1 Corinthians · Epistles

1 Corinthians 5

Paul commands the church to discipline a man in flagrant immorality and to purge the old leaven.

Lechaeum, at sea levelFrom the harbor at Lechaeum up through Corinth to Acrocorinth, about 3 milesAcrocorinth, about 1,500 ft

5:7

“Cleanse out the old leaven that you may be a new lump, as you really are unleavened. For Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed.”

1 Corinthians 5:7, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–2Sin toleratedThe church should have mourned, not boasted
  2. 3–5Delivered to SatanDiscipline aims at the sinner’s final salvation
  3. 6–8Christ our PassoverThe sacrificed Lamb makes a new, unleavened people
  4. 9–13Judging those insideDiscipline is for the church, not the world

The chapter in brief

Paul has heard of sexual immorality in the church of a kind not tolerated even among pagans: a man is living with his father’s wife. Worse, the church is arrogant about it instead of mourning. Though absent in body, Paul has already judged the case, and when they are assembled in the name of the Lord Jesus, with the Lord’s power, they are to deliver the man to Satan for the destruction of the flesh, so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord. A little leaven leavens the whole lump, so they must cleanse out the old leaven and be a new lump, for Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed. Paul clarifies an earlier letter: he did not mean they should avoid immoral people in the world, but anyone who bears the name of brother and lives in such sin. God judges outsiders; the church is to judge those inside.

The chapter moves from the factions of chapters 1-4 to the moral disorder of chapters 5-6, but the root is the same: boasting (v. 6). A church proud of its tolerance is no more humble than a church proud of its leaders. Paul’s answer is again the cross. Christ our Passover lamb has been sacrificed, so His people are already unleavened, and the call to cleanse out the old leaven is a call to become what the gospel has made them. Discipline, rightly done, is not the church’s self-protection; it is a severe mercy aimed at the sinner’s salvation in the day of the Lord.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–2

A sin the pagans would not tolerate

“His father’s wife” is most likely his stepmother, a union forbidden in the law (Leviticus 18:8; Deuteronomy 22:30) and condemned by Roman law and custom too. Paul says nothing about disciplining the woman, which suggests she was not a member of the church (compare vv. 12-13). The heart of the rebuke is not only the man’s sin but the church’s response: “And you are arrogant! Ought you not rather to mourn?” (v. 2). Perhaps they saw their acceptance as a mark of freedom or broad-mindedness. Paul calls it pride. Grief is the fitting response to sin among God’s people, the same grief as Ezra’s or Daniel’s over the sins of the community (Ezra 9:3-6; Daniel 9:4-5).

vv. 3–5

Delivered to Satan

The action is to be taken “when you are assembled in the name of the Lord Jesus” (v. 4), by the church gathered and under Christ’s authority, not by one person’s decree. Churches order this differently, and believers differ on how authority in discipline is shared between elders and congregation; the passage itself stresses the whole church acting together in the Lord’s name. This commentary holds that Scripture prescribes the Presbyterian order, elders ruling together and accountable to wider assemblies (Acts 14:23; 15; 20:17, 28), with the church’s discipline carried out in the presence and for the good of the whole congregation; that order is not a condition of salvation, and churches ordered otherwise are faithful churches. “Deliver this man to Satan” (v. 5) is usually read as putting him out of the church’s fellowship into the world, where Satan holds sway (compare 1 Timothy 1:20). “The destruction of the flesh” is read in two main ways: some take it as physical suffering that may follow; many take it as the destruction of his sinful nature, using “flesh” as Paul often does. Either way the stated aim is mercy: “so that his spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord.” Discipline is meant to bring a sinner home. Many readers think 2 Corinthians 2:5-11, where Paul urges the church to forgive and comfort a disciplined man, may concern the same case, though that is uncertain.

For discussion

How can church discipline be both serious and loving? Compare Matthew 18:15-17 and Galatians 6:1.

vv. 6–8

Christ our Passover

At Passover every Israelite house removed all leaven before the feast (Exodus 12:15-20). Leaven, a small piece of old dough that works through a whole batch, became a picture of the way evil spreads. Paul’s logic runs backwards from what we might expect: “Cleanse out the old leaven that you may be a new lump, as you really are unleavened” (v. 7). They are already unleavened, because “Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed.” The Lamb has been slain, the deliverance has happened, so the feast is underway, and they should keep it “with the unleavened bread of sincerity and truth” (v. 8). Holiness is not the price of the sacrifice but the shape of life after it. Paul may have been writing near the Passover season (he plans to stay in Ephesus until Pentecost, 16:8), though that is only a suggestion.

vv. 9–13

Inside and outside

Paul’s earlier letter had been misread as a call to withdraw from all immoral people. He corrects it: that would mean leaving the world (v. 10). Christians are to live among their neighbors, sinners like themselves, as Jesus ate with sinners (Luke 15:1-2). The separation applies to one who “bears the name of brother” and persists in open sin, and the list includes greed, reviling, and swindling as well as sexual sin (v. 11). “Not even to eat with such a one” is read by many as withdrawing ordinary fellowship, so the man feels the weight of where he stands. “God judges those outside” (v. 13), and the closing command echoes the refrain of Deuteronomy: “Purge the evil person from among you” (Deuteronomy 17:7; 22:21).

What this chapter does not authorize

Church discipline has sometimes been turned against the very people it should protect: used to silence someone who reports abuse, to shield a powerful leader, or to punish dissent. That is a betrayal of this passage. Paul’s target is a member persisting in open sin, and the church’s sin in Corinth was protecting him, not exposing him. Discipline is never a substitute for the civil authorities when a crime has been committed; abuse and other crimes belong with the authorities God has appointed for justice (Romans 13:1-4), as well as with the church. And no one should read this chapter as permission to shun a struggling believer who is fighting his sin and seeking help.

Threads across the chapter

  • Boasting again. The church’s arrogance (vv. 2, 6) is the same pride that drove the factions of chapters 1-4.

  • A little leaven. The man’s sin (vv. 1-2), the church’s tolerance (v. 6), and the old leaven of malice and evil (v. 8) all show how sin spreads if left alone.

  • Judgment for salvation. The sentence on the man (v. 5) and the call to purge (v. 13) aim at his salvation and the church’s purity, not at revenge.

  • The church and the world. Paul separates the judgment of those inside (vv. 11-13) from life among those outside (vv. 9-10), whom God judges.

Key words

5:1
πορνεία porneia“Sexual immorality”; a broad word for sexual sin outside God’s design
5:6–8
ζύμη zymē“Leaven”; fermenting dough, a picture of sin that spreads through the whole
5:7
πάσχα pascha“Passover,” here the Passover lamb; Christ sacrificed for His people
5:13
ἐξαίρω exairō“Purge,” remove; the Deuteronomy word for putting evil out of the community

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does Paul move straight from the factions of chapters 1-4 to this case, and what do the two problems have in common?

  2. 2

    What does it mean that the church is already “unleavened” because Christ our Passover has been sacrificed, and why does Paul put that before the command?

  3. 3

    Why does Paul say “mourn” (v. 2) rather than simply “act,” and what would mourning over sin look like in a church today?

  4. 4

    How can a church avoid both tolerating open sin and using discipline as a weapon against the weak or the wounded?

  5. 5

    Paul tells the church not to withdraw from immoral people in the world. How should that shape our friendships with unbelieving neighbors?

My notes