Deuteronomy · Pentateuch (Law)

Deuteronomy 19

Cities of refuge, the sanctity of boundaries, and the requirement of two or three witnesses.

19:15

“A single witness shall not suffice against a person for any crime or for any wrong in connection with any offense that he has committed. Only on the evidence of two witnesses or of three witnesses shall a charge be established.”

Deuteronomy 19:15, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–10Cities of refugeA safe place for the one who killed by accident
  2. 11–13No refuge for the murdererDeliberate murder is not sheltered
  3. 14The neighbor’s landmarkDo not steal a family’s inheritance
  4. 15–21Witnesses true and falseTwo or three witnesses; the liar receives his intended harm

The chapter in brief

When Israel has taken the land, it is to set apart three cities, with roads measured so that “any manslayer can flee to them” (v. 3). The case is someone who kills “his neighbor unintentionally without having hated him in the past” (v. 4), as when an axe head flies off its handle in the forest. He may flee to a city of refuge and live, so that “the avenger of blood in hot anger” does not overtake him (v. 6). If the land is enlarged, three more cities are to be added, “lest innocent blood be shed in your land” (v. 10). But a murderer who lies in wait and kills, then flees to a refuge city, is to be taken out by his own city’s elders and handed over: “Your eye shall not pity him” (v. 13). Israel must not move a neighbor’s ancient landmark (v. 14). In court, “a single witness shall not suffice”; a charge stands only on two or three witnesses (v. 15). A malicious witness is to be examined by priests and judges, and if he lied, “you shall do to him as he had meant to do to his brother” (v. 19): “life for life, eye for eye, tooth for tooth” (v. 21).

The chapter is about guarding the innocent and convicting the guilty, and it refuses to let either give way to the other. Refuge protects the man who did not mean to kill; it does not protect the murderer. Witnesses protect the accused from one man’s word; the false witness’s own sentence protects the court from lies. Hebrews uses refuge language for the gospel: “we who have fled for refuge” have “strong encouragement to hold fast to the hope set before us” (Hebrews 6:18). Many readers see in the cities of refuge a picture of Christ, the refuge to which guilty sinners flee. The picture has a surprise in it: the refuge cities sheltered only the innocent, but Christ shelters the guilty, because He took the guilt on Himself.

Points for discussion

vv. 1–10

Cities of refuge

The “avenger of blood” (go’el haddam) was the victim’s nearest kinsman, charged in ancient custom with avenging a death. Israel’s law did not abolish him but restrained him: a man who killed by accident could reach safety before “hot anger” (v. 6) did what justice did not require. The roads were to be measured and maintained (v. 3) so that no one was too far from refuge. Moses had already set apart three cities east of the Jordan (4:41-43), and Joshua 20 records the three west of it. Whether the three further cities of verses 8-9 were ever needed depends on whether Israel’s borders were ever enlarged to the full promise, and interpreters differ on that. The careful example of the axe head (v. 5) shows that the law cared about intent: “he had not hated his neighbor in the past” (v. 6). God’s justice looks at the heart, as Jesus would press further (Matthew 5:21-22).

vv. 11–13

No refuge for the murderer

Refuge is not a loophole. The elders of the murderer’s own town must send and fetch him, “and hand him over to the avenger of blood” (v. 12). “Your eye shall not pity him” sounds harsh, but the reason follows: “you shall purge the guilt of innocent blood from Israel” (v. 13). Pity for the murderer that ignores the murdered is not mercy; it is injustice to the victim. Genesis 9:6 grounds the seriousness of murder in the image of God. The civil penalty belonged to Israel’s state, and its general equity remains in the duty of rulers to punish murder justly (Romans 13:4).

v. 14

The neighbor’s landmark

A boundary stone, which “the men of old have set,” marked a family’s share of the land God gave. To move it quietly was to steal land and, with it, a family’s future. Proverbs repeats the warning, adding that God Himself is the defender of the fatherless whose fields are encroached upon (Proverbs 23:10-11). Ahab’s seizure of Naboth’s vineyard (1 Kings 21) shows the powerful doing exactly this. The application today is broader than land: any quiet taking of what belongs to the weak falls under it.

vv. 15–21

Witnesses true and false

“A single witness shall not suffice” (v. 15). This rule protected the accused from one person’s word, and the New Testament carries it into the church: Jesus for church discipline (Matthew 18:16), Paul for charges against an elder (1 Timothy 5:19) and for his own dealings with Corinth (2 Corinthians 13:1). Yet a caution belongs here. This was a rule for a court’s verdict, not a rule that a lone report may be ignored. In chapter 22 the law believes a betrothed woman assaulted in the open country, where “there was no one to rescue her” (22:27), with no second witness. A report of abuse with no second witness must still be heard, taken seriously, and brought to the civil authorities, who have the means to investigate. The two-witness rule must never be used to silence a victim.

The false witness receives what he intended: “you shall do to him as he had meant to do to his brother” (v. 19). That is the meaning of “eye for eye, tooth for tooth” (v. 21): a limit set for judges, so that the penalty fits the crime, no more and no less. It was never a license for private revenge. Jesus, quoting the phrase, forbade His followers to use it that way: “Do not resist the one who is evil. But if anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to him the other also” (Matthew 5:38-39). Courts keep justice; disciples keep mercy.

For discussion

How should a church follow Matthew 18:16 and 1 Timothy 5:19 while making sure that no victim’s report is dismissed for lack of a second witness?

Threads across the chapter

  • Innocent blood. Refuge keeps innocent blood from being shed (v. 10), the murderer’s death purges the guilt of innocent blood (v. 13), and the false witness who sought blood receives his own sentence (v. 19).

  • Intent. The manslayer had not hated his neighbor (vv. 4, 6), the murderer hated and lay in wait (v. 11), and the false witness “meant to do” harm (v. 19).

  • Your eye shall not pity. The phrase governs the murderer (v. 13) and the false witness (v. 21), protecting victims from misplaced sympathy.

  • Guarding the neighbor. The manslayer’s life (vv. 4-6), the neighbor’s landmark (v. 14), and the accused man’s name (v. 15) are each protected.

Key words

19:4
בִּבְלִי־דַעַת bivli-da'at“Unintentionally”; literally “without knowing,” the intent that separates the manslayer from the murderer
19:6
גֹּאֵל הַדָּם go'el haddam“Avenger of blood”; the kinsman-redeemer in his role of avenging a death
19:14
גְּבוּל gevul“Landmark,” boundary; the marker of a family’s God-given inheritance
19:16
עֵד חָמָס ed chamas“Malicious witness”; literally a “witness of violence,” whose lie aims to destroy

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    How do the cities of refuge show that God’s justice weighs intent and not only outcome?

  2. 2

    Why is it unjust to pity a murderer in a way that forgets his victim (v. 13)? Where might misplaced sympathy do harm today?

  3. 3

    How does Christ as our refuge both fit and surpass the picture of the cities of refuge?

  4. 4

    The two-witness rule protects the accused. How can the church honor it while still hearing and protecting those who report abuse?

  5. 5

    Jesus quoted “eye for eye” in Matthew 5:38-39. How does that law serve justice in a court, and why must it never become personal revenge?

My notes