1 Samuel · Historical Books

1 Samuel 8

Israel demands a king “like all the nations”; Samuel warns of a king’s ways, but the LORD grants their request.

8:7

“And the LORD said to Samuel, ’Obey the voice of the people in all that they say to you, for they have not rejected you, but they have rejected me from being king over them.’”

1 Samuel 8:7, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–3Samuel’s sonsCorrupt judges give the elders their reason
  2. 4–5The elders’ demand“A king to judge us like all the nations”
  3. 6–9Samuel prays; the LORD answersThey have rejected God as their king
  4. 10–18The ways of the kingHe will take, take and take
  5. 19–22The people insistGod gives them what they ask

The chapter in brief

When Samuel grows old he makes his sons Joel and Abijah judges in Beersheba, but they do not walk in his ways: they turn aside after gain, take bribes and pervert justice. All the elders of Israel come to Samuel at Ramah: you are old, your sons do not walk in your ways; “appoint for us a king to judge us like all the nations” (v. 5). The request displeases Samuel, and he prays. The LORD tells him to obey the people’s voice, for they have not rejected Samuel but the LORD Himself “from being king over them,” as they have done since the day He brought them out of Egypt; but Samuel must solemnly warn them of “the ways of the king” (v. 9). Samuel tells them: the king will take your sons for his chariots and fields and weapons, your daughters for his kitchens, the best of your fields and vineyards for his servants, a tenth of your grain and flocks, your servants and your donkeys, “and you shall be his slaves” (v. 17). In that day you will cry out because of the king you have chosen, and the LORD will not answer. The people refuse to listen: “No! But there shall be a king over us, that we also may be like all the nations, and that our king may judge us and go out before us and fight our battles” (vv. 19-20). The LORD tells Samuel to give them a king.

This is the hinge of the book: the end of the judges and the beginning of the kings. The issue is not whether God would ever give Israel a king, for He had promised kings to Abraham and Jacob (Genesis 17:6; 35:11) and made provision for one in the law (Deuteronomy 17:14-20). The issue is what kind of king they wanted and why. They asked for a king to replace the LORD who had just thundered against the Philistines for them (7:10), a king who would make them “like all the nations.” The answer to their request runs through Saul, then David, and finally to the King who is everything they needed and nothing they feared: the Son of David, who “came not to be served but to serve, and to give his life as a ransom for many” (Mark 10:45).

Points for discussion

vv. 1–3

Samuel’s sons

The chapter opens with an echo that is hard to miss: as Eli’s sons corrupted the priesthood, Samuel’s sons corrupt the judgeship, taking bribes and perverting justice, the very things the law forbade judges (Deuteronomy 16:19). Scripture does not rebuke Samuel the way it rebuked Eli, and it does not say why his sons went wrong. That restraint matters. Godly parents may have children who stray, and a child’s sin is not always a verdict on the parent (Ezekiel 18:20). Yet the elders’ complaint was true, and Samuel seems not to have removed them. Even the best leaders are flawed, which is part of the chapter’s point.

For discussion

How should we think about faithful parents whose grown children turn away? What comfort and what caution do Ezekiel 18:20 and Proverbs 22:6 (a proverb, not a guarantee) give?

vv. 4–9

What was wrong with the request?

Readers have long asked this, since Deuteronomy 17:14-15 anticipates Israel saying, “I will set a king over me, like all the nations that are around me,” and permits a king “whom the LORD your God will choose.” Some read 1 Samuel as opposed to kingship itself, pointing to Gideon’s refusal (“the LORD will rule over you,” Judges 8:23) and Hosea 13:11 (“I gave you a king in my anger”). Others read it as rejecting not kingship but this request: its motive, to be like the nations; its timing, while the LORD was fighting for them; and its manner, a demand rather than a petition. This commentary reads it the second way, because God had promised kings from Abraham’s line, would choose David as a man after His heart, and would promise David an everlasting throne. The sin was in wanting a king instead of the LORD rather than a king under Him: “they have rejected me from being king over them” (v. 7).

vv. 10–18

He will take

Samuel’s warning turns on one verb, repeated six times: “he will take” (vv. 11, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17). Sons, daughters, fields, a tenth of the harvest and flocks, servants, donkeys, and finally the people themselves: “you shall be his slaves.” This tenth is a royal tax, not the tithe given to the LORD. The warning is not that all government is evil, but that a king “like all the nations” governs by taking. Solomon would later prove the warning true (1 Kings 12:4). The deepest note is v. 18: “you will cry out because of your king, whom you have chosen for yourselves.” Freedom from God does not end in freedom.

For discussion

Samuel described the king Israel wanted as one who takes. Read Mark 10:42-45. How is Jesus’ kingship the exact opposite?

vv. 19–22

Like all the nations

The people’s answer gives away their heart: they want to be “like all the nations,” and they want a king to “go out before us and fight our battles” (v. 20). But that is what the LORD had just done at Mizpah (7:10). They wanted a visible king they could see in front of the army, rather than an invisible King they had to trust. God gives them what they ask, and Psalm 106:15 shows how solemn that can be: “he gave them what they asked, but sent a wasting disease among them.” Sometimes God’s judgment is to let us have our way. Yet even here He does not abandon them: He will choose the king, He will warn him, and through this very kingship He will bring David and, from David, Christ.

Threads across the chapter

  • Ways. Samuel’s sons do not walk in his ways (vv. 3, 5), and Samuel describes the ways of the king (vv. 9, 11).

  • The voice. The LORD tells Samuel three times to obey the people’s voice (vv. 7, 9, 22), while the people refuse to obey Samuel’s voice (v. 19).

  • Judging. Corrupt sons judge (vv. 1-3), the people ask for a king “to judge us” (vv. 5-6, 20), and the LORD who truly judges is the one rejected (v. 7).

  • Crying out. Israel once cried out and the LORD answered (7:8-9); now Samuel warns of a day when they will cry out because of their king and He will not answer (v. 18).

Key words

8:5–7
מֶלֶךְ melekh“King”; the title the people want for a man, and the LORD’s own title as Israel’s King (v. 7)
8:9, 11
מִשְׁפָּט mishpat“Ways” (of the king); justice, custom or right, the same word for the “rights and duties of the kingship” Samuel writes down (10:25)
8:11–17
לָקַח laqach“Take”; the verb that sums up a king like the nations

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Chapter 7 ended with the LORD thundering for Israel and Samuel judging faithfully. Why is it striking that chapter 8 begins with a demand for a king?

  2. 2

    Deuteronomy 17 allowed for a king. What exactly was wrong with Israel’s request?

  3. 3

    Samuel warned that the king would “take.” Where do people today look for security in something that will finally take more than it gives?

  4. 4

    Have you ever wanted to be “like all the nations” in a way that meant trusting God less? What did it cost?

  5. 5

    How does Jesus fulfill Israel’s real need for a king while being the very opposite of the king Samuel warned against?

My notes