1 Corinthians · Epistles

1 Corinthians 14

Prophecy is to be preferred over tongues, and all worship must be orderly and build up the church.

Lechaeum, at sea levelFrom the harbor at Lechaeum up through Corinth to Acrocorinth, about 3 milesAcrocorinth, about 1,500 ft

14:1

“Pursue love, and earnestly desire the spiritual gifts, especially that you may prophesy.”

1 Corinthians 14:1, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–5Prophecy over tonguesPrefer the gifts that build up the church
  2. 6–12Sound without senseSpeech no one understands builds no one up
  3. 13–19Spirit and mindPray with the mind; five words to instruct
  4. 20–25A sign for unbelieversProphecy convicts: “God is really among you”
  5. 26–33aOrder in the gatheringAll for building up; God is a God of peace
  6. 33b-35Women in the churchesA disputed instruction for the gathering
  7. 36–40A command of the LordApostolic authority; decently and in order

The chapter in brief

Paul applies love to the church’s gathering. Pursue love, he says, and desire the spiritual gifts, especially prophecy. The one who speaks in a tongue speaks to God, uttering mysteries no one understands, and builds up himself; the one who prophesies speaks to people for their upbuilding, encouragement, and consolation, and builds up the church. Uninterpreted tongues are like an instrument with no distinct notes or a bugle with an unclear call. Since the Corinthians are eager for manifestations of the Spirit, they should seek to excel in building up the church, pray for the power to interpret, and pray and sing with the mind as well as the spirit. Paul speaks in tongues more than all of them, yet in church he would rather speak five words with his mind than ten thousand in a tongue. Quoting Isaiah 28, he calls tongues a sign for unbelievers, while prophecy brings an outsider under conviction so that he falls on his face and declares that God is really among them. When they come together each one brings a hymn, a lesson, a revelation, a tongue, or an interpretation, and all must be done for building up: tongues two or three at most, in turn, with interpretation; prophets two or three, with the others weighing what is said; “for God is not a God of confusion but of peace.” Then comes the instruction that women should keep silent in the churches, one of the most debated passages in the letter. Paul claims for his words the authority of a command of the Lord and closes: desire to prophesy, do not forbid tongues, and do all things decently and in order.

Love is the hinge (v. 1 picks up 12:31 and 13:13), and its test in worship is “building up.” A gift used to display oneself, or one that bypasses the minds of others, fails love however impressive it sounds. Intelligibility matters because God speaks to be understood, and the Word that convicts the outsider and lays bare the heart is the voice of Christ by His Spirit (Hebrews 4:12-13). The outsider’s confession, “God is really among you,” may echo the hope of Isaiah 45:14 that the nations would say so of Israel, and it is fulfilled where the risen Christ is present among His gathered people (Matthew 18:20). Two questions here divide faithful believers, whether these gifts continue and what verses 34-35 require. This commentary names the views fairly and states its own conviction on each (vv. 1-5, 26-33a, 33b-35, 36-40), held without dividing over it; the chapter’s main point is not in doubt.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–5

Prophecy over tongues

The test is who is built up. Tongues, as Paul describes them here, are speech to God that the hearers do not understand (v. 2) and that may bypass the speaker’s own mind (v. 14). Paul does not despise the gift: “I want you all to speak in tongues, but even more to prophesy” (v. 5), a wish perhaps like his wish in 7:7 that all were as he is. Interpreted, a tongue builds up the church as prophecy does. Readers differ over what New Testament prophecy is. Some see revelation carrying the authority of God’s own words, like the Old Testament prophets, and therefore tied to the apostolic foundation. Others see Spirit-prompted speech that must be weighed and may be mixed with error (v. 29; 1 Thessalonians 5:19-21). Others see it as including Spirit-given application of Scripture, near to preaching. This commentary holds that prophecy today is the Spirit enabling believers to speak God’s revealed truth to one another with discernment, weighed and tested by Scripture (v. 29; 1 Thessalonians 5:20-21), not new revelation; foretelling such as Agabus’s (Acts 11:28; 21:10-11) belonged to the apostolic foundation (Ephesians 2:20).

vv. 6–12

Sound without sense

A flute, a harp, or a bugle that gives no distinct sound helps no one; a speaker whose language I do not know is a foreigner to me, and I to him. Communication is a form of love: speech no one understands leaves the hearer outside. Since they are “eager for manifestations of the Spirit,” let them “strive to excel in building up the church” (v. 12). God Himself has spoken plainly in His Son (Hebrews 1:1-2), and the gathering should sound like it.

vv. 13–19

Spirit and mind

“I will pray with my spirit, but I will pray with my mind also” (v. 15). Christian worship engages the whole person, and the Spirit is not honored by setting the mind aside. Verse 16 shows the outsider unable to say “Amen” to a thanksgiving he cannot follow, which assumes the congregation said Amen together to prayers it understood. Then Paul’s self-restraint: he speaks in tongues more than all of them, yet in church he would rather speak five words with his mind than ten thousand in a tongue. The man with the most of the gift refuses to make his own experience the measure of everyone else’s.

vv. 20–25

A sign for unbelievers

“Be infants in evil, but in your thinking be mature.” Isaiah 28:11-12 is the background. Israel mocked the prophets’ plain words, so God warned that He would speak to them through the foreign tongues of Assyrian invaders, a sign of judgment on unbelief. Uninterpreted tongues work the same way in the assembly: the outsider hears only noise and concludes, “you are out of your minds” (v. 23). Prophecy, by contrast, discloses the secrets of his heart, and he falls on his face and worships, declaring “that God is really among you.” Readers differ on how verse 22 fits with verses 23-25, but the drift is clear: worship should aim at understanding and conviction, because the One who knows every heart (John 2:24-25) is present by His Word.

vv. 26–33a

Order in the gathering

When they come together, “each one has a hymn, a lesson, a revelation” (v. 26): the gathering Paul describes was participatory, and churches today differ in how much of that pattern they keep. His rules are simple: tongues two or three, in turn, with an interpreter or else silence; prophets two or three, with the others weighing (diakrinō) what is said. Because “the spirits of prophets are subject to prophets” (v. 32), no one may plead that the Spirit compelled him to disrupt the meeting. Every word claiming to be from God is weighed, the Berean habit applied to the gathering (Acts 17:11; 1 John 4:1). This commentary holds that these rules still bind: where tongues are used today, they are used in the gathered church only with an interpreter (v. 28), weighed like prophecy, and never added to Scripture or given its authority. The ground of it all is God’s own character: “God is not a God of confusion but of peace.” Order in worship reflects the God who is worshiped.

vv. 33b-35

Women in the churches

The ESV attaches “As in all the churches of the saints” to verse 34; others attach it to verse 33. Paul has already assumed that women pray and prophesy (11:5), in the gathering as many read it, so whatever “keep silent” means, many readers agree it cannot simply cancel that. The main readings: (1) many complementarian readers take the silence to concern a particular speech, most often the weighing of prophecies just mentioned (v. 29), which they see as authoritative teaching reserved to qualified men (1 Timothy 2:11-12), with “as the Law also says” pointing to the order of creation in Genesis 2; (2) others see disruptive questions or talk during the service, given “let them ask their husbands at home,” and read it as a word about order in that setting; (3) some churches have read it as a broad rule of silence in public worship; (4) some egalitarian readers note that in a few manuscripts verses 34-35 stand after verse 40 and argue they were added later, while others think Paul is quoting a Corinthian position that he rebuts in verse 36. Every known manuscript contains the verses. Believers who share a high view of Scripture land in different places here, and the question is not a test of fellowship. This commentary holds, with 1 Timothy 2:12, that women should not deliver the sermon to the gathered church of men and women, and holds that conviction while remaining open to the conversation; it honors fully the gospel work Scripture records of women such as Phoebe, Priscilla, Junia, Euodia and Syntyche, and Philip’s daughters (Romans 16:1-7; Philippians 4:2-3; Acts 21:9). On no reading do these verses forbid a woman to speak up about harm done to her, to seek help, or to tell the truth to church leaders or the authorities. Using them to silence someone who has been wronged is a misuse of the text.

For discussion

How should 1 Corinthians 11:5 shape the way we read verses 34-35, whichever view we hold?

vv. 36–40

A command of the Lord

“Or was it from you that the word of God came?” (v. 36) rebukes a church acting as though God’s Word began and ended with them. Then Paul claims that what he writes is “a command of the Lord” (v. 37). The apostolic Word carries Christ’s own authority, and so every claim to prophecy is tested by it, not the reverse. The closing charge holds two things together: “earnestly desire to prophesy, and do not forbid speaking in tongues,” and do everything “decently and in order.” Cessationists read the first half as binding while those gifts were given; continuationists press it today; both read the second half as binding on every church. This commentary finds no text that withdraws the first half, so it does not forbid tongues, and it holds them to the second.

Threads across the chapter

  • Building up. The test of every gift runs through the chapter (vv. 3-5, 12, 17, 26).

  • Mind and Spirit together. Speech that is understood (vv. 6-12), praying with the mind (vv. 13-19), and mature thinking (v. 20) show that understanding is not the Spirit’s rival.

  • The outsider in the room. The one who cannot say Amen (v. 16) and the unbeliever who is convicted or repelled (vv. 23-25) are kept in view.

  • Order from God’s character. The rules of verses 26-33a and the closing charge of verse 40 rest on a God of peace (v. 33).

Key words

14:3, 5, 12, 26
οἰκοδομή oikodomē“Upbuilding,” building up; the test Paul applies to every gift
14:2
γλῶσσα glōssa“Tongue”; the tongue or a language, used for the gift of speaking in tongues
14:29
διακρίνω diakrinō“Weigh”; to judge or discern, the church’s testing of what is said
14:33
ἀκαταστασία akatastasia“Confusion”; disorder or tumult, the opposite of God’s peace

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    How does chapter 13 change the way we read Paul’s instructions about gifts in chapter 14?

  2. 2

    What does “building up” look like in an ordinary gathering of our church?

  3. 3

    If an unbeliever walked into our worship, what would he understand, and what might lead him to say that God is really among us?

  4. 4

    Why does Paul ground orderly worship in God’s character (v. 33) rather than in good manners?

  5. 5

    Believers who hold Scripture’s authority read verses 33b-35 differently. How can a church hold its own view with conviction and still treat those who differ as brothers and sisters?

My notes