The chapter at a glance
- 1–5Paul’s anguishIsrael’s privileges, and the Christ from them
- 6–13The Word has not failedThe promise runs by God’s choosing
- 14–18Mercy on whom He willsMercy is free, never owed
- 19–23Potter and clayThe creature does not judge the Maker
- 24–29Called from Jews and GentilesThe prophets foresaw the nations and a remnant
- 30–33The stumbling stoneRighteousness received by faith, missed by works
The chapter in brief
Paul turns from the unbreakable love of God to the sorrow of his life: most of his own people, Israel, have not believed in their Messiah. He has “great sorrow and unceasing anguish” in his heart and could wish himself accursed and cut off from Christ for their sake. To them belong the adoption, the glory, the covenants, the law, the worship, the promises, and the patriarchs, and from them, according to the flesh, comes the Christ, who is God over all. Yet God’s Word has not failed, for not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel. The promise ran through Isaac, not Ishmael, and through Jacob, not Esau, chosen before the twins were born or had done anything good or bad. God is not unjust: He has mercy on whom He has mercy, He raised up Pharaoh to show His power, and like a potter He has rights over the clay. He has called a people “not from the Jews only but also from the Gentiles,” as Hosea and Isaiah foretold. The chapter closes with a paradox: Gentiles who did not pursue righteousness have attained it by faith, while Israel, pursuing the law as if righteousness were based on works, stumbled over the stumbling stone.
Chapters 9-11 are not a detour from the gospel. If God’s promises to Israel have failed, the promises of Romans 8 cannot be trusted either, so the question here is the faithfulness of God. Paul’s answer begins with sovereign mercy: God’s purpose has always moved by election by grace, not by descent or merit, and this is the gospel of grace alone (chapters 3-4) seen from the side of God’s choosing. But the chapter must be read whole. It opens in tears, not triumph, and it ends with human responsibility and an open promise: whoever believes in Him will not be put to shame. Election in Romans 9 is a ground of hope and humility, never a reason for contempt toward Israel or anyone else.
Points for discussion
vv. 1–5
Anguish before argument
Before he says a word about election, Paul solemnly affirms his grief. “I could wish that I myself were accursed and cut off from Christ” (v. 3) may echo Moses, who asked to be blotted out of God’s book if Israel could not be forgiven (Exodus 32:32). Then he lists Israel’s privileges in the present tense: these things belong to them. Whoever reads chapters 9-11 without this posture has misread them. These chapters have been used to justify contempt for Jewish people, as though Israel’s unbelief made them a cursed race. That is a grave misuse of Scripture, and this commentary rejects it. Paul, himself a Jew, writes with tears; the Christ is Jewish according to the flesh; and chapter 11 warns Gentile believers against precisely this arrogance (11:18-20).
v. 5
“God over all”
The ESV reads that the Christ “is God over all, blessed forever.” The earliest manuscripts had little punctuation, so some translations place a full stop after “Christ” and read the rest as a separate blessing of God the Father. The ESV’s reading is the most natural way to take the Greek and is widely held, and it makes this one of Paul’s plainest statements of Christ’s deity (compare Titus 2:13). The doctrine does not hang on this verse alone (John 1:1; Colossians 2:9), but here it may stand at the climax of Israel’s privileges: their greatest gift is that God Himself came from them according to the flesh.
vv. 6–13
The Word has not failed
The thesis is verse 6: “it is not as though the word of God has failed.” The proof is that “not all who are descended from Israel belong to Israel,” a distinction within Israel, not a replacement of Israel by the Gentiles. Isaac, not Ishmael; Jacob, not Esau, though Jacob and Esau had the same father and mother and were chosen between before birth, “not because of works but because of him who calls” (v. 11). “Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated” quotes Malachi 1:2-3, and in Hebrew idiom love and hate can mean choosing and passing over (Genesis 29:30-31; Luke 14:26), not personal malice. Readers divide over what kind of election Paul means. One reading, held by many Arminian brothers, sees God choosing peoples rather than individuals: nations for a role in history (Genesis 25:23; Malachi 1:2-3), or a people in Christ whose members are those who believe (9:30-32). Another sees individuals chosen for salvation: Paul’s grief is over individual Israelites who are not saved (vv. 1-3), verse 11 sets God’s choice against “works,” which is the language of salvation, and the objections that follow (vv. 14, 19) arise only if the choice is unconditional. This commentary holds the second, with the Reformed confessions, because we believe it most faithfully reflects the Word, while gladly owning as brothers those who differ and who also confess salvation by grace through faith in Christ.
vv. 14–18
Mercy on whom He wills
“Is there injustice on God’s part? By no means!” (v. 14). Notice that Paul does not answer by appealing to foreseen faith, as one might expect if the choice rested on it. He quotes Exodus 33:19, God’s own words to Moses: mercy that is owed is not mercy. “So then it depends not on human will or exertion, but on God, who has mercy” (v. 16). Then Pharaoh, raised up so that God’s power and name would be proclaimed in all the earth (Exodus 9:16). Exodus says both that Pharaoh hardened his own heart (Exodus 8:15, 32) and that the LORD hardened it (Exodus 9:12). Scripture holds the two together without making God the author of sin: Pharaoh is responsible for his rebellion, and God is sovereign over it for His purpose.
vv. 19–23
Potter and clay
The next objection is sharper: if no one can resist His will, why does God still find fault? Paul gives no philosophical solution. He puts the questioner in his place: “But who are you, O man, to answer back to God?” (v. 20), drawing on the potter of Isaiah 29:16, 45:9, and Jeremiah 18:1-6. This is not a rebuke of honest lament, which the Psalms are full of, but of the creature who sits in judgment on his Maker. Notice the wording of verses 22-23. Of the vessels of mercy Paul says God “has prepared beforehand for glory,” naming God as the one who acts. Of the vessels of wrath he says only “prepared for destruction,” a passive form that names no agent, and adds that God “endured with much patience.” Many readers see a deliberate difference: salvation is wholly God’s work, while destruction is the just wage of sin (6:23). A reader troubled by whether he might be a vessel of wrath should hear the chapter’s own answer in verse 33: whoever believes in Him will not be put to shame. Election is known by coming to Christ, not by searching the hidden counsel of God (Deuteronomy 29:29; John 6:37), and it is never a label to fasten on another person.
For discussion
How do verses 14-23 and Paul’s prayer for Israel in Romans 10:1 belong together? Does believing that God chooses make us pray less or more?
vv. 24–29
Not my people
In Hosea 2:23 and 1:10 the promise that God would call “not my people” His people spoke first of restoring the northern tribes of Israel after judgment. Paul hears in it the same mercy now reaching the Gentiles: the God who can make “not my people” His people can do it for the nations. Isaiah supplies the other half. Only a remnant of Israel will be saved (Isaiah 10:22-23), and even that is God’s gift, for if the Lord had not left them offspring they would have been like Sodom (Isaiah 1:9). The remnant is not proof that God’s promise failed but proof that He kept it.
vv. 30–33
The stumbling stone
The chapter that began with God’s choosing ends with human pursuit. Israel pursued a law that would lead to righteousness but did not reach it, “because they did not pursue it by faith, but as if it were based on works” (v. 32). Paul holds both truths, God’s sovereign mercy (vv. 6-29) and real human responsibility for unbelief (9:30-10:21), without dissolving either into the other. The stone is Christ, drawn from Isaiah 28:16 and 8:14: a sure foundation to faith and a stumbling block to unbelief. And the chapter about election closes with an open door: “whoever believes in him will not be put to shame” (v. 33).
Threads across the chapter
God’s faithfulness on trial. The question of verse 6 is answered by the line of promise (vv. 6-13), the remnant (vv. 27-29), and the sure stone (v. 33).
Mercy, not merit. “Not because of works” (v. 11), mercy that is not owed (vv. 15-16), vessels of mercy (v. 23), and righteousness by faith (vv. 30-32) all say the same thing.
Sovereignty and responsibility. God’s free choice (vv. 14-23) and Israel’s pursuit of righteousness by works (vv. 30-33) stand side by side, unreconciled by Paul and both affirmed.
Grief as the frame. The anguish of verses 1-5 governs how the hard sayings of verses 13-23 are to be held: with tears and humility, never with pride.
Key words
- 9:3
- ἀνάθεμα anathema“Accursed,” devoted to destruction; what Paul could wish to be for Israel’s sake
- 9:11
- ἐκλογή eklogē“Election,” choice; God’s purpose that stands “not because of works but because of him who calls”
- 9:18
- σκληρύνω sklērynō“Harden”; God’s judicial hardening, as with Pharaoh, alongside Pharaoh’s own
- 9:21–23
- σκεῦος skeuos“Vessel”; the potter’s image for vessels of mercy and of wrath
Cross-references
- Exodus 32:32Moses asks to be blotted out for Israel’s sake
- Genesis 25:23“The older shall serve the younger,” quoted in Romans 9:12
- Malachi 1:2-3“Jacob I loved, but Esau I hated,” quoted in Romans 9:13
- Exodus 33:19“I will have mercy on whom I have mercy”
- Exodus 9:16God raised up Pharaoh to show His power
- Jeremiah 18:1-6The potter and the clay
- Hosea 2:23“Not my people” called “my people”
- Isaiah 28:16The tested cornerstone; whoever believes will not be put to shame
- 1
Why might Paul turn to Israel’s unbelief straight after promising that nothing can separate believers from God’s love?
- 2
How should Paul’s anguish in verses 1-3 shape the way we read, teach, and talk about the rest of the chapter?
- 3
Why does Paul answer the charge of injustice with God’s mercy (vv. 15-16) rather than with an explanation of God’s choices?
- 4
How can the doctrine of election be held as a comfort rather than a source of fear or pride, and how does verse 33 help?
- 5
Where might Christians be tempted to treat election as a reason to look down on others, and what in Romans 9-11 forbids it?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.