1 Samuel · Historical Books

1 Samuel 28

Facing the Philistines, terrified Saul consults a medium at Endor and hears Samuel foretell his doom.

28:6

“And when Saul inquired of the LORD, the LORD did not answer him, either by dreams, or by Urim, or by prophets.”

1 Samuel 28:6, ESV

The chapter at a glance

  1. 1–2David with AchishDavid is trapped by his own deception
  2. 3–7Saul’s terror and God’s silenceThe king who banished mediums seeks one
  3. 8–14The woman at En-dorSaul in disguise asks for Samuel
  4. 15–19Samuel’s verdictThe judgment already given is confirmed
  5. 20–25The last mealSaul eats and goes out into the night

The chapter in brief

The Philistines gather for war, and Achish tells David he will march with them; David answers ambiguously, and Achish makes him his bodyguard. The narrator recalls that Samuel is dead and that Saul had put the mediums and necromancers out of the land. The Philistines camp at Shunem and Saul at Gilboa, and when Saul sees their army his heart trembles. He inquires of the LORD, but the LORD does not answer by dreams, by Urim, or by prophets. So Saul asks for a woman who is a medium, and his servants name one at En-dor. He disguises himself and goes by night, swears to her by the LORD that she will not be punished, and asks her to bring up Samuel. When she sees Samuel she cries out, recognizing Saul. She describes “a god coming up out of the earth,” an old man wrapped in a robe, and Saul bows down. Samuel asks why he has been disturbed and then repeats the LORD’s verdict: the kingdom is torn from Saul and given to David, because he did not obey the LORD against Amalek; Israel will be given into the Philistines’ hand, and tomorrow Saul and his sons will be with Samuel. Saul falls full length in fear. The woman and his servants urge him to eat, and she kills a fattened calf and bakes bread, and they go away into the night.

This is the darkest night of Saul’s life. He has silenced the voices God gave: he killed the priests who carried the ephod (22:18), Samuel is dead, and the prophet Gad counsels David, not Saul (22:5). When God is silent he turns to what God had forbidden (Deuteronomy 18:10-12), and he hears only the same Word he had already been told (15:28). The chapter points us to Christ by contrast. God’s people are not to seek the dead for the living (Isaiah 8:19), because God has spoken finally “by his Son” (Hebrews 1:2), and the One who truly came back from the dead is Jesus Himself, whose Word we already have. As Jesus said, those who will not hear Moses and the Prophets will not be convinced “if someone should rise from the dead” (Luke 16:31).

Points for discussion

vv. 1–2

David’s ambiguous answer

“Very well, you shall know what your servant can do” (v. 2). Achish hears loyalty; the reader wonders what David means. His deception in chapter 27 has led him here: marching with Israel’s enemies against his own people. The narrator leaves the question open and turns to Saul, and chapter 29 will show how God gets David out.

vv. 3–7

Why God was silent

God’s silence was not arbitrary. Dreams, Urim, and prophets were the ordinary means of guidance, and Saul had cut himself off from each one. The Urim belonged with the priestly ephod, and Saul had slaughtered the priests of Nob while Abiathar escaped with the ephod to David (22:18-20; 23:6). Samuel had already given the LORD’s Word, and Saul had refused it (15:23-28). Proverbs warns that those who refuse wisdom will call and not be answered (Proverbs 1:24-28). When God’s Word has been rejected, the answer is not to seek another voice, but to return to the Word already given.

vv. 3, 7–10

The occult forbidden

The law is plain: “There shall not be found among you anyone who... practices divination... or a medium or a necromancer or one who inquires of the dead, for whoever does these things is an abomination to the LORD” (Deuteronomy 18:10-12; compare Leviticus 19:31). Saul had once enforced this law (v. 3). Now he swears “by the LORD” that a medium will not be punished for breaking the LORD’s law (v. 10), and 1 Chronicles 10:13 names this as part of why he died: he “consulted a medium, seeking guidance.” The prohibition still stands for God’s people: séances, spiritualism, fortune-telling, horoscopes, and any attempt to contact the dead or gain hidden knowledge apart from God are forbidden, not because they are always fake, but because they seek another lord. Isaiah’s question answers every generation: “should not a people inquire of their God? Should they inquire of the dead on behalf of the living?” (Isaiah 8:19).

vv. 11–19

Was it really Samuel?

Faithful readers have long differed. Some hold that God Himself, in judgment, allowed Samuel to appear and speak, apart from the medium’s arts. Their reasons: the narrator says plainly “the woman saw Samuel” and “Samuel said,” the woman cried out as if something happened that she did not expect or control, and the message was a true prophecy that came to pass the next day. Others have held that an evil spirit impersonated Samuel, since God would not honor a forbidden practice and the dead are not at the call of the living; they read the narrator as describing the scene as it appeared to those present. A third view holds that the woman staged it, noting that Saul himself saw nothing and relied on her description (vv. 13-14). Each view is held by faithful readers. This commentary leans, loosely, toward the first reading, because the narrator’s own words call the figure Samuel and the prophecy proved true, and it would not press that lean on anyone. On any reading the main point stands: the medium had no power over God’s prophet, the encounter gave Saul no help, and Samuel’s message was only the Word the LORD had already spoken.

For discussion

Why does the narrator include the medium’s “I see a god coming up out of the earth” (v. 13)? What might that suggest about what she saw and how much she understood?

v. 19

“Tomorrow you... shall be with me”

Samuel’s words mean that Saul and his sons will die and join him among the dead. They do not settle anyone’s eternal state; faithful Jonathan is included in the same sentence. Readers should not build a doctrine of the afterlife from a chapter of judgment at a medium’s house. The New Testament speaks more clearly: believers who die “depart and be with Christ, for that is far better” (Philippians 1:23).

vv. 20–25

The last meal

The woman sees Saul’s terror and shows him real kindness: she kills her fattened calf and bakes bread for a doomed king. The narrator honors the kindness without approving the trade. Saul eats, rises, and goes out “that night,” his last night. A word for any grieving reader: the longing to speak with someone we have lost is deeply human, and God does not despise it. But the comfort He gives is not contact with the dead; it is the risen Christ, through whom “God will bring with him those who have fallen asleep” (1 Thessalonians 4:14), so that we “may not grieve as others do who have no hope” (1 Thessalonians 4:13).

Threads across the chapter

  • Silenced voices. Samuel is dead (v. 3), the priests are dead, and God does not answer (v. 6), so Saul turns to a forbidden voice (v. 7).

  • The law kept and broken. Saul banished mediums (vv. 3, 9) and then consults one, swearing by the LORD to protect her (v. 10).

  • The same Word again. Samuel repeats the verdict of 15:28 (vv. 17-18); seeking another voice only confirmed the Word already given.

  • Darkness. Saul comes by night (v. 8) and leaves “that night” (v. 25), the last night of his reign.

Key words

28:3, 7–8
אוֹב 'ov“Medium”; one who claims to consult spirits of the dead, forbidden in Deuteronomy 18:11
28:3, 9
יִדְּעֹנִי yidde'oni“Necromancer,” a “knowing one”; one who claims hidden knowledge from the dead
28:13
אֱלֹהִים elohim“A god”; the usual word for God, here used by the medium of a spirit being from the realm of the dead; it says nothing of Samuel being divine
28:6
אוּרִים urim“Urim”; the priestly means of inquiry kept with the ephod, which had gone with Abiathar to David

Cross-references

Questions for your group

  1. 1

    Why does the narrator remind us here that Samuel had died and that Saul had banished the mediums?

  2. 2

    What had Saul done, over the years, that left him with no answer from God?

  3. 3

    Why does God forbid seeking the dead or hidden knowledge, and what modern forms does that temptation take?

  4. 4

    Faithful readers differ on whether Samuel truly appeared. Why does the chapter’s main lesson hold on any reading?

  5. 5

    How does the hope of the resurrection in Christ answer the grief that might draw someone to a medium?

My notes