The chapter at a glance
- 1–4The search for virginsThe king’s men propose an empire-wide gathering
- 5–7Mordecai and HadassahAn exile raises an orphan as his daughter
- 8–11Taken into the haremEsther wins favor and keeps her people hidden
- 12–14Twelve months and one nightThe system that consumed young women
- 15–18Esther made queenFavor, the crown, and Esther’s feast
- 19–23The plot at the gateMordecai saves the king; the deed is recorded
The chapter in brief
After these things, when the king’s anger has abated, he remembers Vashti and what was decreed against her. His young men propose that “beautiful young virgins be sought out for the king” (v. 2) in every province and gathered into the harem at Susa, and that the one who pleases him become queen. The narrator then introduces Mordecai, a Jew of the tribe of Benjamin, “the son of Jair, son of Shimei, son of Kish” (v. 5), whose family had been carried away from Jerusalem with King Jeconiah. He is raising his orphaned cousin Hadassah, that is, Esther, as his own daughter. When the king’s edict is proclaimed, “Esther also was taken into the king’s palace” (v. 8). She wins the favor of Hegai, who is in charge of the women, and at Mordecai’s command she does not reveal her people. After twelve months of beautifying, each young woman goes in to the king for one night and then to the second harem, the house of the concubines, not to return unless summoned by name. When Esther’s turn comes, in the tenth month of the king’s seventh year (about 479 BC), “the king loved Esther more than all the women” (v. 17), sets the royal crown on her head, and makes her queen. Some time later Mordecai, sitting at the king’s gate, learns that two eunuchs, Bigthan and Teresh, are plotting against the king. He tells Esther, she tells the king in Mordecai’s name, the men are hanged, and the deed is “recorded in the book of the chronicles in the presence of the king” (v. 23).
This chapter must be read with care and not as a romance. Esther is taken, with no choice of hers recorded, into an institution built for a king’s pleasure, and the narrator describes its procedure in flat, bureaucratic terms that let its cost show. Yet the God who is never named is placing the right woman in the right place, and the deed recorded and forgotten at the gate is a seed that will lie in the chronicles until the night it is needed (6:1-3). Scripture often shows God working His purposes through the wrongs of the powerful without excusing them: Joseph’s brothers “meant evil,” “but God meant it for good” (Genesis 50:20), and at the cross Herod and Pilate did “whatever your hand and your plan had predestined to take place” (Acts 4:28). The story of a Jewish orphan in a Persian harem is one more link in the chain by which God kept the people from whom, “according to the flesh, is the Christ” (Romans 9:5).
Points for discussion
vv. 1–4
The search for virgins
“After these things” covers several years: Vashti was deposed in the king’s third year (1:3), and Esther comes to him in the seventh (2:16). Many readers place Xerxes’ war against Greece in that gap. The king “remembered Vashti and what she had done and what had been decreed against her” (v. 1), and some readers hear regret in it, but the law of chapter 1 cannot be repealed. His servants’ answer is to gather “all the beautiful young virgins” of the provinces (v. 3). This is not a contest the young women entered. It is the power of an absolute king to take, and the chapter should never be retold as a beauty pageant.
vv. 5–7
Mordecai and Hadassah
Mordecai’s genealogy runs back to Kish, a Benjaminite, the name of Saul’s father (1 Samuel 9:1-2), and in the next chapter his enemy will be Haman “the Agagite,” which recalls Agag, the Amalekite king Saul spared (1 Samuel 15:8-9). Many readers see the old conflict between Saul’s house and Amalek taken up again here; the names may mark the family line or simply its tribe, but the echo seems intended. Verse 6 says of someone that he “had been carried away from Jerusalem” with Jeconiah (597 BC); since that was more than a century before the events of this chapter, many readers take it of Kish, Mordecai’s ancestor, rather than of Mordecai himself. Mordecai takes his orphaned cousin “as his own daughter” (v. 7), a quiet reflection of the God who is a father to the fatherless (Psalm 68:5). Hadassah means “myrtle”; Esther is often explained as a Persian name meaning “star,” and Mordecai’s name is commonly linked to the Babylonian god Marduk, the kind of court names exiles bore (compare Daniel 1:7).
vv. 8–11
Taken into the harem
“Esther also was taken” (v. 8): the verb is passive, and the text records no consent asked or given. Readers differ sharply on how to judge Esther and Mordecai. Some fault them for compromise: Esther hides her identity, eats from the king’s provision where Daniel refused to defile himself with the king’s food (Daniel 1:8), and enters the bed and marriage of a pagan king (compare Deuteronomy 7:3). Others answer that she had no recorded choice, that the text never condemns her, and that its silence keeps our eyes on God’s hidden purpose. This commentary reads Esther with care: Scripture records what was done to her without approving the system that did it, and it does not blame her. Mordecai’s command that she not reveal her people (v. 10) may be prudence in a dangerous court, or a sign of how far the exiles had blended in; Mordecai himself will openly say he is a Jew (3:4). Each day he walks before the court of the harem “to learn how Esther was and what was happening to her” (v. 11), the act of a father who can do nothing else.
vv. 12–14
Twelve months and one night
The narrator describes the procedure without comment: twelve months of oils and spices, one night with the king, and then “the second harem,” the house of the concubines, where a woman would stay unless “the king delighted in her and she was summoned by name” (v. 14). Many young women spent their lives in that house. The flat tone does the work of judgment. Anyone who has been used by someone with power over them is not stained or disqualified by what was done to them: it was not their fault, and God’s purposes for them are not ended. Abuse today is a crime and belongs with the authorities. And there is a God who does what Ahasuerus did not: He calls His own by name and does not forget them (Isaiah 43:1).
For discussion
How should we read a passage that describes an injustice without stopping to condemn it? Compare the way Genesis tells the stories of Hagar (Genesis 16) and Dinah (Genesis 34).
vv. 15–18
Esther made queen
When her turn comes, Esther “asked for nothing except what Hegai the king’s eunuch ... advised” (v. 15), whether from humility, wisdom, or both. Twice the chapter says she won favor (vv. 9, 15), and verse 17 joins two strong words, “grace and favor” (chen and chesed). The favor comes through people, but the reader of Scripture knows who gives favor in a foreign court: the LORD gave Joseph favor in the sight of the prison keeper (Genesis 39:21), and God gave Daniel favor and compassion with his overseer (Daniel 1:9). The king marks the day with “Esther’s feast,” a remission of taxes, and gifts (v. 18). Esther is now in the palace. She does not yet know why.
vv. 19–23
The plot at the gate
Mordecai “was sitting at the king’s gate” (vv. 19, 21), which many readers take as a sign that he held an official post. He uncovers a plot by two eunuchs against the king’s life and passes it through Esther, who tells the king “in the name of Mordecai” (v. 22). The men are executed (on the word “gallows,” see 5:14). The deed is written down “in the presence of the king,” and then nothing happens. Mordecai receives no reward. The reader will learn in chapter 6 that God’s timing is better than a prompt reward, for the right moment is not yet come (Galatians 4:4 shows the same patience on the largest scale).
Threads across the chapter
Taken and hidden. Esther is taken (vv. 8, 16) and keeps her people hidden (vv. 10, 20), while the God who is never named is also, in a sense, hidden in the story.
Favor. Esther wins favor with Hegai (v. 9), with all who see her (v. 15), and with the king (v. 17), and the chapter invites the reader to ask who gives it.
Mordecai’s watchfulness. He raises her (v. 7), walks by the harem daily (v. 11), commands her silence (vv. 10, 20), and sits at the gate where he saves the king (vv. 19-23).
The record. The deed is written in the chronicles (v. 23) and forgotten, setting up the sleepless night of 6:1-3.
Key words
- 2:8, 16
- לָקַח laqach“taken”; the passive “was taken” records what was done to Esther, not a choice she made
- 2:17
- חֵן וָחֶסֶד chen vachesed“grace and favor”; chesed is often God’s covenant love elsewhere; here it is favor Esther wins, which the reader learns to trace to God
- 2:7
- הֲדַסָּה Hadassah“myrtle”; Esther’s Hebrew name beside her Persian one
Cross-references
- 1 Samuel 9:1-2Kish the Benjaminite, Saul’s father
- 1 Samuel 15:8-9Saul spares Agag, king of the Amalekites
- Daniel 1:8-9Daniel refuses the king’s food, and God gives him favor
- Genesis 39:21The LORD gives Joseph favor in a foreign prison
- Psalm 68:5God, a father of the fatherless
- Genesis 50:20Evil meant by men, good meant by God
- Acts 4:27-28The worst injustice serving God’s predestined plan, without excusing it
- 1
Why do you think the narrator introduces Mordecai with a genealogy that reaches back to Kish, and what does it prepare for in the next chapter?
- 2
How does the chapter’s flat description of the harem (vv. 12-14) shape the way we should read Esther’s story?
- 3
Readers have both faulted and defended Esther and Mordecai for hiding her identity. What do you make of it, and what does the text itself say?
- 4
Esther and Mordecai could not see why she was in the palace. Where have you been placed in a situation you did not choose, and how might God be at work in it?
- 5
Mordecai’s good deed was recorded and then forgotten. How does the rest of the book change the way we think about good done without reward?
My notes
Saved to your account, so they are on every device you sign in on, and private unless you specifically share them with another.
A different version of this note was saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Your account’s copy is above and was left alone; copy anything worth keeping out of this one, then let it go.
Notes are kept with your account rather than in this browser, so what you write here is still there on your phone, on another machine, and after you clear your history. Signing in takes an email address and one click, there is no password to remember.
Saved in this browser before notes moved to accounts. Sign in and it will be carried up to your account; it stays here until then.