Judges · Historical Books

Judges 9

Abimelech murders his brothers to seize kingship, and he and Shechem destroy one another, as Jotham’s fable warned.

9:56

“Thus God returned the evil of Abimelech, which he committed against his father in killing his seventy brothers.”

Judges 9:56, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–6Abimelech made kingKinship, idol silver, and the murder of seventy brothers
  2. 7–21Jotham’s fableThe bramble king who offers only fire
  3. 22–25God sends an evil spiritGod begins to repay the bloodshed
  4. 26–41Gaal’s revoltShechem turns on its king
  5. 42–49Shechem destroyedAbimelech burns the stronghold of El-berith
  6. 50–57Death at ThebezA woman’s millstone, and God’s justice fulfilled

The chapter in brief

Abimelech, Gideon’s son by his concubine in Shechem, persuades his mother’s relatives to ask the leaders of Shechem whether seventy sons should rule them or one, “your bone and your flesh.” They give him seventy pieces of silver from the temple of Baal-berith, and he hires reckless men, goes to Ophrah, and kills his brothers, seventy men, on one stone. Only Jotham, the youngest, escapes by hiding. The leaders of Shechem make Abimelech king by the oak of the pillar. Jotham climbs Mount Gerizim and tells a fable: the olive, the fig, and the vine all refuse to leave their fruitfulness to rule the trees, but the bramble accepts and threatens fire that will devour the cedars. If Shechem has acted in good faith, let them rejoice in Abimelech; if not, let fire come out from each to devour the other. Abimelech rules three years. Then God sends an evil spirit between Abimelech and Shechem. Gaal son of Ebed stirs the city to revolt; Zebul the governor warns Abimelech, who defeats Gaal, destroys Shechem and sows it with salt, and burns about a thousand men and women in the stronghold of El-berith. At Thebez, as he approaches a tower to burn it, a woman drops an upper millstone on his head. Dying, he orders his armor-bearer to kill him so no one will say a woman killed him. “Thus God returned the evil of Abimelech,” and the curse of Jotham comes on Shechem.

This is the book’s first king, and he is a murderer chosen by kinship and paid with an idol’s silver. The chapter is a portrait of power seized rather than given, and of how such power devours both the ruler and the people who put him there. God is not absent from the violence: He sends the spirit that divides them, and He returns their evil on their own heads. Jotham’s fable points the way to the true King. The fruitful trees would not leave their fruit to rule; the bramble, which had nothing to give, was eager to rule. Many readers see in this the opposite of Christ, who is fruitful and life-giving and who came to rule by giving Himself, “taking the form of a servant” (Philippians 2:7), the King whose shade is real refuge.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–6

Kinship and silver

Abimelech’s appeal is “I am your bone and your flesh” (v. 2), and Shechem chooses him because “He is our brother” (v. 3). Shechem was the very place where Joshua had renewed the covenant with the LORD (Joshua 24:25); now its leaders fund a massacre with seventy pieces of silver from the house of Baal-berith (v. 4), “lord of the covenant.” One silver piece for each brother. Some readers see in the murder “on one stone” (v. 5) the look of a sacrifice on an altar. Everything about this kingship inverts the covenant: chosen by blood ties rather than by God (compare Deuteronomy 17:15), paid for by an idol, and founded on the death of brothers.

vv. 7–21

Jotham’s fable

Jotham’s parable is one of the few fables in Scripture, and it is pointed. The olive, the fig, and the vine are productive trees, and each refuses to leave its fruitfulness “and go hold sway over the trees” (vv. 9, 11, 13). Only the bramble, which bears nothing and gives no shade, accepts. Its offer is absurd, “come and take refuge in my shade” (v. 15), and its threat is real: fire. The fable does not condemn kingship as such, since God will later give Israel a king after His own heart (1 Samuel 13:14). It condemns the man who wants to rule because he has nothing else to give. Jotham ends with a conditional curse (vv. 19-20): if Shechem acted in good faith, may they rejoice; if not, may fire come out from each to devour the other. Then he runs (v. 21). He leaves the outcome with God.

For discussion

Why are the people best fitted to lead sometimes the least eager to rule, and the worst the most eager? Read Matthew 20:25-28.

vv. 22–25

God sent an evil spirit

“God sent an evil spirit between Abimelech and the leaders of Shechem” (v. 23). The purpose is stated in the next verse: that the violence done to the seventy “might come, and their blood be laid on Abimelech... and on the men of Shechem” (v. 24). Scripture speaks this way elsewhere too (1 Samuel 16:14; 1 Kings 22:22-23). It does not make God the author of their sin. Abimelech and Shechem were already treacherous; God gave them over to the distrust they had sown, so that their own wickedness became their punishment. God is sovereign over evil without ever doing evil (James 1:13), which is what the Westminster Confession teaches in its chapter on providence. For a reader troubled by evil that seems to go unpunished, this chapter is a comfort: “Thus God returned the evil” (v. 56).

vv. 50–57

The millstone

Abimelech killed his brothers on a stone, and he dies by a stone, an upper millstone dropped by “a certain woman” (v. 53). His last concern is his reputation: “lest they say of me, ’A woman killed him’” (v. 54). It did not work. Israel remembered exactly that, and Joab later uses the story as a warning not to go near a wall (2 Samuel 11:21). The chapter closes by naming God as the one who repaid both the king and the city (vv. 56-57), and by noting that Jotham’s curse came true. The innocent brother who ran for his life was vindicated by God, not by his own sword.

Threads across the chapter

  • Seventy. Seventy brothers (vv. 2, 5, 18, 24, 56) and seventy pieces of silver (v. 4) tie the crime to the price and to the final repayment.

  • Stone. The brothers are killed on one stone (vv. 5, 18), and Abimelech dies by a millstone (v. 53).

  • Fire. The bramble threatens fire (v. 15), Jotham’s curse calls for fire (v. 20), and Abimelech burns the stronghold (v. 49) and is struck while trying to burn a tower (v. 52).

  • God repays. God sends the spirit (vv. 23-24) and returns the evil of king and city (vv. 56-57), fulfilling Jotham’s words (vv. 19-20).

Key words

8:31; 9:1
אֲבִימֶלֶךְ avimelekh“Abimelech”; “my father is king,” a name that claims what Gideon had refused
9:14
אָטָד atad“Bramble”; a thornbush that bears no fruit and gives no shade, Jotham’s picture of Abimelech
9:23
רוּחַ רָעָה ruach ra'ah“Evil spirit”; a spirit of distrust God sent so that the guilty would reap what they had sown
9:56–57
שׁוּב shuv“Returned”; God turned back their evil on their own heads

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Chapter 8 ended with Israel forgetting Gideon’s family; chapter 9 shows one of his sons murdering the rest. How does the end of chapter 8 prepare for this?

  2. 2

    Abimelech’s claim was “I am your bone and your flesh.” What makes kinship or loyalty a dangerous reason to follow a leader?

  3. 3

    What does Jotham’s fable say about the kind of person who wants power for its own sake? Where do you see the bramble in your own heart?

  4. 4

    How does God’s sending of an “evil spirit” fit with the truth that God never does evil?

  5. 5

    Jotham fled and left his cause with God. How does the chapter encourage those who have been wronged by powerful people?

My notes