Judges · Historical Books

Judges 11

Jephthah delivers Israel from Ammon but binds himself with a rash and tragic vow concerning his daughter.

11:27

“I therefore have not sinned against you, and you do me wrong by making war on me. The LORD, the Judge, decide this day between the people of Israel and the people of Ammon.”

Judges 11:27, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–3Jephthah driven outThe son of a prostitute is rejected by his brothers
  2. 4–11Recalled by the eldersThe rejected man is bargained back as head
  3. 12–28Appeal to historyJephthah argues Israel’s right and calls on the LORD the Judge
  4. 29–33The Spirit, the vow, the victoryVictory from the LORD, and a vow He did not ask for
  5. 34–40Jephthah’s daughterA father’s word costs an only child

The chapter in brief

Jephthah the Gileadite is a mighty warrior, the son of Gilead by a prostitute. His half-brothers drive him out, saying he will have no inheritance, and he lives in the land of Tob, where worthless men gather to him. When the Ammonites make war, the elders of Gilead come to bring him back. He reminds them that they drove him out, and they promise to make him head over all Gilead; he agrees on the condition that he remain head if the LORD gives him victory, and he speaks all his words “before the LORD at Mizpah.” Jephthah sends messengers to the king of Ammon, who claims the land between the Arnon and the Jabbok. Jephthah answers with history: Israel did not take land from Moab or Ammon but went around them, and it was Sihon king of the Amorites who attacked Israel and lost his land to the LORD; Israel has held it 300 years. He ends, “The LORD, the Judge, decide this day.” The king does not listen. Then the Spirit of the LORD is upon Jephthah, and he makes a vow: if the LORD gives him the Ammonites, “whatever comes out from the doors of my house to meet me... shall be the LORD’s, and I will offer it up for a burnt offering.” The LORD gives him a great victory. When he comes home, his daughter, his only child, comes out to meet him with tambourines and dances. He tears his clothes and says he cannot take back his vow. She tells him to do as he has vowed, asks for two months to weep for her virginity on the mountains with her companions, and returns, and he does “according to his vow.” It becomes a custom that the daughters of Israel lament her four days every year.

This is one of the most painful chapters in the Bible, and it is meant to be. An outcast becomes a deliverer, argues well, receives the Spirit, wins a great victory, and then destroys his own household with his own mouth. The LORD gave the victory; the LORD did not ask for the vow. Hebrews 11:32 names Jephthah among those who acted by faith, which shows that God works through people whose faith is real and whose understanding is badly flawed. The chapter also sets two fathers and two only children side by side. When Abraham was told to offer “your only son Isaac” (Genesis 22:2), God Himself stopped the knife and provided the lamb. Jephthah’s daughter had no such rescue from her father’s words. The one Father who did offer His only Son did so not to keep a rash word but out of love, “He who did not spare his own Son but gave him up for us all” (Romans 8:32), and that sacrifice ended every other.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–11

The rejected son

Jephthah’s story begins with injustice. His brothers drive him out because of his mother (v. 2), the elders apparently allow it (v. 7), and he gathers “worthless fellows” in exile. When trouble comes, the same elders want him back. Jephthah bargains hard and makes his headship depend on the LORD giving him victory (v. 9), and he speaks “all his words before the LORD at Mizpah” (v. 11). Readers have long noticed the pattern of the rejected one who becomes the deliverer of those who rejected him, the pattern of Joseph and of David, and many see in it a faint outline of the stone the builders rejected (Psalm 118:22; Acts 4:11). But the differences matter as much as the likeness. Jephthah negotiates for position; Christ “emptied himself, by taking the form of a servant” (Philippians 2:7), for those who rejected Him.

vv. 12–28

“The LORD, the Judge”

Jephthah’s long message to the king of Ammon is a careful argument from Israel’s history in Numbers 20-21. Israel went around Edom and Moab, and only fought Sihon of the Amorites when he attacked them; the LORD gave that land to Israel (vv. 16-23). Jephthah notes that Israel has held it for 300 years (v. 26), a figure that sits naturally with the traditional early date of the exodus that this commentary holds, though chronologies differ. He even speaks of “Chemosh your god” (v. 24), the god of Moab (Numbers 21:29; 1 Kings 11:7), which may mean the disputed land had once been Moab’s or that Ammon was pressing Moab’s claim; readers are not agreed. His final appeal is the high point of the chapter: “The LORD, the Judge, decide this day” (v. 27). In a book named for judges, the true Judge is the LORD.

vv. 29–33

The vow

“Then the Spirit of the LORD was upon Jephthah” (v. 29), and then, with the victory already as good as given, Jephthah makes a vow. The Spirit equipped him for battle; the text does not say the Spirit prompted the vow. The vow tries to secure what God had already shown He would give. The ESV notes that “whatever” in verse 31 can be read “whoever,” and Israelite houses often sheltered animals and people together, so a man vowing a burnt offering of whatever came out of his doors had already put a person within reach of his words. The law did not require such a vow (Deuteronomy 23:22); it forbade offering children (Leviticus 18:21; Deuteronomy 12:31) and gave a way to redeem a person vowed to the LORD with money (Leviticus 27:2-8). “It is a snare to say rashly, ’It is holy,’ and to reflect only after making vows” (Proverbs 20:25).

For discussion

Jephthah tried to secure God’s help with a promise. Where are we tempted to bargain with God for what He has already promised freely? Read Romans 8:32.

vv. 34–40

What Jephthah did

Faithful readers read the ending two ways, and both have long been held by people who love the Bible. One reading takes it at its plain sense: Jephthah offered his daughter as a burnt offering, as his vow said (v. 31) and as verse 39 states, “who did with her according to his vow”; on this reading the chapter records a horror that Israel’s law forbade, possibly shaped by pagan practice (compare 2 Kings 3:27). The other reading holds that he dedicated her to the LORD for life, unmarried, perhaps in service at the sanctuary. It points to her two months of weeping for her “virginity” rather than for her life, to the note that “she had never known a man” (v. 39), to the redemption the law allowed (Leviticus 27:2-8), and to the fact that the text never says she died; some also take the Hebrew “and” before “I will offer it up” in verse 31 as “or,” so that an animal would be offered and a person dedicated. This commentary leans, tentatively, toward the first reading as the more natural sense of the words, and holds that lean with an open hand: the second is a serious reading of the same text, not an evasion of it. On either reading the text does not approve what Jephthah did, God never asked for it, and Jephthah’s first words when he saw her, “you have become the cause of great trouble to me” (v. 35), blame the daughter for the father’s vow. The Westminster Confession teaches that no one may vow to do anything forbidden in the Word of God (22.7): a promise to sin binds no one. The daughter is the one who speaks with dignity, and the daughters of Israel refused to forget her (v. 40).

A word to anyone who has suffered because of a parent’s or a leader’s promises, rages, or religion: this chapter does not ask you to call that faith. God forbade what was done to Jephthah’s daughter, and He saw her when her father looked only at his vow. If you have been harmed by someone who should have protected you, it was not your fault. Tell someone you trust, and where a crime has been done, it belongs with the authorities.

Threads across the chapter

  • Rejection and return. Jephthah is driven out (vv. 1-3) and brought back as head (vv. 4-11), and the rejected son ends by losing his own only child (vv. 34-40).

  • Words spoken before the LORD. Jephthah speaks his terms “before the LORD” (v. 11), appeals to “the LORD, the Judge” (v. 27), and vows “to the LORD” (vv. 30-31, 35-36), and the chapter weighs what each kind of speech was worth.

  • History rightly told. Jephthah tells Israel’s past accurately to Ammon (vv. 15-27), yet he does not apply the law’s teaching on vows and children to his own house (vv. 30-31, 39).

  • Daughters. Jephthah’s daughter comes out with tambourines like Miriam (v. 34; Exodus 15:20), speaks with courage (vv. 36-37), and is remembered by the daughters of Israel (v. 40).

Key words

11:30, 11:39
נֶדֶר neder“Vow”; a solemn promise to the LORD, often conditional, which the law regulated and never required
11:31
עֹלָה olah“Burnt offering”; the offering wholly consumed on the altar, the word that makes the plain reading of the vow so dark
11:34
יְחִידָה yechidah“Only child”; the feminine form of the word used of Isaac, “your only son” (Genesis 22:2)
11:35–36
פָּצָה פֶה patsah peh“Opened my mouth”; Jephthah’s phrase for his vow, which his daughter repeats back to him

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Chapter 10 ended with Gilead’s leaders offering headship to whoever would fight. How does Jephthah’s bargaining with the elders show the kind of leader that offer produced?

  2. 2

    Jephthah’s appeal to “the LORD, the Judge” is right, but his vow is rash. How can a person be wise in one part of life and foolish in another?

  3. 3

    Why do you think Jephthah made a vow after the Spirit of the LORD had already come upon him?

  4. 4

    How do you read verses 34-40, and what in the text supports your reading? What do both readings agree on?

  5. 5

    Hebrews 11:32 names Jephthah among the faithful. What does that tell you about the kind of people God works through, and how does Romans 8:32 answer the darkness of this chapter?

My notes