has children, and Hannah, who has none, “because the LORD had closed her womb” (v. 5). Year by year the family goes up to worship at Shiloh, where Eli’s sons Hophni and Phinehas serve as priests, and year by year Peninnah provokes Hannah until she weeps and will not eat. Elkanah loves Hannah and gives her a double portion, but his comfort (“Am I not more to you than ten sons?”) cannot reach her grief. After the meal she rises, prays and weeps bitterly before the LORD, and vows that if He will give her a son she will give him to the LORD all the days of his life, and no razor shall touch his head. Eli, watching her lips move without sound, takes her for drunk; she answers that she has been “pouring out my soul before the LORD” (v. 15). Eli blesses her, and she goes away with her face no longer sad. The LORD remembers her, she bears a son and names him Samuel, saying, “I have asked for him from the LORD” (v. 20). When he is weaned she brings him to the house of the LORD at Shiloh and gives him back: “As long as he lives, he is lent to the LORD” (v. 28).

The book of Judges ended with no king in Israel and everyone doing what was right in his own eyes (Judges 21:25). First Samuel opens not in a palace or a battle but with a grieving woman at prayer, and that is the point: the God who will give Israel its king begins with a barren woman’s petition. Hannah stands in the line of Sarah, Rebekah, Rachel and the mother of Samson, women whose emptiness God filled to carry His promise forward, and that line runs on to Elizabeth (Luke 1:7) and finally to Mary, whose Son was given not to a barren womb but to a virgin’s. Every child of promise in that line was a gift no one could manufacture, and each points to the one Child through whom God would bring salvation to the humble.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–2

A household like Jacob’s

The opening has the shape of the patriarch stories: a man with two wives, one loved and barren, the other fruitful and a rival (Genesis 29:30-31; 30:1). Scripture records Elkanah’s two marriages without commending them, and the chapter quietly shows their fruit: provocation, tears, a feast that becomes a yearly wound. The genealogy in v. 1 matters too. Samuel’s family lived in Ephraim’s hill country, but the Chronicler lists Elkanah and Samuel among the Levites (1 Chronicles 6:27-28), which helps explain why Samuel will later serve at the sanctuary and offer sacrifice.

vv. 3–8

“The LORD had closed her womb”

The narrator says it twice (vv. 5, 6). Hannah’s barrenness is not chance, and it is not a punishment: the text names no sin of hers. It lies within God’s purpose, which is both harder and more hopeful than chance. Peninnah uses the grief as a weapon, “to irritate her” (v. 6), and does it at the very place of worship. Elkanah loves her truly, yet his question, “Am I not more to you than ten sons?” (v. 8), turns the conversation to himself. Love that does not listen can still wound.

A word for readers who carry this grief: infertility and the loss of a child are not a verdict on anyone’s faith or worth. Scripture does not promise that every prayer for a child will be answered with a child, and Hannah’s story is not a formula. What it does show is that God sees the one who weeps at His house while others feast, and that He is “near to the brokenhearted” (Psalm 34:18).

For discussion

Peninnah’s cruelty and Elkanah’s clumsy comfort both happen at Shiloh, during worship. What does that suggest about how a church can unintentionally deepen someone’s grief? Compare Romans 12:15.

vv. 9–18

Pouring out the soul

Hannah’s prayer is not polished. She “wept bitterly” (v. 10) and prayed silently, only her lips moving, which seems to have looked strange where prayer was usually spoken aloud. Eli, the high priest, sees and judges wrongly, and his rebuke is sharp. Her answer is dignified and true: “I have been pouring out my soul before the LORD” (v. 15). The Psalms use the same picture (Psalm 62:8, “pour out your heart before him”), and Lamentations calls the afflicted to pour out their heart like water before the Lord (Lamentations 2:19). The Spirit Himself helps us when we do not know what to pray (Romans 8:26). Notice that her face changes in v. 18 before she has conceived: she goes away with a word of blessing, not yet a child.

vv. 11, 21–28

The vow

Hannah promises that “no razor shall touch his head” (v. 11), the mark of the Nazirite (Numbers 6:5) that had been set on Samson before his birth (Judges 13:5). The word play of the chapter is on the Hebrew sha’al, “ask”: she asked (v. 17), Samuel is the one she “asked for” (v. 20), and in v. 28 she has “lent” him, literally made him one asked for, to the LORD. Her giving was a free vow, gladly kept; the text gives no warrant for pressuring any parent to give up a child. And it sets up a contrast the book will draw out: Samuel, the child asked of God and given back to Him, and Saul (Sha’ul, “asked”), the king the people will ask for themselves (8:10).

For discussion

Hannah asked for a gift and then gave the gift back to the Giver. How does James 1:17 shape the way we hold the good things God gives us, including our children?

Threads across the chapter

  • Asking. Hannah asks (vv. 11, 17), names her son for asking (v. 20), and gives back what she asked (vv. 27-28), sounding the word that will name Saul.

  • Seeing. Hannah asks the LORD to “look on the affliction” of His servant (v. 11), while Eli looks at her lips and sees only drunkenness (vv. 12-14).

  • Year by year. The yearly journey to Shiloh is the setting of the grief (vv. 3, 7) and then of its answer (v. 21), as the ordinary rhythm of worship becomes the place God meets her.

  • Food and fasting. Hannah weeps and will not eat (vv. 7-8), and after her prayer she eats and her face is no longer sad (v. 18).

Key words

1:20, 27–28
שָׁאַל sha'al“Ask”; the root behind Hannah’s petition, Samuel’s naming, and “lent” in v. 28, and the sound of Saul’s name
1:11
עֳנִי oni“Affliction”; the word used of Israel’s misery in Egypt (Exodus 3:7), here of one woman’s grief
1:11, 19
זָכַר zakhar“Remember”; God’s covenant attention, as when He remembered Noah and Rachel (Genesis 8:1; 30:22)

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Judges ended in chaos with no king. Why do you think 1 Samuel begins the story of Israel’s kings with a barren woman’s prayer rather than with a ruler or a battle?

  2. 2

    The narrator says twice that the LORD had closed Hannah’s womb. How does that change the way we read her grief, and her prayer?

  3. 3

    Eli misjudged Hannah, and Elkanah’s comfort missed her. What do we learn here about how to come alongside someone who is grieving?

  4. 4

    Hannah’s face changed before her circumstances did (v. 18). What was it that changed, and how does that bear on our own unanswered prayers?

  5. 5

    Hannah gave back the child she had asked for. What would it look like to hold God’s gifts with open hands?

My notes