James · Epistles

James 2

Show no partiality, fulfill the law of love, and know that faith without works is dead.

2:17

“So also faith by itself, if it does not have works, is dead.”

James 2:17, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–4Partiality at the doorFavoring the rich contradicts faith in the Lord of glory
  2. 5–7God chose the poorThe poor are heirs; the rich are the oppressors
  3. 8–13The royal lawPartiality breaks the law; mercy triumphs over judgment
  4. 14–17Can that faith save?Faith with no works is dead
  5. 18–20Faith shown, and the demons’ faithBare belief is useless; even demons believe
  6. 21–24Abraham justified by worksFaith completed by works fulfills Genesis 15:6
  7. 25–26Rahab, and the body without breathLiving faith acts; faith without works is a corpse

The chapter in brief

James forbids partiality “as you hold the faith in our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory.” When a man with a gold ring and fine clothes is given a good seat in the assembly and a poor man is told to stand or sit on the floor, the church has become “judges with evil thoughts.” God has chosen the poor of the world to be rich in faith and heirs of the kingdom, while the rich oppress believers and drag them into court. To love one’s neighbor as oneself is to fulfill “the royal law,” but partiality is sin, and whoever fails in one point of the law is guilty of all of it. So speak and act as those who will be judged by the law of liberty, because “mercy triumphs over judgment.” Then James asks what good it is if someone says he has faith but has no works: “Can that faith save him?” Words of blessing to a hungry, ill-clothed brother or sister, with nothing given, are worthless, and so is faith that has no works. Even the demons believe that God is one. Abraham was “justified by works” when he offered Isaac, his faith “completed by his works,” fulfilling the Scripture that he believed God and it was counted to him as righteousness. Rahab too was justified by works when she received the messengers. As the body without the spirit is dead, “so also faith apart from works is dead.”

The chapter has two halves that belong together: the partiality of verses 1-13 is a test case for the dead faith of verses 14-26. Both turn on a faith that speaks well and does nothing, whether to the poor man at the door or to the hungry brother. The faith James defends has an object, “our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory” (v. 1), and it trusts the God who chose the poor and gives the kingdom to those who love Him. Abraham’s offering of his only son points beyond itself to the Father who “did not spare his own Son but gave him up for us all” (Romans 8:32), and Rahab, the Gentile prostitute whose faith showed itself in action, is named among the ancestors of Jesus (Matthew 1:5). James does not teach a second way of salvation beside Paul’s. He shows what the one saving faith in Christ looks like when it is alive.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–4

The Lord of glory at the door

The word for “assembly” in verse 2 is synagōgē, a reminder of how Jewish these early congregations were. The scene is ordinary: a gold ring and fine clothes get a good seat, shabby clothes get the floor. But James measures it against the faith “in our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory.” That title is the same one Paul gives the crucified Christ (1 Corinthians 2:8), and many readers hear in it the glory of God’s own presence. When the Lord of glory Himself is the church’s treasure, a gold ring is nothing to bow to. He “became poor” for our sake (2 Corinthians 8:9), and God Himself “shows no partiality” (Deuteronomy 10:17; Acts 10:34). The Greek word for partiality means “receiving the face,” judging by appearance, which is why James calls it becoming “judges with evil thoughts.”

vv. 5–7

God chose the poor

“Has not God chosen those who are poor in the world to be rich in faith and heirs of the kingdom?” The echo of Jesus’ “Blessed are you who are poor” (Luke 6:20; compare Matthew 5:3) is clear. James does not say poverty saves, or that every poor person is a believer. He says God’s choosing runs against the world’s ranking (1 Corinthians 1:26-29), and notice what the poor are chosen to be: “rich in faith.” Faith itself is the fruit of God’s free choice, not a credential anyone brings. Meanwhile the rich whom the church is flattering are the very ones dragging believers into court and blaspheming “the honorable name by which you were called,” the name of Christ.

vv. 8–13

The royal law and the whole law

“You shall love your neighbor as yourself” (Leviticus 19:18) is “the royal law,” the law of the King whose kingdom the poor inherit (v. 5), the law Jesus named second only to loving God (Matthew 22:39). Partiality is not a minor social lapse; it makes us “transgressors.” Verse 10 explains why: the law is one because the Lawgiver is one, so whoever “fails in one point has become guilty of all of it.” That verse shuts every mouth. No one keeps the whole law, and so no one stands before God on his own record (Galatians 3:10). Then verse 13: “Mercy triumphs over judgment.” Those who have received mercy show it, and a heart that shows none reveals it has never known it (Matthew 18:21-35). Our mercy does not purchase God’s; it is the evidence that His has reached us. Mercy triumphed over judgment first at the cross, where Christ bore the judgment that mercy might be ours.

vv. 14–17

“Can that faith save him?”

Everything hangs on the wording. James does not ask whether faith saves; he asks whether “that faith” can, the faith of someone who “says he has faith” and does nothing. The Greek has the article: that kind of faith, the claimed faith just described. His illustration mirrors the problem. A brother or sister is cold and hungry, and someone offers a blessing, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled,” and nothing else. Words without help are useless to the hungry, and a faith that is only words is useless too: “dead,” not weak or immature, but without life (compare 1 John 3:17-18).

vv. 18–20

The objector and the demons

Verse 18 is hard to punctuate, since Greek has no quotation marks, and readers differ on where the objector’s words end. The ESV ends them after “I have works,” and the drift is clear either way: faith and works cannot be parceled out as two separate gifts, and faith is shown by what it does. Then James reaches for the most orthodox creed in Israel, “God is one,” the confession of the Shema (Deuteronomy 6:4). “You do well.” “Even the demons believe,” and they shudder. The demons’ theology is correct (in the Gospels they know exactly who Jesus is, Mark 1:24), and it saves no one. Reformed teaching has long distinguished knowing the truth, agreeing that it is true, and resting one’s whole trust on Christ; the Heidelberg Catechism (Q&A 21) defines true faith as both a sure knowledge and a wholehearted trust. The demons have the first two and hate the third. There is a pun in verse 20: faith without works (erga) is “useless” (argē), literally “workless.”

vv. 21–24

Abraham justified by works

This is the heart of the chapter, and the place where Christians have most often argued. James and Paul both quote Genesis 15:6, “Abraham believed God, and it was counted to him as righteousness,” and Paul uses it to prove that Abraham was justified by faith apart from works (Romans 4:1-5). James says Abraham was “justified by works when he offered up his son Isaac.” Genesis 15 and Genesis 22 are many years apart. Abraham was counted righteous when he believed the promise, long before Moriah. So James does not say the offering of Isaac earned what Abraham already had. He says that on Moriah his faith “was active along with his works,” was “completed” (brought to its full expression), and that in this act the Scripture of Genesis 15:6 “was fulfilled”: what God declared in Genesis 15 was shown to be true in Genesis 22. God’s own words there name it: “now I know that you fear God” (Genesis 22:12). The word “justify” can mean to declare righteous, or to show and vindicate as righteous (“by your words you will be justified,” Matthew 12:37). James speaks of a faith shown to be real; Paul of how a sinner is accepted by God.

vv. 21–24

How James and Paul fit together

Readers have taken verse 24, “a person is justified by works and not by faith alone,” in several ways. Roman Catholic teaching, at the Council of Trent (Session 6) and since, has appealed to it to teach that justification, first given freely, is increased in the justified through good works done in grace. Some critical scholars think James and Paul simply contradict each other. Luther, in the preface to his 1522 German New Testament, set James beside the books he judged to show Christ most clearly (John’s Gospel and first letter, Romans, Galatians, 1 Peter, and others) and called it, by comparison with them, “a right strawy epistle,” though in his preface to James itself he called it a good book that urges God’s law. Some Protestant readers take James’s “justified” as the verdict of the last day, when works will be the evidence of faith (Romans 2:6-7; Matthew 25:31-46). This commentary holds the Reformation reading, because we believe it most faithfully reflects the Word: James speaks of a living faith shown by its works, justification shown before men and borne out in the believer’s life, while Paul speaks of justification before God, which is by faith alone, apart from works of the law (Romans 3:28; Galatians 2:16). They face different errors. Paul answers people who would add works to Christ as the ground of acceptance; James answers people who would subtract works from faith as though bare assent were enough. The faith James condemns is the faith of verses 14 and 19, a claim and a creed. The phrase “faith alone” appears in the ESV only here, and what James denies is a faith that is alone. As the Reformation saying put it, faith alone justifies, but the faith that justifies is never alone. The Westminster Confession says the same (11.2): faith is “the alone instrument of justification: yet is it not alone in the person justified,” and it is “no dead faith, but worketh by love.” Our works add nothing to Christ’s finished work; they are the life of the faith that rests on Him (Ephesians 2:8-10; Galatians 5:6).

For discussion

Why does Paul use Genesis 15 for his point and James reach for Genesis 22? Read Romans 4:1-5 beside James 2:21-23.

vv. 25–26

Rahab and the breath of faith

James sets beside Abraham, the father of Israel and “a friend of God” (2 Chronicles 20:7; Isaiah 41:8), the least likely partner possible: a Canaanite prostitute. Her faith spoke first in a confession, that the LORD “is God in the heavens above and on the earth beneath” (Joshua 2:11), and showed itself when she hid the messengers at the risk of her life. Hebrews 11:31 says she was spared “by faith”; James says she was “justified by works.” Both are true of one woman. And grace did not stop there: Rahab became an ancestor of David and of Jesus (Matthew 1:5). The closing image is surprising. One might expect faith to be the spirit and works the body; James makes works the breath. A faith without works is not resting; it is a corpse.

Threads across the chapter

  • Words without deeds. “You sit here in a good place” (v. 3) and “Go in peace, be warmed and filled” (v. 16) are the same failure: speech that costs nothing and helps no one.

  • The poor at the center. The poor man at the door (vv. 2-6), the poor chosen as heirs (v. 5), and the ill-clothed brother or sister (vv. 15-16) are the test of faith in both halves of the chapter.

  • Law and mercy. The royal law (v. 8), the whole law broken at one point (v. 10), and mercy triumphing over judgment (v. 13) drive the reader to the mercy found in Christ.

  • Living and dead faith. Faith that is dead (vv. 17, 26), useless (v. 20), and demonic (v. 19) is set against Abraham’s faith completed (v. 22) and Rahab’s faith acting (v. 25).

Key words

2:1
προσωπολημψία prosōpolēmpsia“Partiality,” literally “receiving the face”; judging by appearance
2:2
συναγωγή synagōgē“Assembly”; the gathering of believers, called by the word for a synagogue
2:20
ἀργός argos“Useless,” idle, literally “workless”; a play on erga, works
2:21, 24
δικαιόω dikaioō“Justified”; read here, as this commentary holds, of showing and vindicating as righteous, where Paul uses it of God declaring the ungodly righteous

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does James put a scene about seating in the assembly right before his teaching on faith and works?

  2. 2

    In your own words, what is the difference between the faith James calls dead and the faith Paul says justifies?

  3. 3

    Where might our church, or our family, treat people differently because of how they look, dress, or what they can give?

  4. 4

    James says even the demons believe. How can a person know the right things about God and still not trust Him?

  5. 5

    How would you answer a friend who says James teaches salvation by our works?

My notes