4:11
“And should not I pity Nineveh, that great city, in which there are more than 120,000 persons who do not know their right hand from their left, and also much cattle?”
The chapter at a glance
- 1–4Jonah’s angry prayerHe fled because God is merciful
- 5–8The plant, the worm, and the windGod appoints a lesson
- 9–11God’s questionShould not I pity Nineveh?
The chapter in brief
Nineveh’s rescue displeases Jonah exceedingly, and he is angry. He prays, and now the reason for his flight comes out: “I knew that you are a gracious God and merciful, slow to anger and abounding in steadfast love, and relenting from disaster” (v. 2). He asks the LORD to take his life, for it is better for him to die than to live. The LORD asks, “Do you do well to be angry?” (v. 4). Jonah goes out east of the city, makes a booth, and sits in its shade to see what will happen. The LORD God appoints a plant to grow up over him and shade his head, and Jonah is exceedingly glad. At dawn God appoints a worm that attacks the plant so that it withers, and when the sun rises God appoints a scorching east wind. The sun beats on Jonah’s head until he is faint, and again he asks to die. God asks whether he does well to be angry for the plant, and Jonah answers, “Yes, I do well to be angry, angry enough to die” (v. 9). The LORD replies that Jonah pities a plant he did not labor for or make grow, which came in a night and perished in a night; “And should not I pity Nineveh, that great city,” with its more than 120,000 persons and its many animals? The book ends there, on God’s question.
This is the chapter the whole book was building toward. Jonah’s problem was never that God might be harsh; it was that God would be kind, to the wrong people. He quotes the LORD’s own name, proclaimed at Sinai (Exodus 34:6), as a complaint. God answers His angry servant not with a thunderbolt but with a plant, a worm, a wind, and a question, the same patience He showed Nineveh. The book leaves the question open so that every reader must answer it. Its answer is given at the cross, where God’s pity for a world that did not know its right hand from its left went as far as it could go: “God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son” (John 3:16). The Father’s compassion and the Son’s willing self-giving are one mercy, the very mercy Jonah resented and needed.
Points for discussion
vv. 1–3
“I knew that you are a gracious God”
The Hebrew of verse 1 says, roughly, that it was evil to Jonah, a great evil: the word used of Nineveh’s evil (1:2; 3:8) and of the disaster God relented from (3:10). God turned from Nineveh’s disaster, and Jonah took it as a disaster to himself. His prayer quotes the confession God gave of His own name (Exodus 34:6-7), one of the most repeated descriptions of God in the Old Testament (compare Joel 2:13; Psalm 103:8). Jonah knew his theology perfectly and hated where it led. He wanted mercy for Israel and for himself, as chapter 2 shows, but not for Assyria, and many readers think he feared what Assyria would one day do to Israel. Knowing true things about God is not the same as loving what He loves.
vv. 3–4, 8–9
Angry enough to die
Twice Jonah asks to die (vv. 3, 8), and the second time he says he does well to be angry, “angry enough to die” (v. 9). Elijah too once asked God to take his life (1 Kings 19:4). In both stories God does not crush His servant for saying it. With Elijah He sends food and rest; with Jonah He asks gentle questions and gives shade. Scripture records these prayers honestly, and they show that a believer can come to that dark place. This passage is not a verdict on anyone who has felt that way, and it is not grounds for despair. If you are where Jonah was, so worn down by anger or grief that death seems better than life, or if you are thinking of ending your life, you are not beyond God’s reach and you are not alone. Tell someone you trust today, or call or text 988 (in the US). The God who asked Jonah, “Do you do well to be angry?” was not finished with him, and He is not finished with you.
For discussion
God answers Jonah’s anger with questions rather than rebukes. What does that show about how God deals with His children, and how might we speak to an angry or despairing friend? Consider 1 Kings 19:4-8 and Psalm 103:13-14.
vv. 5–9
The plant and the worm
Jonah sits east of the city hoping, it seems, that God will still destroy it. The narrator changes God’s name as the lesson unfolds: “the LORD God” appoints the plant (v. 6), and “God” appoints the worm and the wind (vv. 7-8), the same verb used of the great fish (1:17). Every creature in the book serves God’s purpose: storm, lot, fish, plant, worm, and wind. Jonah is “exceedingly glad” about the plant (v. 6), the only time in the book he is glad, and the gladness is for his own comfort. He grieves the plant more than he ever grieved for Nineveh. God uses the smallest things to show a man the size of his own heart.
vv. 10–11
Should not I pity?
God’s argument moves from lesser to greater. Jonah pitied a plant he did not labor for and did not make grow; God made Nineveh and every person and beast in it. The 120,000 “who do not know their right hand from their left” have been read two ways: as young children, which would make the city’s whole population larger, or as the whole people, morally and spiritually untaught. Either way, God’s pity goes to the helpless. And “also much cattle”: the God who keeps count of sparrows (Matthew 10:29) cares for the animals too: “man and beast you save, O LORD” (Psalm 36:6). The book ends without Jonah’s answer. If Jonah himself told this story, as the traditional view holds, he told it against himself, which may suggest he came at last to answer God’s question rightly. The question is left for us.
For discussion
Who is your Nineveh, the person or people whose rescue you would find hardest to rejoice in? How does Luke 15:25-32, the older brother, press the same question?
Threads across the chapter
Anger. Jonah’s anger at mercy (v. 1), God’s question about it (v. 4), and the same question about the plant (v. 9).
Pity. Jonah’s pity for the plant (v. 10) set against God’s pity for the city and its animals (v. 11).
Appointed. The plant, the worm, and the east wind (vv. 6-8) continue the appointed fish of 1:17.
Life and death. Jonah’s two requests to die (vv. 3, 8-9), and God’s care for the life of 120,000 persons and their cattle (v. 11).
Key words
- 4:1, 4, 9
- חָרָה charah“be angry”; literally “burn”; Jonah’s burning anger set against God’s slowness to anger (v. 2)
- 4:2
- חֶסֶד chesed“steadfast love”; the covenant love Jonah knew and resented God showing to Nineveh
- 4:10–11
- חוּס chus“pity, have compassion”; Jonah’s for a plant, God’s for a city
- 4:6
- קִיקָיוֹן qiqayon“plant”; an uncertain species of fast-growing plant, often thought to be the castor-oil plant or a gourd
Cross-references
- Exodus 34:6-7The LORD’s name: merciful and gracious, slow to anger
- Joel 2:13The same confession, with relenting from disaster
- 1 Kings 19:4-8Elijah asks to die and God feeds him
- Psalm 36:6Man and beast you save, O LORD
- Psalm 103:8-14The LORD’s compassion on His children
- Luke 15:25-32The older brother angry at the father’s mercy
- John 3:16God so loved the world
- Acts 10:34-35God shows no partiality among the nations
- 1
Why do you think the book ends with a question instead of Jonah’s answer?
- 2
Jonah quotes God’s own description of Himself as a complaint. How can a person know true things about God and still resent them?
- 3
Where are we tempted, like Jonah, to want God’s mercy for ourselves and our own, but not for our enemies?
- 4
What does the argument from the plant to the city teach about the size and direction of God’s compassion?
- 5
How does the cross answer the question “Should not I pity Nineveh?” for the nations, and for you?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.