Exodus · Pentateuch (Law)

Exodus 17

Water flows from the struck rock, and Israel defeats Amalek as Moses’ hands are held up.

Rameses, at sea levelThe traditional route to Jebel Musa (Exodus 12:37; 19:1-2); the crossing and the mountain are debated, about 210 milesMount Sinai, about 5,150 ft

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–4Quarreling at RephidimThirst becomes accusation
  2. 5–7Water from the rockGod stands on the rock and gives life
  3. 8–13The battle with AmalekVictory comes while the mediator’s hands are held up
  4. 14–16The memorial and the altarThe LORD is His people’s banner

The chapter in brief

At Rephidim there is no water, and the people quarrel with Moses: “Give us water to drink.” Moses asks, “Why do you quarrel with me? Why do you test the LORD?” The people grumble that he brought them out to kill them, their children, and their livestock with thirst, and Moses cries to the LORD, “They are almost ready to stone me.” The LORD tells him to take the elders and the staff with which he struck the Nile: “Behold, I will stand before you there on the rock at Horeb, and you shall strike the rock, and water shall come out of it.” Moses does so, and names the place Massah and Meribah, testing and quarreling, because they said, “Is the LORD among us or not?” Then Amalek attacks. Joshua leads the fight while Moses stands on the hill with the staff of God; whenever Moses holds up his hand Israel prevails, and when he lowers it Amalek prevails. When his hands grow weary, Aaron and Hur sit him on a stone and hold up his hands until sunset, and Joshua overwhelms Amalek. The LORD tells Moses to write it in a book, for He will blot out the memory of Amalek. Moses builds an altar and names it “The LORD Is My Banner.”

The chapter sets two scenes side by side: Israel tests God, and God provides water from a rock; Israel is attacked, and God gives victory through a mediator’s lifted hands. Paul says plainly where the first scene points: “they drank from the spiritual Rock that followed them, and the Rock was Christ” (1 Corinthians 10:4). The Son was present with Israel in the wilderness, giving life to a people who had just accused Him, and in the fullness of time He would invite all who thirst to come to Him and drink (John 7:37-39).

Points for discussion

vv. 1–7

“Is the LORD among us or not?”

The question sounds like honest doubt, but Moses calls it testing the LORD. After the plagues, the sea, the pillar that never left, and manna every morning, the people demand that God prove Himself again on their terms. Massah and Meribah became bywords. “Do not harden your hearts, as at Meribah” (Psalm 95:8), and Hebrews 3:7-11 presses the warning on the church. When the devil asked Jesus to throw Himself from the temple, Jesus answered from Deuteronomy 6:16, which names this very place: “You shall not put the LORD your God to the test, as you tested him at Massah.” Where Israel tested God in the wilderness, the true Son refused to.

For discussion

What is the difference between bringing honest doubts to God, as in the Psalms, and testing Him as Israel did here? Compare Psalm 13 with Psalm 95:8-9.

vv. 5–6

The staff and the rock

God tells Moses to take “the staff with which you struck the Nile,” the staff of judgment. Then He says, “I will stand before you there on the rock... and you shall strike the rock.” Many readers see in this a striking picture: the blow of judgment that the people deserved falls on the rock where the LORD Himself stands, and water flows out for the guilty. The New Testament does not spell out that detail, but Paul does say “the Rock was Christ” (1 Corinthians 10:4), and the gospel is exactly this: judgment falling on the One who stands in our place, so that life flows to those who deserved the blow. Many readers also connect the water to the blood and water from Jesus’ pierced side (John 19:34). Later, at a second Meribah, Moses was told to speak to the rock but struck it twice in anger, and was barred from Canaan (Numbers 20:8-12). Some readers see in that contrast a picture of Christ struck once for all (Hebrews 9:28), though the text itself gives Moses’ unbelief and failure to honor God as the reason.

vv. 8–13

Lifted hands

Amalek attacks at Rephidim, and Deuteronomy 25:17-18 adds the detail Exodus leaves out: they struck the stragglers at the rear, “faint and weary,” and “did not fear God.” The battle is won by Joshua’s sword and by Moses’ lifted hand together. Readers take the lifted hand in two ways. Many see it as a posture of prayer and intercession; others note that the text speaks of the staff of God in his hand (v. 9) and read the raised staff as a banner of God’s power over the battle. Either way the victory does not come from Moses’ arm strength, and his arms do fail. Aaron and Hur give him a stone to sit on and hold up his hands until sunset. Even Israel’s mediator needed help to keep his hands raised. Christ’s intercession does not tire: He “always lives to make intercession” for His people (Hebrews 7:25). This is also the first time we meet Joshua, whose Hebrew name means “the LORD saves,” and whose name in Greek is the same as Jesus’ (compare Hebrews 4:8).

vv. 14–16

The banner and the war with Amalek

God tells Moses to write this “in a book,” one of the first notes in Scripture of Moses writing at God’s command, and the oath that God will blot out Amalek is carried out much later (1 Samuel 15). That was God’s judgment on a particular people for their cruelty to the weak, given once to Israel; it gives no one a warrant for violence in God’s name today. Moses names the altar “The LORD Is My Banner.” A banner (nes) was the standard troops rallied around. Isaiah says the root of Jesse “shall stand as a signal (nes) for the peoples” (Isaiah 11:10), and Paul applies that promise to Christ (Romans 15:12). The church’s banner is not a flag of any nation but the risen Lord.

Threads across the chapter

  • Standing. The LORD will stand on the rock (v. 6), Moses will stand on the hill (v. 9), and Aaron and Hur keep his hands steady (v. 12).

  • The staff. The staff that struck the Nile (v. 5) strikes the rock (v. 6) and is lifted over the battle (v. 9).

  • Testing and trusting. Israel tests the LORD (vv. 2, 7) and then must trust Him in battle (vv. 8-13).

  • Remembering. Massah and Meribah are named for Israel’s sin (v. 7), the book records Amalek’s (v. 14), and the altar is named for the LORD’s faithfulness (v. 15).

Key words

17:6
צוּר tsur“Rock”; the rock at Horeb, which Paul says was Christ
17:7
מַסָּה וּמְרִיבָה Massah and Meribah“Testing” and “quarreling”; places named for Israel’s unbelief
17:15
נֵס nes“Banner”; the rallying standard, “The LORD Is My Banner”

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why do you think this chapter places God’s patience with grumbling Israel (vv. 1-7) right before Israel’s first battle (vv. 8-16)?

  2. 2

    What does Paul mean by “the Rock was Christ,” and how does the picture of the LORD standing on the rock that is struck help us understand the cross?

  3. 3

    When are we tempted to ask, “Is the LORD among us or not?” after He has already shown His faithfulness?

  4. 4

    Who are the Aarons and Hurs in your life, and whose weary hands might you help hold up?

  5. 5

    How does Moses’ tiring intercession make you thankful for Christ’s intercession that never tires?

My notes