8:23
“Gideon said to them, ’I will not rule over you, and my son will not rule over you; the LORD will rule over you.’”
The chapter at a glance
- 1–3Ephraim calmedA gentle answer turns away a tribe’s anger
- 4–9Succoth and Penuel refuseTowns that would not help the LORD’s army
- 10–12The kings capturedGod completes the victory over Midian
- 13–21Gideon’s reprisalsPunishment and personal vengeance
- 22–28The crown refused, the ephod madeRight words, and a snare to his house
- 29–35Gideon’s death and Israel’s relapseIsrael forgets the LORD and Gideon’s house
The chapter in brief
The men of Ephraim fiercely accuse Gideon of not calling them to the battle, and he calms them by praising their capture of Oreb and Zeeb above his own work. Crossing the Jordan exhausted, Gideon and his 300 ask the towns of Succoth and Penuel for bread, and both refuse, mocking him; he vows to punish them. He surprises the remaining Midianite army at Karkor and captures the two kings, Zebah and Zalmunna. On his return he flails the elders of Succoth with thorns and briers, breaks down the tower of Penuel, and kills its men. When the kings admit killing men at Tabor who were his own brothers, Gideon tells his young son Jether to kill them; the boy is afraid, and Gideon kills them himself. The men of Israel ask him to rule over them and his sons after him. He refuses: “the LORD will rule over you.” But he asks for the gold earrings from the spoil, makes an ephod, and sets it up in Ophrah, where “all Israel whored after it,” and it becomes a snare to him and his family. The land rests forty years. Gideon has many wives and seventy sons, and a concubine in Shechem bears him a son he names Abimelech. As soon as Gideon dies, Israel turns to Baal-berith and forgets the LORD.
Gideon’s story turns in this chapter. The man who began hiding in a winepress ends punishing towns, avenging his brothers, and setting up a shrine. His words are right, “the LORD will rule over you,” but his life drifts toward a king’s: gold, many wives, a son named in a way that may mean “my father is king.” Judges shows that even the best deliverer cannot keep himself or his people from relapse, and it leaves the reader longing for the King who would truly rule for God. Jesus is that King. He refused the crown the crowds tried to give Him by force (John 6:15) and took instead the way of the servant: “the Son of Man came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many” (Matthew 20:28).
Points for discussion
vv. 1–3
A soft answer
Ephraim’s complaint is about honor: why were they not called? Gideon answers by lowering himself and praising them: “Is not the gleaning of the grapes of Ephraim better than the grape harvest of Abiezer?” (v. 2). Their anger subsides. It is a living example of Proverbs 15:1: “A soft answer turns away wrath.” Jephthah will face the same complaint from Ephraim and answer it very differently (Judges 12:1-6). The contrast shows how much a leader’s humility can spare a people.
vv. 4–21
Succoth, Penuel, and personal vengeance
Succoth and Penuel were Israelite towns, and their refusal to feed the LORD’s army was a real wrong, like Meroz’s in the Song of Deborah (Judges 5:23). But Gideon’s response is fierce: flailing the elders with thorns and briers, tearing down Penuel’s tower, and killing its men (vv. 16-17). Then the story reveals a private motive. The men killed at Tabor were “my brothers, the sons of my mother,” and Gideon says he would have spared the kings if they had spared his brothers (v. 19). The war of the LORD has become, at least in part, a family feud. Asking his young son to do the killing (v. 20) adds a sad note: Gideon passes his anger to the next generation, and the next chapter shows what happens to his sons. Scripture records these acts; it does not commend them.
For discussion
How can a fight that began as God’s cause become a personal grievance? Read James 1:19-20.
vv. 22–27
“The LORD will rule over you”
Gideon’s refusal of the crown is one of the best sentences in the book: “I will not rule over you, and my son will not rule over you; the LORD will rule over you” (v. 23). Then, in the next breath, he asks for gold. He makes an ephod, the garment the high priest wore to seek the LORD’s will (Exodus 28:6-30), and sets it in his own town. Readers are not agreed on what Gideon meant by it: an attempt to provide a way of inquiring of God, a memorial of victory, or a rival shrine. Whatever he intended, “all Israel whored after it there, and it became a snare to Gideon and to his family” (v. 27). The word “snare” is the one the angel used of the Canaanite gods (Judges 2:3). Right words do not protect a leader whose choices quietly gather what he has refused in name. Many readers also notice his many wives (v. 30), one of the marks of the kings Deuteronomy 17:17 warned against, and the name he gives his son, Abimelech, “my father is king” (v. 31).
vv. 33–35
Forgetting the LORD and His servant
As soon as Gideon dies, Israel goes after the Baals and makes “Baal-berith their god” (v. 33). The name means “lord of the covenant.” Israel had a covenant Lord; they traded Him for a counterfeit with the same title. And they “did not remember the LORD their God” and showed no “steadfast love” to Gideon’s family (vv. 34-35). Ingratitude toward God and ingratitude toward people go together. This is the downward spiral of Judges 2:19 in a single verse, and it sets the stage for the bloodshed of chapter 9.
Threads across the chapter
Humility and its loss. Gideon’s soft answer to Ephraim (vv. 1-3) gives way to harsh reprisals on Succoth and Penuel (vv. 7-9, 16-17).
The LORD’s war and Gideon’s. The pursuit of Midian’s kings (vv. 10-12) turns into vengeance for “my brothers” (vv. 18-21).
King in word and deed. Gideon refuses the crown (v. 23) but gathers gold (vv. 24-26), wives (v. 30), and a son named “my father is king” (v. 31).
Snares. The ephod becomes a snare to Gideon’s house (v. 27) and Israel turns to Baal-berith (v. 33), as the angel had warned (Judges 2:3).
Key words
- 8:22–23
- מָשַׁל mashal“Rule”; the word Israel uses to offer Gideon a dynasty and Gideon uses to give the rule back to the LORD
- 8:27
- אֵפוֹד ephod“Ephod”; the high priest’s garment used in seeking God’s will, here turned into an object of worship
- 8:33
- בַּעַל בְּרִית ba'al berit“Baal-berith”; “lord of the covenant,” the false god Israel set in the place of the true covenant Lord
- 8:35
- חֶסֶד chesed“Steadfast love”; covenant loyalty, which Israel failed to show to Gideon’s family
Cross-references
- Proverbs 15:1A soft answer turns away wrath
- Judges 12:1-6Jephthah’s very different answer to Ephraim
- Judges 5:23Meroz cursed for not coming to the help of the LORD
- Exodus 28:6-30The ephod of the high priest
- Deuteronomy 17:15-17The king God would choose, warned against many wives and much gold
- 1 Samuel 8:7In asking for a king, Israel rejected the LORD as King
- John 6:15Jesus withdraws when the crowd would make Him king by force
- Matthew 20:25-28The Son of Man came not to be served but to serve
- 1
Gideon began hiding in a winepress and ends setting up an ephod. Looking back over chapters 6-8, where do you see the turn begin?
- 2
Why does a soft answer work with Ephraim, and what does that teach about handling conflict in a family or church?
- 3
Gideon said the right thing about the LORD’s rule and then did something that undercut it. Where are we tempted to do the same?
- 4
How does the forgetting in verses 33-35 show the link between forgetting God and failing to love people?
- 5
How is Jesus the King that Gideon refused to be and could not have been?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.