Judges · Historical Books

Judges 1

After Joshua’s death the tribes fight the Canaanites with only partial success, failing to drive many of them out.

1:19

“And the LORD was with Judah, and he took possession of the hill country, but he could not drive out the inhabitants of the plain because they had chariots of iron.”

Judges 1:19, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–7Judah goes up firstGod answers and gives victory; Adoni-bezek owns God’s justice
  2. 8–15Hebron, Debir, and AchsahCaleb’s household shows faith and generous blessing
  3. 16–21Judah’s gains and limitsThe LORD was with Judah, yet the plain was left
  4. 22–26Bethel and the informantA man spared like Rahab, but never joined to Israel
  5. 27–36The roll of failureTribe after tribe settles for coexistence and forced labor

The chapter in brief

After the death of Joshua, Israel asks the LORD, “Who shall go up first for us against the Canaanites?” and He answers, “Judah shall go up; behold, I have given the land into his hand.” Judah, joined by Simeon, defeats the Canaanites at Bezek and captures Adoni-bezek, who confesses that God has repaid him for the seventy kings he maimed. Judah strikes Jerusalem, Hebron and the hill country, and Caleb gives his daughter Achsah to Othniel for taking Debir; she asks her father for a blessing and receives the upper and lower springs. Then the chapter turns. Judah cannot drive out the people of the plain, Benjamin leaves the Jebusites in Jerusalem, and the house of Joseph takes Bethel by sparing an informant who goes off to build another Luz. A long roll follows of tribes that “did not drive out” the Canaanites: Manasseh, Ephraim, Zebulun, Asher, Naphtali, and finally Dan, pressed back into the hills by the Amorites.

The chapter is a slow slide told in a list. It begins with Israel asking the LORD and ends with Israel settling for forced labor and coexistence, the very compromise Moses had warned would turn Israel’s heart to other gods (Deuteronomy 7:2-4). The conquest was God’s just judgment on the nations of Canaan, as this commentary holds, and it gives no one a warrant for violence in God’s name today; what this chapter shows is a people who stopped short of what God had told them to do. It also opens the book’s ache for a leader. Joshua is dead, and no one takes his place. Hebrews says that Joshua did not give God’s people their final rest (Hebrews 4:8), and Judges begins by showing how far from rest they were. The greater Joshua, whose name means “the LORD saves,” finishes what no tribe could: He disarmed the powers and triumphed over them (Colossians 2:15), and He leaves no enemy unconquered at the last.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–7

Judah first

The book opens with the right question, asked of the right Person, and the LORD names Judah, the tribe of the scepter (Genesis 49:10). The same question and the same answer, “Judah shall go up first,” return near the end of the book (Judges 20:18), but there the enemy is Benjamin, a tribe of Israel. The frame quietly shows how far the people fall between the first chapter and the last. Adoni-bezek’s words, “As I have done, so God has repaid me” (v. 7), are a Canaanite king’s confession that God judges justly. Scripture records the maiming; it does not command it. What it does show is a man who knew that the measure he had used on others had come back to him.

vv. 11–15

Achsah’s request

In a chapter of failure, Caleb’s household shines. Caleb, who decades earlier had trusted God against the giants of Hebron (Numbers 14:24; Joshua 14:6-14), now drives out the sons of Anak (v. 20). His kinsman Othniel takes Debir and will become the first judge (Judges 3:9). And his daughter Achsah boldly asks, “Give me a blessing,” and receives more than she asked: the upper springs and the lower springs. Many readers note that Judges begins with a daughter honored and generously blessed by her father, and that the book’s later daughters (Jephthah’s daughter in chapter 11, the Levite’s concubine in chapter 19) fare far worse as the nation decays. The way a people treats its daughters is one of the book’s measures of its health.

For discussion

Achsah asks her father boldly and is not rebuked. Read Luke 11:11-13. What does a good father’s generosity teach about how we may ask of God?

vv. 16–21

“Could not”

Verse 19 holds two things side by side: “the LORD was with Judah,” and Judah “could not drive out the inhabitants of the plain because they had chariots of iron.” Read alone, the verse might suggest that iron was stronger than the LORD. But Joshua had told the house of Joseph that they would drive out the Canaanites “though they have chariots of iron” (Joshua 17:18), and later in this book the LORD routs a general with 900 of them (Judges 4:13-15). Many readers therefore take “could not” as the inability of fear and unbelief rather than of God’s power. The next verses move from “could not” to “did not” (v. 21), and the rest of the chapter uses only “did not.”

vv. 22–26

The man from Bethel

The spies promise to “deal kindly” with the man who shows them the way in, and they keep their word. The scene echoes Rahab, who asked Israel’s spies to deal kindly with her house (Joshua 2:12). The difference is telling. Rahab confessed the LORD and “has lived in Israel to this day” (Joshua 6:25). This man takes his life and goes off to the land of the Hittites to rebuild the old Canaanite city of Luz. He is spared, but he never joins the people of God. Rescue without faith only carries the old life somewhere else.

vv. 27–36

The roll of failure

Read slowly, the list gets worse as it goes. First the Canaanites persist among Israel and are put to forced labor (vv. 27-30). Then the wording flips: “the Asherites lived among the Canaanites” (v. 32), and so did Naphtali (v. 33). Last of all, Dan cannot even keep its ground and is pushed into the hills (v. 34). Forced labor looked like victory, and it was profitable, but God had told Israel to devote the cities of these nations to destruction “that they may not teach you to do according to all their abominable practices” (Deuteronomy 20:18). Israel kept the Canaanites for their labor and soon learned their gods (Judges 2:11-13; Psalm 106:34-36). The danger was never Canaanite blood; it was Canaanite worship, as Rahab and later Ruth show. A sin kept for its usefulness rarely stays a servant.

For discussion

Where do we tolerate something God has told us to put away because it seems useful, manageable, or profitable? Read Hebrews 12:1.

Threads across the chapter

  • Asking and settling. The chapter opens with Israel inquiring of the LORD (vv. 1-2) and ends with tribes settling for coexistence without any word of asking (vv. 27-36).

  • Faith in a household. Caleb, Othniel and Achsah (vv. 11-15, 20) stand out against the tribes around them (vv. 21, 27-36), showing that faithfulness was possible in the same land and the same years.

  • From “could not” to “did not”. Judah’s limit (v. 19) gives way to Benjamin’s failure (v. 21) and the long refrain of “did not drive out” (vv. 27-33).

  • Kindness and its limits. Adoni-bezek owns God’s justice (v. 7) and the Bethel informant receives mercy (vv. 24-26), yet neither turns to the LORD.

Key words

1:17
חָרַם charam“Devoted it to destruction”; to set apart wholly to the LORD in judgment, which gives Hormah its name (the ESV footnote: “utter destruction”)
1:28
מַס mas“Forced labor”; the compromise by which Israel profited from the Canaanites instead of obeying God’s command about them
1:15
בְּרָכָה berakah“Blessing”; Achsah’s request, answered with springs of water in a dry land

Cross-references

  • Deuteronomy 7:2-4The command not to make covenants or intermarry with the nations, lest they turn Israel to other gods
  • Numbers 33:55Those left in the land would be barbs in the eyes and thorns in the sides
  • Joshua 15:16-19The same account of Othniel and Achsah
  • Joshua 17:18Joseph promised victory “though they have chariots of iron”
  • Joshua 2:12; 6:25Rahab, spared and joined to Israel, unlike the man from Bethel
  • Judges 20:18“Judah shall go up first,” now against Benjamin
  • Psalm 106:34-36Israel did not destroy the peoples and served their idols
  • Hebrews 4:8Joshua did not give the people their final rest

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Joshua’s book ends with a faithful generation; Judges opens with the question “Who shall go up first for us?” Why does the book begin with a leaderless people asking the LORD for direction?

  2. 2

    Verse 19 says both that the LORD was with Judah and that Judah could not drive out the people of the plain. How do you hold those two statements together?

  3. 3

    What made forced labor look like a reasonable compromise, and why was it so dangerous?

  4. 4

    Caleb’s family is faithful in a failing generation. What does that say about whether our faithfulness depends on the spiritual climate around us?

  5. 5

    Hebrews 4:8 says Joshua did not give the people rest. How does Jesus finish what the tribes of Judges 1 left undone?

My notes