5:15
“Take off your sandals from your feet, for the place where you are standing is holy.”
The chapter at a glance
The chapter in brief
When the kings of the Amorites and Canaanites hear that the LORD dried up the Jordan, their hearts melt. At that moment, in enemy territory, the LORD tells Joshua to make flint knives and circumcise the sons of Israel a second time. The generation born in the wilderness had not been circumcised, and now they are, at a place named Gibeath-haaraloth. They stay in camp until they heal, and the LORD says, “Today I have rolled away the reproach of Egypt from you” (v. 9), which gives Gilgal its name. On the fourteenth day of the month they keep the Passover on the plains of Jericho. The next day they eat the produce of the land, and the day after that the manna stops for good. Then, near Jericho, Joshua sees a man with a drawn sword. “Are you for us, or for our adversaries?” Joshua asks. “No; but I am the commander of the army of the LORD. Now I have come” (vv. 13-14). Joshua falls on his face, and is told to take off his sandals, for the place is holy.
Before Israel fights, it is marked again as God’s covenant people, it remembers its redemption at the Passover, and its leader is reminded that the battle belongs to the LORD. Christ stands behind every part of the chapter: He is the true circumcision, “the circumcision of Christ” (Colossians 2:11); “Christ, our Passover lamb, has been sacrificed” (1 Corinthians 5:7); and He is “the living bread that came down from heaven” (John 6:51), the reality of the manna Israel no longer needed. Whether the commander of the LORD’s army was the Son Himself is a question faithful readers answer differently, and is taken up below.
Points for discussion
vv. 2–9
Circumcised in enemy country
The timing looks foolish. Most of Israel’s fighting men are made unable to fight, within sight of Jericho, just as the kings of Canaan hear of Israel’s arrival. Genesis shows what could happen to men in that condition (Genesis 34:25). The command is an act of faith: Israel’s safety rests on the LORD, not on readiness for battle. The wilderness generation had not given their sons the covenant sign (vv. 5-7); the text does not say why, but it ties the generation’s death to their unbelief (v. 6). Their children now receive the sign their fathers had neglected.
“The reproach of Egypt” (v. 9) has been read as Egypt’s taunt that the LORD could not bring His people into the land (Exodus 32:12; Numbers 14:13-16), or as the shame of slavery, or as the shame of the uncircumcised state. On every reading, the LORD rolls it away (galal, the sound in “Gilgal”).
Circumcision always pointed to the heart (Deuteronomy 10:16; Romans 2:29), and Paul says believers have received “a circumcision made without hands, ... by the circumcision of Christ” (Colossians 2:11), joined there to baptism (2:12). Christians differ on what that link means for baptism and the children of believers; this commentary sets out its conviction with Colossians 2:11-12, since this passage concerns Israel’s covenant sign renewed in the land.
vv. 10–12
Passover, and the end of manna
No uncircumcised man could eat the Passover (Exodus 12:48), so the order of the chapter is the order of the law. The last Passover Scripture records was at Sinai (Numbers 9:1-5); now Israel keeps it in the land. The next day they eat “unleavened cakes and parched grain” from the land, and the day after, the manna stops. For forty years God had fed them every morning; now He feeds them from fields they did not plant (Deuteronomy 6:11). God’s provision did not end; it changed form. Both the Passover and the manna are fulfilled in Christ: the Lamb of God “who takes away the sin of the world” (John 1:29), and the bread from heaven of which Jesus said, “If anyone eats of this bread, he will live forever” (John 6:51).
vv. 13–15
“Are you for us?” “No”
Joshua’s question is the natural one, and the answer is startling: “No.” The commander has not come to join Israel’s side; he has come to take command. The question is not whether God is on our side, but whether we are on His. Joshua understands at once, falls on his face, and asks for orders: “What does my lord say to his servant?” (v. 14).
Who is he? Christians give three main answers. Many Reformed readers see a Christophany, the Son appearing before His incarnation. They point to Joshua’s falling down to worship (v. 14) without rebuke, where angels elsewhere refuse it (“You must not do that! ... Worship God,” Revelation 22:9); to the command to remove sandals because the place is holy, nearly the words spoken from the burning bush (Exodus 3:5); and to 6:2, where “the LORD said to Joshua” may continue the same encounter. Others read a theophany: the LORD present in visible form, without the text saying which person of the Godhead appeared. Others read a created angel, the chief of the LORD’s heavenly host, like Michael, “one of the chief princes” (Daniel 10:13); they note that the ESV gives “paid homage” as an alternative to “worshiped” (v. 14), the bow a servant gives a great lord, and that ground is made holy by God’s presence and purpose, not only by a visible appearance of the Son. Scripture does not settle it here, and this commentary takes no stand. On any reading Joshua stands before the LORD’s own power and purpose, and if the commander was the Son, He did not become anything He was not; He took our flesh only at the incarnation (John 1:14).
For discussion
What changes when we stop asking whether God is on our side and start asking whether we are on His? Compare Matthew 16:23-24.
Threads across the chapter
Rolled away. The reproach of Egypt rolled away (v. 9) answers the hearts of Canaan melting away (v. 1).
Old things ending, new things beginning. The wilderness generation is gone (vv. 4-6), the manna ends (v. 12), and the fruit of the land begins (vv. 11-12).
Holiness before battle. Circumcision (vv. 2-8), Passover (v. 10), and holy ground (v. 15) all come before the first city falls.
Who commands. Joshua’s question (v. 13) is answered by the commander’s “No” and by Joshua’s “What does my lord say to his servant?” (v. 14).
Key words
- 5:9
- חֶרְפָּה cherpah“Reproach”; shame or disgrace, here rolled away by the LORD
- 5:9
- גָּלַל galal“Roll”; the wordplay behind the name Gilgal (ESV note)
- 5:14
- שַׂר־צְבָא־יְהוָה sar-tseva-YHWH“Commander of the army of the LORD”; captain of the LORD’s hosts
- 5:14
- הִשְׁתַּחֲוָה hishtachavah“Worshiped” or “paid homage” (ESV note); to bow down to the ground
Cross-references
- Exodus 3:5“Take your sandals off your feet” at the burning bush
- Exodus 12:48No uncircumcised person shall eat the Passover
- Colossians 2:11-12The circumcision of Christ, and baptism
- Romans 2:29Circumcision as a matter of the heart
- 1 Corinthians 5:7Christ our Passover lamb
- John 6:49-51The manna and the living bread
- Daniel 10:13Michael, one of the chief princes
- Revelation 22:8-9An angel refuses worship
- 1
Why does God have Israel circumcised and keep the Passover before the first battle, rather than after?
- 2
What does the end of the manna teach about how God’s provision can change form without ending?
- 3
How do the Passover and the manna point to Christ, according to the New Testament?
- 4
What does the commander’s “No” (v. 14) say to the way we pray about our own battles?
- 5
The readings of the commander differ. Which details in verses 13-15 seem weightiest to you, and why?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.