21:16
“Whoever steals a man and sells him, and anyone found in possession of him, shall be put to death.”
The chapter at a glance
- 1These are the rulesCase law applies the Ten Words to life
- 2–6The Hebrew slaveSix years, then freedom; the pierced ear
- 7–11A daughter sold as a slaveHer food, clothing, and rights protected
- 12–14Murder and manslaughterIntent matters; a place of refuge
- 15–17Parents and man-stealingCapital crimes against family and freedom
- 18–27Injuries and “eye for eye”Justice fits the harm and protects the weak
- 28–36The goring ox and the pitOwners answer for harm they could prevent
The chapter in brief
“Now these are the rules that you shall set before them.” With these words the Book of the Covenant begins (the name comes from 24:7), the case laws that apply the Ten Words of chapter 20 to the life of a people. The first case is the Hebrew slave, who serves six years and goes out free in the seventh; if he chooses to stay out of love for his master and his family, his ear is bored through with an awl at the door and he serves for life. A daughter sold as a slave, to be the wife of her master or his son, is protected: she may be redeemed but never sold to foreigners, and her food, clothing, and marital rights may not be cut. Then come capital crimes: deliberate murder (with a place of refuge appointed for the one who kills without intent), striking or cursing father or mother, and stealing a man to sell him. Injuries follow: a man hurt in a quarrel must be paid for lost time and healed; a master who kills his slave is to be punished, and a slave whose eye or tooth is destroyed goes free; a pregnant woman struck in a fight is protected by the rule “eye for eye, tooth for tooth.” The chapter ends with the goring ox and the uncovered pit, where an owner answers for harm he could have prevented.
These laws are not a ladder to God. They are given to a people already redeemed, whose law opened with “I am the LORD your God, who brought you out of the land of Egypt, out of the house of slavery” (20:2), and it is no accident that the first case concerns a slave going free. They show what the God who rescued Israel cares about: life, intent, the protection of the weak, and justice that fits the wrong and goes no further. Some laws here are hard to read today, and the study says so; Jesus Himself taught that Moses permitted some things “because of your hardness of heart” (Matthew 19:8). The chapter points to Christ in two ways. He fulfills the law (Matthew 5:17), and He reads its “eye for eye” rightly for His disciples (Matthew 5:38-39). And He is the true refuge for those who have no defense of their own (Hebrews 6:18), the Servant who came “to give his life as a ransom for many” (Mark 10:45).
Points for discussion
v. 1
These are the rules
God spoke the Ten Words to all the people from the mountain (20:1, 22); the “rules” (mishpatim, the judgments a court would apply) He gives through Moses. Most are case law: “When a man... if he...” They do not cover every situation; they teach a judge how to reason from the commandments to a case. How should Christians read them now? This commentary holds the Westminster Confession’s reading (19.3-5): the moral law in the Ten Commandments binds everyone, the ceremonial law is fulfilled in Christ, and Israel’s civil laws “expired together with the State of that people,” binding no other nation beyond their “general equity.” So we ask of each case what it shows about God’s justice, not whether a modern state should copy its penalty. Read that way these chapters are a gift: they show the Ten Words worked out in barns, fields, and courtrooms.
vv. 2–6
The Hebrew slave
The ESV footnote notes that the Hebrew ’ebed covers a range of roles, from servant to slave. The Hebrew in view is usually a man who sold himself, or was sold, to pay a debt or make restitution for theft (22:3). His service has a limit: six years, then freedom “for nothing,” and Deuteronomy adds that he must not be sent away empty-handed (Deuteronomy 15:13-14). The hard case of verse 4, where a wife given by the master stays with the master, leaves the man a painful choice, and the law makes his own word decisive: “I love my master, my wife, and my children; I will not go out free.” Then the ear is bored at the door, before God (some read “to God” as to the sanctuary, others as before the judges), so the choice is public and solemn. Many readers have linked this pierced ear to Psalm 40:6, “you have given me an open ear,” and to Christ, who emptied Himself “by taking the form of a servant” (Philippians 2:7). The New Testament does not draw that line from Exodus 21, so it is best held as a picture rather than a proof.
vv. 2–11, 20–21, 26–27
What this law is, and is not
Honesty requires saying that Israel’s law regulated slavery rather than abolishing it, and that it allowed foreigners to be held for life (Leviticus 25:44-46). It also bound slavery in ways the ancient world did not. Stealing a man to sell him was a capital crime (v. 16). A master who killed his slave was to be punished (v. 20), and a slave maimed by his master went free (vv. 26-27). A runaway slave was not to be handed back (Deuteronomy 23:15-16). Jesus gives the key to laws like these: Moses permitted divorce “because of your hardness of heart... but from the beginning it was not so” (Matthew 19:8). These laws were used to defend American slavery, which they never warranted. That slavery was built on kidnapping, the very crime verse 16 punishes with death, and Paul names “enslavers” among the lawless (1 Timothy 1:10). The gospel’s direction is plain: in Christ “there is neither slave nor free” (Galatians 3:28), and Paul sends Onesimus back “no longer as a bondservant but more than a bondservant, as a beloved brother” (Philemon 16).
For discussion
How does Matthew 19:8 help us read laws that regulate a broken practice without approving it? Where else does God’s law restrain sin it does not yet remove?
vv. 7–11
A daughter sold
A father in poverty might sell his daughter into a household where she would become the wife of the master or his son. Every clause limits the man’s power over her. If she does not please him he must let her be redeemed, and he may not sell her to foreigners, “since he has broken faith with her.” If she is for his son, she is treated “as with a daughter.” If he takes another wife, he may not reduce her food, clothing, or marital rights, and if he fails in these she goes free without payment. Scripture records polygamy without approving it (Genesis 2:24; Matthew 19:4-6); here the law protects the woman most likely to be cast aside.
vv. 12–14
Murder and refuge
The law distinguishes the man who “willfully attacks another to kill him by cunning” (v. 14) from the one who “did not lie in wait for him, but God let him fall into his hand” (v. 13), an accident under God’s providence that carries no guilt of murder. For him God will appoint a place to flee, later the cities of refuge (Numbers 35:11-12). The altar is no shelter for a willful murderer (v. 14; compare 1 Kings 2:28-34). Behind the death penalty stands Genesis 9:6, and Christians differ over how that verse bears on nations today; the general equity here is clear on any view: human life is sacred, intent matters, and guilt must be judged, not assumed. Hebrews borrows the language of refuge for the gospel: “we who have fled for refuge” hold fast to the hope set before us (Hebrews 6:18).
vv. 15–17
Father, mother, and man-stealing
Striking or cursing a parent stands beside murder. Jesus quotes verse 17 against teachers who used a religious vow to escape caring for their parents: “Whoever reviles father or mother must surely die” (Mark 7:10; Matthew 15:4). The family is the first school of the fifth commandment, and the law guards it. This law protects parents; it gives no warrant for harshness toward children (“Fathers, do not provoke your children to anger,” Ephesians 6:4), and it never commands a child to stay in danger. Between the two parent laws stands man-stealing, and the clause “and anyone found in possession of him” reaches past the kidnapper to everyone who profits by the trade.
vv. 18–27
Injuries and “eye for eye”
“Eye for eye, tooth for tooth” is a rule for judges, not permission for private revenge. Verse 22 has the payment set “as the judges determine,” and Deuteronomy gives the same formula to judges examining a false witness (Deuteronomy 19:18-21). It limits punishment to the harm done and applies one standard to all, “the same rule for the sojourner and for the native” (Leviticus 24:22). The cases around it show that payment often stood in place of the literal penalty (vv. 19, 30). When Jesus says, “You have heard that it was said, ’An eye for an eye’... But I say to you, Do not resist the one who is evil” (Matthew 5:38-39), He does not abolish justice in the courts (Romans 13:4); He forbids His disciples to make the judge’s rule their own license to repay. Vengeance belongs to God (Romans 12:19).
The slave laws here are among the hardest verses in the chapter. A master who kills his slave is to be “avenged,” treated as a homicide (v. 20); but if the slave survives a day or two, “he is not to be avenged, for the slave is his money” (v. 21). Many read the delay as evidence that the master did not intend to kill, and the loss of the slave’s service as his penalty; even so, the verse shows the law working within a fallen institution. Verses 26-27 then do something many ancient codes did not: the injured slave receives his own freedom, rather than the owner receiving payment for damaged property.
vv. 22–25
The pregnant woman
Begin with what is not in doubt. The child in the womb is a human life, formed and known by God: He knits us together “in my mother’s womb” (Psalm 139:13), John “leaped” in Elizabeth’s womb at the coming of the Lord (Luke 1:41-44), and the Son Himself took our nature from His conception (Luke 1:31, 35). This commentary holds the sanctity of unborn life firmly, on that whole witness and not on this verse alone. The verse itself is read two main ways by faithful scholars. In the first, the blow causes a premature birth: “her children come out,” using the ordinary word for children and the verb used of live birth (Genesis 25:25-26), and “harm” then covers mother or child alike. In the second, the blow causes a miscarriage, which is fined, and “harm” refers to the mother. (The ESV footnote offers a third, about who was to blame.) Some note in favor of the first that two chapters later the law uses a verb that can mean miscarry (“None shall miscarry,” 23:26), but not here. This commentary reads the first as somewhat more natural and holds that lean loosely. On either reading the loss is punished, and neither gives any warrant for treating unborn life lightly. A reader who has lost a pregnancy, or who grieves a choice made in the past, should hear that this passage is no verdict on them; “if we confess our sins, he is faithful and just to forgive us” (1 John 1:9), and the little ones who die are left to a God who is both just and good.
vv. 28–36
The goring ox
An ox that kills without warning is destroyed, but its owner is not guilty; an owner who was warned and did nothing is. Responsibility grows with knowledge. A “ransom” (kofer, v. 30, the word used again for the atonement money in 30:12) may be accepted in place of his life, and the same rule protects a son or daughter (v. 31). For a slave the payment is “thirty shekels of silver” (v. 32). Many readers hear that price again when Judas is paid “thirty pieces of silver” for Jesus (Matthew 26:15; compare Zechariah 11:12-13 and Matthew 27:9). The New Testament cites Zechariah, not this verse, but the sum was a slave’s price: the Lord of glory was valued at what Israel’s law set for a servant gored by an ox, and He gave Himself a ransom for many.
Threads across the chapter
Freedom. The slave goes out free (v. 2), the daughter goes out for nothing (v. 11), and the maimed slave goes free (vv. 26-27), while the man-stealer dies (v. 16).
Intent and knowledge. The killer who lay in wait (vv. 12-14), the quarrel (vv. 18-19), and the owner who was warned (vv. 29, 36) are judged by what they meant and what they knew.
Protecting the weak. The slave (vv. 2-6, 20, 26-27), the daughter sold (vv. 7-11), the parents (vv. 15, 17), and the pregnant woman (vv. 22-25) are each guarded against the stronger.
Ransom and price. The daughter may be redeemed (v. 8), the owner’s life ransomed (v. 30), and a slave priced at thirty shekels (v. 32).
Key words
- 21:1
- מִשְׁפָּטִים mishpatim“Rules”; the judgments of a court, case law applying the Ten Words
- 21:2
- עֶבֶד 'ebed“Slave” or “servant”; a word covering a range of roles, here usually debt service with a time limit
- 21:16
- גֹּנֵב אִישׁ gonev 'ish“Steals a man”; kidnapping for sale, a capital crime, the root of the trade Paul calls “enslavers” (1 Timothy 1:10)
- 21:30
- כֹּפֶר kofer“Ransom”; a payment given in place of a life, the same word used for the atonement money in 30:12
Cross-references
- Exodus 20:2The law begins with redemption from the house of slavery
- Deuteronomy 15:12-18The Hebrew slave sent out free and not empty-handed
- Deuteronomy 23:15-16The runaway slave not handed back
- Matthew 19:8Laws given because of hardness of heart
- 1 Timothy 1:9-10“Enslavers” among the lawless
- Matthew 5:38-39Jesus on “an eye for an eye”
- Psalm 139:13-16God knits us together in the womb
- Mark 7:10Jesus quotes the law on reviling father or mother
- 1
The covenant law opens with the case of a slave going free. Why might that be the right first case for a people just brought “out of the house of slavery” (Exodus 20:2)?
- 2
How does “eye for eye” restrain revenge, and how do Jesus’ words in Matthew 5:38-39 and Paul’s in Romans 12:17-21 and 13:4 fit together?
- 3
What do the slave laws show us about how God’s law can restrain a sin in a fallen world without approving it, and how should that guard us from misusing Scripture today?
- 4
Where in your own life does responsibility grow with knowledge, as it does with the owner who was warned about his ox?
- 5
How do the two readings of verses 22-25 differ, and what other Scriptures should shape how Christians think about the unborn and about those who grieve their loss?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.