18:39
“And when all the people saw it, they fell on their faces and said, ’The LORD, he is God; the LORD, he is God.’”
The chapter at a glance
- 1–6Ahab searching for grassThe king’s concern is his horses
- 7–16Obadiah meets ElijahA God-fearer serving in a wicked court
- 17–19“You troubler of Israel”The real troubler is the one who forsakes the LORD
- 20–24The challenge on CarmelNo limping between two opinions
- 25–29Baal’s prophets cryNo voice, no answer, no one paying attention
- 30–35The altar rebuilt and drenchedTwelve stones and no trick
- 36–40Elijah’s prayer and the fire“The LORD, he is God”
- 41–46The rainPersistent prayer and a little cloud
The chapter in brief
In the third year of the drought the LORD sends Elijah back to Ahab with a promise of rain. Ahab and his steward Obadiah are out searching the land for grass to keep the horses alive. Obadiah “feared the LORD greatly” (v. 3) and had hidden a hundred of the LORD’s prophets in caves when Jezebel was killing them. Elijah meets him and sends him to announce him to Ahab, and Obadiah is terrified that Elijah will vanish and leave him to die. Elijah swears he will appear. Ahab greets him as “you troubler of Israel,” and Elijah answers that the troubler is Ahab, who has abandoned the LORD’s commandments for the Baals (vv. 17-18). He summons all Israel and the 450 prophets of Baal and 400 prophets of Asherah to Mount Carmel and asks the people, “How long will you go limping between two different opinions?” (v. 21). The test is simple: two bulls, two altars, no fire, “and the God who answers by fire, he is God” (v. 24). Baal’s prophets cry from morning to evening, limp around their altar, and cut themselves until the blood flows, while Elijah mocks; “no one answered; no one paid attention” (v. 29). Elijah repairs the LORD’s altar with twelve stones, drenches it three times with water, and prays a short prayer. The fire of the LORD falls and consumes the offering, the wood, the stones, the dust, and the water. The people fall on their faces: “The LORD, he is God.” The prophets of Baal are put to death at the brook Kishon. Then Elijah prays on the top of Carmel, sending his servant seven times to look at the sea, until a cloud the size of a man’s hand rises, and a great rain falls. The hand of the LORD is on Elijah, and he runs before Ahab’s chariot all the way to Jezreel.
Carmel is the turning point of the Elijah story and one of the great contests in Scripture, and its question is the first commandment: who is God? Baal, the god of storm and fire, cannot produce a spark or a cloud; the LORD sends fire and then rain, on the day He chooses, in answer to a prayer that asks only that He be known. The chapter points to Christ in several ways the New Testament itself draws. Elijah’s prayer, “that you have turned their hearts back” (v. 37), is the work Malachi promised a coming Elijah would do (Malachi 4:5-6), and the angel says John the Baptist will go before the Lord “in the spirit and power of Elijah” to turn hearts (Luke 1:16-17). Elijah stands with Moses on the mountain of transfiguration speaking with Jesus (Luke 9:30-31), and the voice from heaven there says of Jesus, “listen to him” (Luke 9:35). Many readers also see the cross in the fire that fell on the sacrifice and not on the people: God’s judgment consumed the offering, and the people lived. That is a picture, not the chapter’s stated point, but it is the shape of the gospel: the fire of God fell on Christ, our sacrifice, so that we who deserved it fall on our faces in worship rather than in ruin.
Points for discussion
vv. 1–16
Obadiah in Ahab’s house
Obadiah’s name means “servant of the LORD,” and he is exactly that, in the worst house in Israel. He runs Ahab’s household, yet “feared the LORD greatly” and risked his life to hide a hundred prophets and feed them through a famine (vv. 3-4, 13). Readers sometimes treat him as a compromiser beside Elijah’s boldness. The text does not; it praises him. God has servants in palaces and servants in the wilderness, and each has a different calling (compare Joseph, Daniel, and Nehemiah in foreign courts). Obadiah’s fear in verses 9-14 is also honest. He has every reason to think Elijah will disappear again and Ahab will kill him. Elijah does not scold him; he swears by “the LORD of hosts... before whom I stand” (v. 15) and keeps his word. Notice too that Elijah will soon say, “I, even I only, am left a prophet of the LORD” (v. 22), while Obadiah has just told him of a hundred more in hiding. That sets up the next chapter (19:10, 18).
For discussion
What does faithfulness look like for a believer whose job puts them inside a godless system? Read Daniel 1:8 and 6:4-5 beside verses 3-4.
vv. 17–19
“You troubler of Israel”
Ahab’s charge is the oldest trick of a guilty ruler: blame the messenger. The word (okher, from akar) is the one used of Achan, whose hidden sin brought defeat on Israel; Joshua told him, “The LORD brings trouble on you today” (Joshua 7:25). Elijah turns the word back: the troubler is not the one who names the sin, but the one who commits it, “because you have abandoned the commandments of the LORD and followed the Baals” (v. 18). The drought is the covenant’s own warning coming true (Deuteronomy 11:16-17). Faithful people who name sin are still called troublemakers, and Jesus was accused of stirring up the people (Luke 23:5).
vv. 20–24
No more limping
Elijah’s question uses a vivid verb: “How long will you go limping (pasach) between two different opinions?” (v. 21). The same verb returns in verse 26, where the prophets of Baal “limped around the altar” in their ritual dance. Israel’s divided heart is a lame dance between two gods. The people had not renounced the LORD; they wanted the LORD and Baal both, the God of the exodus for their history and the storm god for their crops. Elijah says that is impossible: “If the LORD is God, follow him; but if Baal, then follow him.” Jesus says the same: “No one can serve two masters” (Matthew 6:24). And the people’s response is telling: “the people did not answer him a word.” Silence before a clear choice is its own answer.
vv. 25–29
No voice, no answer
Elijah gives Baal every advantage: first choice of bull, many prophets, all day. They cry “O Baal, answer us!” from morning to noon. Elijah’s mockery is sharp and even crude: perhaps Baal is “musing,” or “relieving himself,” or traveling, or asleep (v. 27). It is prophetic satire aimed at a god who does not exist, in the same spirit as Isaiah 44:9-20 and Psalm 115:4-8, and it is not a license for believers to mock people. The prophets cut themselves “after their custom” (v. 28), a practice the law forbade to Israel (Leviticus 19:28; Deuteronomy 14:1). False gods demand their worshipers’ blood and give nothing back. The narrator’s triple line is devastating: “No one answered; no one paid attention” (v. 29). The living God is the one who answers, and He gave not our blood but His Son’s.
vv. 30–35
Twelve stones and the water
Elijah first repairs “the altar of the LORD that had been thrown down” (v. 30). He uses twelve stones, one for each tribe, recalling the LORD’s Word to Jacob, “Israel shall be your name” (v. 31; Genesis 35:10). Though the kingdom is split and the north has its calves, Elijah builds as though the twelve tribes are still one people under one God, which in God’s eyes they are. Then he drenches the offering and wood with twelve jars of water, filling the trench. In a drought that water was precious, and it removed any suspicion of a hidden flame. God’s glory would not be shared with a trick.
vv. 36–40
A short prayer and the fire
At the hour of the evening offering, the time of Jerusalem’s daily sacrifice, Elijah prays. Baal’s prophets had raved for hours; Elijah prays two sentences. He asks for one thing, that the LORD be known as God, that Elijah be known as His servant who acted “at your word,” and that the people know “that you have turned their hearts back” (vv. 36-37). True prayer is not measured by its length or noise (Matthew 6:7-8), and true repentance is God’s work in us before it is ours. “Then the fire of the LORD fell,” and it consumed not only the offering but the stones, the dust, and the water (v. 38), as fire from the LORD had consumed the first offerings at the tabernacle (Leviticus 9:24). The people fall on their faces and confess what Elijah’s own name means: “The LORD, he is God.”
Then Elijah has the prophets of Baal seized and killed at the brook Kishon (v. 40). Under the law, a prophet who led Israel after other gods was to be put to death (Deuteronomy 13:1-5; 17:2-7), and Elijah carried out that sentence in Israel’s covenant nation. This commentary holds, with the Westminster Confession (19.4), that Israel’s civil laws expired with Israel’s state. Verse 40 is no warrant for violence against false teachers or anyone else today. When James and John wanted to call down fire from heaven on a Samaritan village that rejected Jesus, He rebuked them (Luke 9:54-55). The church’s weapons “are not of the flesh” (2 Corinthians 10:4), and Christ’s kingdom “is not of this world” (John 18:36).
For discussion
Why does Jesus refuse the Carmel pattern in Luke 9:51-56? What does that teach about how we answer those who reject Him?
vv. 41–46
Seven times to the sea
Elijah tells Ahab he hears “the rushing of rain” (v. 41) before there is a cloud; he speaks by God’s promise (v. 1). Then he goes up and prays, bowed with his face between his knees, and sends his servant to look six times and find “nothing.” Only at the seventh comes “a little cloud like a man’s hand.” The God who answered with fire in a moment answers with rain after persistent asking. James draws exactly this lesson: “he prayed again, and heaven gave rain, and the earth bore its fruit” (James 5:18), and he reminds us that Elijah “was a man with a nature like ours” (5:17). The chapter ends with Elijah, by “the hand of the LORD,” running ahead of Ahab’s chariot to Jezreel (v. 46), a long run in a storm. Some readers see him running as a herald before the king, still honoring the throne, hoping the king will now lead Israel back to the LORD. The next chapter shows what Jezebel thought of that hope.
Threads across the chapter
Who answers? “The God who answers by fire” (v. 24), Baal’s silence (vv. 26, 29), and Elijah’s “Answer me, O LORD, answer me” (v. 37).
The troubler. Ahab blames Elijah (v. 17), Elijah names Ahab (v. 18), and the fire shows who is right (vv. 38-39).
Limping and turning. The people limp between two opinions (v. 21), the prophets limp around their altar (v. 26), and the LORD turns their hearts back (v. 37).
Fire and rain. The LORD who withheld both (17:1) sends fire on the altar (v. 38) and rain on the land (v. 45), the very things Baal claimed.
Servants. Obadiah the servant of the LORD (vv. 3, 12), Elijah “your servant” (v. 36), and Elijah’s own servant sent seven times (v. 43).
Key words
- 18:17–18
- עֹכֵר okher“Troubler”; the word used of Achan’s troubling of Israel (Joshua 7:25)
- 18:21, 26
- פָּסַח pasach“Limp”; the people’s divided worship and the Baal prophets’ dance
- 18:24, 39
- הָאֱלֹהִים ha'elohim“The God,” God with the article; the question is which one is the true God
- 18:29, 36
- מִנְחָה minchah“Oblation,” offering; the hour of the evening sacrifice when Elijah prays
Cross-references
- Deuteronomy 11:16-17The shut heaven as the covenant warning against idolatry
- Joshua 7:25Achan, the original troubler of Israel
- Joshua 24:15Choose this day whom you will serve
- Psalm 115:4-8Idols that have mouths but do not speak
- Matthew 6:24No one can serve two masters
- Malachi 4:5-6The coming Elijah who will turn hearts
- Luke 9:51-56Jesus rebukes the disciples who want fire from heaven
- James 5:17-18Elijah prayed again, and heaven gave rain
- 1
How does the contest on Carmel answer the drought of 1 Kings 17 and the temple of Baal in 1 Kings 16:32?
- 2
What does it mean to go “limping between two different opinions,” and where do Christians today try to keep both the LORD and another god?
- 3
Obadiah served God inside Ahab’s household, and Elijah stood outside it. How do both callings honor God, and which is closer to yours?
- 4
Compare the prayers of Baal’s prophets with Elijah’s prayer in verses 36-37. What does that teach about how we pray, and about who turns hearts back?
- 5
How do Luke 9:54-55 and John 18:36 guide us in reading verse 40, and how does the fire falling on the sacrifice point us to the cross?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.