Numbers · Pentateuch (Law)

Numbers 31

Israel takes vengeance on Midian for Peor; Balaam is killed, and the spoil is divided and purified.

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–12The LORD’s vengeance on MidianJudgment for Peor, and Balaam falls
  2. 13–20Moses’ anger and commandMoses orders that the agents of Peor not be spared
  3. 21–24Purifying the spoilThrough fire and water
  4. 25–47Dividing the plunderHalf to the warriors, half to all, a share for the LORD
  5. 48–54Not a man missingAn offering of gold as a memorial

The chapter in brief

The LORD tells Moses, “Avenge the people of Israel on the Midianites. Afterward you shall be gathered to your people” (v. 2). A thousand men from each tribe go out with Phinehas, who carries the holy vessels and the trumpets. They kill the men of Midian, its five kings, and “Balaam the son of Beor” (v. 8), and they bring back women, children, livestock and goods. Moses is angry that the women who led Israel into sin at Peor, “on Balaam’s advice” (v. 16), have been spared. He orders the boys killed, and every woman who has lain with a man, and the young girls kept alive. The soldiers and captives are purified for seven days; metal goes through fire and water. The spoil is divided between the soldiers and the congregation, with a share for the LORD from each half. The officers find “not a man missing” (v. 49) and bring an offering of gold “to make atonement for ourselves” (v. 50).

This is the last task God gives Moses before his death (v. 2), and it settles the account of chapter 25. It is a hard chapter, and this commentary does not apologize for what God commanded (v. 2). God is just, and His judgment fell on a people who had set out to destroy Israel by seducing it from Him (25:18). It shows the seriousness of sin and points ahead to the final judgment, and the command was given once to Israel for that judgment; it gives no one a warrant for violence in God’s name today. It points to Christ as the Judge of all, and as the One who took judgment on Himself so that enemies could be reconciled (Romans 5:10). His kingdom does not advance by the sword: “My kingdom is not of this world” (John 18:36).

Points for discussion

vv. 1–12

The LORD’s vengeance

God calls it Israel’s vengeance (v. 2); Moses calls it “the LORD’s vengeance” (v. 3). Both are true, and the order matters: this was God’s judgment, not Israel’s grudge. Phinehas goes with the sanctuary vessels and trumpets (v. 6; 10:9), as a sign the battle is the LORD’s. Balaam dies among the Midianites (v. 8; Joshua 13:22): the man who said, “Let me die the death of the upright” (23:10) died among the enemies of God’s people. Revelation 2:14 and 2 Peter 2:15 keep his name as a warning. Midian appears again in Judges 6, so readers take this war as striking the Midianites allied with Moab at Peor, not every Midianite clan; Moses’ own father-in-law was a Midianite (Exodus 2:16-21).

vv. 13–18

The hardest verses

Moses, angry with the officers (v. 14), orders the boys killed, and every woman who had lain with a man, and the young girls kept “for yourselves” (v. 18). Read carefully what the text says. The LORD’s command was vengeance on Midian (v. 2). The order of verses 15-18 is Moses’ word, spoken in anger; the text records it without saying that God gave it in those words, and without rebuking it. It gives Moses’ reason: “these, on Balaam’s advice, caused the people of Israel to act treacherously against the LORD” (v. 16). It does not explain everything we would ask, and readers are right to feel the weight of it. Three things can be said honestly. The judgment on Midian was God’s, and God is just, even when we cannot see all His reasons (Genesis 18:25). The children who died are in the hands of a God who is both just and good, and we leave them to Him with hope and not dread. And the girls who were spared were purified with the soldiers (v. 19), and the law Moses gave on these same plains limited what a man could do with a captive woman: she could not be sold or treated as a slave (Deuteronomy 21:10-14). That law protected captives; it does not make taking them good. This passage gives no cover to anyone who treats a woman or child as plunder.

For discussion

How do we hold together God’s justice in passages like this and His mercy to Rahab, Ruth, and the nations? Consider Deuteronomy 9:5 and Romans 11:22.

vv. 19–24

Clean after battle

Even a war God commanded left the warriors unclean through contact with death (19:11-13). Killing, however justly done, is never treated as a light thing.

vv. 25–47

A share for the LORD and for all

The plunder is split between those who fought and those who stayed (v. 27), the same principle David later made a rule (1 Samuel 30:24-25). The soldiers gave one in five hundred of their half to the priest as the LORD’s tribute, and the congregation one in fifty of theirs to the Levites (vv. 28-30), so those who did not fight gave more.

vv. 48–54

Not a man missing

The officers count their men and find none lost. Their gold is offered “to make atonement for ourselves” (v. 50); many readers connect it with the ransom paid at a census (Exodus 30:12), and others see thanks mingled with awe at having taken life. It became “a memorial for the people of Israel before the LORD” (v. 54).

Threads across the chapter

  • Peor answered. The vengeance (vv. 2-3), Balaam’s death (v. 8), and Moses’ charge (v. 16) settle chapter 25.

  • As the LORD commanded. The phrase recurs through the battle and the division (vv. 7, 31, 41, 47).

  • Purity and death. The seven days outside the camp (v. 19) and the fire and water (vv. 22-23) guard the holy camp.

  • The LORD’s portion. The tribute (vv. 28-30, 41, 47) and the gold (vv. 50-54) give God His share.

Key words

31:2
נְקָמָה neqamah“Vengeance”; judgment that belongs to God (Deuteronomy 32:35; Romans 12:19)
31:19
חָטָא chata'“Purify” (in this verb form); cleansing from contact with death
31:50
כָּפַר kipper“Make atonement”; the officers’ offering of gold

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why is this war placed right before Moses’ death, and how does it close the story of Peor?

  2. 2

    What does Balaam’s end teach about knowing true things about God without belonging to Him?

  3. 3

    Verse 2 is the LORD’s command and verses 15-18 are Moses’ order. How do we read a passage like this honestly, without excusing it and without accusing God?

  4. 4

    Why can no Christian use this chapter to justify violence today, and what kind of warfare does the church wage instead (Ephesians 6:12)?

My notes